Live data from Hacker News

U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native American reservation

reuters.com

921–930 of 1001 posts

Re: U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native American reservation

#921
post #97

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It is perverse, but there is a method to the madness. Some sentencing mitigations or parole decisions are based upon length of sentence. Someone who is given a 20 year sentence may be eligible for parole when, for example, 1/4 of the sentence has been served. By setting the sentence to a ridiculous length it is effectively denying any possibility for parole without directly stating that the sentence is to served with…

They already do this in LA. Get sentenced to 120 days in jail but due to overcrowding you’d do 5-10 days in jail. Soon local politicians will require you only to do 1% of jail time so you’ll be sentenced to a 100 years in jail for a misdemeanor. This already exists in the California bail system where you pay 1% of astronomically high bails (eg $60,000 bail for 1st time misdemeanor, like if they change a court date an…

[deleted]

Re: U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native American reservation

#922

We have to recognize how much we screwed over the Native Americans. We took away their prime land on the East coast. We gave them some shitty land in Oklahoma that we didn't think we would ever want. We made them walk there in the "Trail of Tears", and lots of them died along the way. Then we decided to screw them out of the land in Oklahoma after all, but didn't go though the process properly because we didn't think…

I find your use of "we" interesting because you clearly identify as part of the group that committed those acts hundreds of years ago. How long should a child be responsible for the crimes of their fathers? As an example, assume your father killed someone and stole $1000 dollars from them. You never knew about this didn't choose for him to do this but now someone is coming after you saying you must pay them $1000. Yo…

It's not just about the literal land and dollars stolen. That theft has contributed to the way that American society sets Native Americans up for failure and repression. That is a systemic inequality that is never too late to correct

Re: U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native American reservation

#923

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Many people came to the US long after the Trail of Tears. Are they responsible [...] Yes, the whole point of being citizens is taking responsibility collectively as a populace for the actions of the state. We collectively owe interest on the national debt. We still must abide by international treaties signed and ratified by long-dead representatives. We follow a constitution written long ago, and if we want to chan…

I have to disagree. No one chose to be citizens of the collective populace and state, they were born/forced into it since they were young. Try not to participate in the system by say not paying taxes or ignoring any law and you get locked up. Try to physically leave the system and at best you are at the mercy of another system. There was no choice where you are born. It is a collective agreement only by force.

Fine. If there's no choice then it doesn't matter, you are deemed responsible and that's it.

But you can't say "we collectively should decide we don't owe because we individually don't have choice". Either you are forced or you have choices.

Re: U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native American reservation

#925

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think use of regulated drugs is legal during a religious service https://www.pewforum.org/2006/02/21/supreme-court-rules-that... And, again I think, reservations are exempt from state laws/taxes and to certain extent able to make/enforce their own laws/taxes but they still need to follow federal laws.

The only way to stop our neverending war on drugs is a Constitutional amendment that guarantees every American the right to consume anything they want for any reason. In the next several decades there will be un unprecedented number of elderly Americans living below the poverty line with no pension and medical issues they can't afford to fix - euthanasia will become something of a nuclear option that they'll want ava…

Hahahahahahaha!

"The constitutional right for every American to eat anything they want for any reason"

Come on that's funny because of, you know, that other epidemic that'll be waiting if you come out of this one. The obesity one.

Re: U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native American reservation

#926

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The only way to stop our neverending war on drugs is a Constitutional amendment that guarantees every American the right to consume anything they want for any reason. In the next several decades there will be un unprecedented number of elderly Americans living below the poverty line with no pension and medical issues they can't afford to fix - euthanasia will become something of a nuclear option that they'll want ava…

Hahahahahahaha! "The constitutional right for every American to eat anything they want for any reason" Come on that's funny because of, you know, that other epidemic that'll be waiting if you come out of this one. The obesity one.

If methamphetamine is widely available, obesity wouldn't be an issue.

Re: U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native American reservation

#927
post #900

We have to recognize how much we screwed over the Native Americans. We took away their prime land on the East coast. We gave them some shitty land in Oklahoma that we didn't think we would ever want. We made them walk there in the "Trail of Tears", and lots of them died along the way. Then we decided to screw them out of the land in Oklahoma after all, but didn't go though the process properly because we didn't think…

> We have to recognize how much we screwed over the Native Americans. We took away their prime land on the East coast. We gave them some shitty land in Oklahoma that we didn't think we would ever want. We made them walk there in the "Trail of Tears", and lots of them died along the way. Then we decided to screw them out of the land in Oklahoma after all, but didn't go though the process properly because we didn't thi…

Are you describing yourself as European with a capital E?

Re: U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native American reservation

#928

Earlier quoted context omitted.

this particular law varies wildly by jurisdiction

Also by how quickly it is discovered/brought to court

Are there conditions on the effort made to revert back to normal? Example moving a fence is not the same as tearing down a 30 year old building crossing a property line.

Re: U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native American reservation

#930

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think use of regulated drugs is legal during a religious service https://www.pewforum.org/2006/02/21/supreme-court-rules-that... And, again I think, reservations are exempt from state laws/taxes and to certain extent able to make/enforce their own laws/taxes but they still need to follow federal laws.

The only way to stop our neverending war on drugs is a Constitutional amendment that guarantees every American the right to consume anything they want for any reason. In the next several decades there will be un unprecedented number of elderly Americans living below the poverty line with no pension and medical issues they can't afford to fix - euthanasia will become something of a nuclear option that they'll want ava…

If the federal government merely abided by the constitution and ended all of its activity in relation to the use and trade of drugs, that would go a long way in reducing the intensity of the War on Drugs and giving states space to legalize it.

Each state can decide its own approach, which I think is the appropriate principle for governance.

Post reply on HN