Live data from Hacker News

Discussion: GCP, AWS and Azure

news.ycombinator.com

1–10 of 10 posts

Re: Discussion: GCP, AWS and Azure

#2
The three have a lot in common, with key differentiators e.g. the backbone connectivity of GCP is far different than that of AWS.

What worked for me is that I went deep into one of them, then uses this resource to 'map' what I learned on GCP to AWS: https://cloud.google.com/docs/compare/aws (use the table mid way down the article), and this gave me a great framework on which to build my AWS knowledge.

A similar table exists for Azure (https://cloud.google.com/docs/compare/azure)

Re: Discussion: GCP, AWS and Azure

#5
Aws, azure, gcp by market share. We went GCP, overall it's not moving as fast as the others but they are working on that. The services are extremely stable. If you use the PaaS products by cautious, Google's product management has gaps. Their Api gateway portfolio is a mess. I just heard Dialogflow now has a new product called CX, not backwards compatible and no port options either.

Re: Discussion: GCP, AWS and Azure

#6
Whats your goals? Are you looking to make a technology decision for a product, or are you looking for one to learn to help you get a job?

If you're looking for a job, AWS has the largest market share (33%), followed by Azure (19%), and GCP (9%).

If you're looking for a place to host your product, you probably can't go wrong with either of the three, but there are some minor considerations...

Personally, I would consider GCP a little more risky long term. There was a report last year about Google considering existing the cloud business and setting a goal to be a top two player by 2023. Since this seems unlikely, what then? Google has some anti-trust concerns, but the bigger anti-trust concern is probably Amazon. There is a non-zero chance that AWS gets split out from Amazon at some point.

Finally, I don't really know GCP that well, but it's my understanding it's a little easier to manage for smaller teams. I believe AWS is considered IAAS while GCP is more PAAS (although the lines get blurred depending on product). In my experience, for companies using AWS... having a DevOps team that smooths over the rough edges of AWS and provides tooling on top of AWS warts has been a requirement.

I have no experience with Azure, but I can't see Google out performing Microsoft in any world as long as MSFT has .NET stack.

Re: Discussion: GCP, AWS and Azure

#9
post #6

Whats your goals? Are you looking to make a technology decision for a product, or are you looking for one to learn to help you get a job? If you're looking for a job, AWS has the largest market share (33%), followed by Azure (19%), and GCP (9%). If you're looking for a place to host your product, you probably can't go wrong with either of the three, but there are some minor considerations... Personally, I would consi…

I would disagree with the IaaS and PaaS distinction with AWS and GCP. Both have many many different services. They both provide an IaaS (compute instance) service and they both have a PaaS offering, among many others. Azure is in the same boat as well.

Re: Discussion: GCP, AWS and Azure

#10
post #6

Whats your goals? Are you looking to make a technology decision for a product, or are you looking for one to learn to help you get a job? If you're looking for a job, AWS has the largest market share (33%), followed by Azure (19%), and GCP (9%). If you're looking for a place to host your product, you probably can't go wrong with either of the three, but there are some minor considerations... Personally, I would consi…

> I believe AWS is considered IAAS while GCP is more PAAS

There was a time when AWS had an IaaS and no PaaS and Google has a PaaS but no IaaS, but that's long (in public cloud offerings time) past.