Live data from Hacker News

Mozilla may make Flash click-to-play by default in future Firefox

arstechnica.com

91–100 of 121 posts

Re: Mozilla may make Flash click-to-play by default in future Firefox

#91

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You say that now, but just wait until they're written in JS+Canvas and enormously more difficult to block.

Yeah, HTML5 YouTube has the significant disadvantage of autoplay.

There's nothing preventing you from blocking HTML5-video just like Flash can be blocked with add-ons today. Personally I use NoScript for that.

Re: Mozilla may make Flash click-to-play by default in future Firefox

#92
post #14

This is great, really, but I'd like to see something more aggressive: Non-foreground tabs should be completely suspended - plugins, JavaScript, media, you name it - unless they specifically request and are granted permission to run in the background.

I'm not sure I'd want that, but I would surely like background tabs getting throttled, similarly to background tasks on Android.

Not sure if that's feasible in firefox.

Re: Mozilla may make Flash click-to-play by default in future Firefox

#94

Earlier quoted context omitted.

To take care of the invisible Flash object problem, Firefox could copy what Chrome does for Java applets and have a bar pop up at the top of the whole page, asking if you want to allow Flash to run on the site in question.

Pandora uses jPlayer to play audio which has an invisible Flash component to play mp3s on browsers that don't support it. If Firefox requires 'click-to-play' on an on-screen piece of Flash to enable it, all sites using jPlayer to play mp3 simply will not work. And of course this doesn't just affect jPlayer, many other players use this technique. Much better -- as mistercow reasons -- to have a pop-up asking you if yo…

Doesn't Firefox support mp3?

Re: Mozilla may make Flash click-to-play by default in future Firefox

#95

For my money, they oughta make Canvas click-to-play as well, since the rendering speed in Firefox is unbelievably slow and the javascript behind it is so frequently written to hog up 100% of the CPU it's hard to even know what you're looking at if you accidentally stumble across an HTML5 page in Firefox, before your system grinds to a complete halt. It's funny how people blame Flash for slow websites when what they s…

Canvas doesn't play sound or suffer from buffer overflows.

Re: Mozilla may make Flash click-to-play by default in future Firefox

#96

Oh man, bad memories. I used to get so frustrated with Internet Explorer* for doing this about 7 years ago. I was young then, 12 or 13, and had just gotten Flash for my birthday. I know it had to be 2004 or 2005 because the version was Flash MX 2004. I was young enough and it was long enough ago that I think I was using Internet Explorer primarily, and got terrible frustrated when they started using this default clic…

I also remember this! I was designing flash programs on the rubbish school computers that still had IE6.

I think I ended up using something like this to bypass it: http://www.flashperfection.com/tutorials/Flash-ActiveX-Micro...

Re: Mozilla may make Flash click-to-play by default in future Firefox

#99

Oh man, bad memories. I used to get so frustrated with Internet Explorer* for doing this about 7 years ago. I was young then, 12 or 13, and had just gotten Flash for my birthday. I know it had to be 2004 or 2005 because the version was Flash MX 2004. I was young enough and it was long enough ago that I think I was using Internet Explorer primarily, and got terrible frustrated when they started using this default clic…

That was annoying. That IE feature still allowed the flash plugin to play though. You had to click on it first before you could interact with it.

Re: Mozilla may make Flash click-to-play by default in future Firefox

#100
Adobe has proven time and again that they cannot produce secure software. Down with Flash, and down with Reader. These two pieces of software seem to be responsible for millions of malware infections and thus tons of spam and fraud online.

The world would be a better place without these two Adobe products. Their /content production/ software is amazing, and they should just stick to that IMO.

Post reply on HN