Live data from Hacker News

Dear Google: please let me ban sites from results

news.ycombinator.com

1–10 of 217 posts

Dear Google: please let me ban sites from results

#1
Given the current high-ranking thread about spammy sites in Google results, it strikes me that a very simple solution would be to let logged-in users blacklist sites.

Bam, no more wareseeker or efreedom.

This would solve a lot of people's complaints in one fell swoop.

There are greasemonkey etc. scripts to do this, but they're tied to a single browser on a single machine. A global filter (like in gmail) would be so much more useful.

Would this be particularly hard to do?

Re: Dear Google: please let me ban sites from results

#6
post #2

In the interim, you can do your searches by adding -wareseeker -efreedom to the search string.

I've discovered you can also set up a Custom Search Engine, with no included sites (default to everything), and specifically exclude the sites you don't want. Then do all your searches through this.

http://www.google.com/cse/

Usability-wise, though, it's not nearly as much use as a 'ban' button next to each result would be. But it shows Google already have the infrastructure and code that would allow this -- they just need to make it instant to use.

EDIT: The other downside of this is you lose a load of bells & whistles, e.g. previews, "pages from the UK" (without typing), icons for images/news/etc. Time will tell if I miss those.

Re: Dear Google: please let me ban sites from results

#7
Yes that would be good. They could then look at the number of people blocking certain domains and de-weight them in the global results.

Traditionally google seem against human powered editing (as this would be), but I think as the black hat SEOs run rings around them, its needed badly.

Re: Dear Google: please let me ban sites from results

#8
post #2

In the interim, you can do your searches by adding -wareseeker -efreedom to the search string.

I've discovered you can also set up a Custom Search Engine, with no included sites (default to everything), and specifically exclude the sites you don't want. Then do all your searches through this. http://www.google.com/cse/ Usability-wise, though, it's not nearly as much use as a 'ban' button next to each result would be. But it shows Google already have the infrastructure and code that would allow this -- they jus…

But its not free, right ?

Re: Dear Google: please let me ban sites from results

#9
post #3

And no more bloody experts-exchange...

I honestly don't mind that site - about half the time I search for an issue, I find it's been resolved by someone over at Experts Exchange.

Do people realise that if Google is your referrer, you can scroll all the way down and see the solutions to the question?

Re: Dear Google: please let me ban sites from results

#10
post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I've discovered you can also set up a Custom Search Engine, with no included sites (default to everything), and specifically exclude the sites you don't want. Then do all your searches through this. http://www.google.com/cse/ Usability-wise, though, it's not nearly as much use as a 'ban' button next to each result would be. But it shows Google already have the infrastructure and code that would allow this -- they jus…

But its not free, right ?

It is free.
Post reply on HN