Live data from Hacker News

US strikes $1.2B deal to pay German firm to halt offshore wind projects

bbc.com

951–954 of 954 posts

Re: US strikes $1.2B deal to pay German firm to halt offshore wind projects

#951

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Batteries. Or pumped storage. Or lifting a really heavy thing and letting it fall slowly. Or retaining an amount of fossil fuel capacity to be turned on during peak consumption and sun and wind dips while still focusing on renewables and storage with the goal to reduce the duty cycle of peaker plants to zero.

> Or lifting a really heavy thing and letting it fall slowly. I challenge you to run the numbers on this. Or at least read or watch someone who has. Whenever you’re certain you know the answer, it behooves to try to prove yourself wrong. Unsurprisingly, gravity is an extraordinarily weak force. It merely appears otherwise because the total mass of the Earth is literally astronomical at around the 5.9722×10^24 kg mark…

I’m powered by the James Bay project and live about three hours from Niagara Falls, so I’m a believer in hydro.

Niagara Falls, to the unaware, uses pumped hydro during night and off-season to account for power dips for when tourists want to look at the waterfall.

For the chemical batteries section, that’s an endorsement: Australia built a system that can handle grid-scale charge and discharge! At this point it’s a matter of buying more batteries and sticking them in, a resourcing problem rather than an engineering one.

Re: US strikes $1.2B deal to pay German firm to halt offshore wind projects

#952

Earlier quoted context omitted.

your neighbors property is not yours either, and hmm, I wonder if datacenters and wind turbines have anything in common?

Speak plainly. You’re making no sense whatsoever.

I'm sorry you were unable to grasp the point, which was that both are loud, and both can can have a impact even if located on an adjacent property. I hope that clears it up for you, but, as an aside, I suggest that instead of trying to make demands of people that you simply ask for clarification if you are have difficulty understanding something

Re: US strikes $1.2B deal to pay German firm to halt offshore wind projects

#953

Earlier quoted context omitted.

your neighbors property is not yours either, and hmm, I wonder if datacenters and wind turbines have anything in common?

Let’s go with what this is actually about, windmills. I lived next door to a farm with windmills on it and I actually found them mesmerizing and nice to look at. Also a fun talking point with people visiting, but if we all had them in our backyard I suppose that novelty would wear off. So tl;dr: I would absolutely want to have windmills as my neighbours again. Datacenter not so much, but they are also substantially b…

they are both noisy

Re: US strikes $1.2B deal to pay German firm to halt offshore wind projects

#954

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Speak plainly. You’re making no sense whatsoever.

I'm sorry you were unable to grasp the point, which was that both are loud, and both can can have a impact even if located on an adjacent property. I hope that clears it up for you, but, as an aside, I suggest that instead of trying to make demands of people that you simply ask for clarification if you are have difficulty understanding something

That does not counter my point at all. There's a gaping maw between "a person's back garden" and "The North Sea." To demonstrate the difference to yourself, look up "Trump International Golf Links Aberdeen" and "Aberdeen Bay Wind Farm" on Google Maps and tell me the gap, in miles, between the two properties.

Once you've done that, think about the analogy you want to draw and ask it. Because your current analogy is fucking idiotic.

Post reply on HN