Live data from Hacker News

EU aims to shift European arms industry to 'war economy mode'

reuters.com

81–90 of 189 posts

Re: EU aims to shift European arms industry to 'war economy mode'

#81

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Being "defence friendly" means also cultivating the mentality that lying in the trenches for your country/culture/values might be necessary. Forget arms industry or military budget as a percent of GDP. The main problem is that Europe lacks the fighting spirit (with some exceptions like Poland). Countries like Germany will fold / capitulate to any demands if they suffer thousands of casualties.

I lack fighting spirit, don't want to spend money for weapons and I'm not afraid of Russia (live in Germany). There is a lot of fear mongering. Ukraine should make a deal instead of sacrificing people without limits. So many people died, for loosing later. If they wait too long there won't be any deal.

> If they wait too long there won't be any deal.

There is no deal on the table, there never was. Putin wants them to surrender and more or less dissolve the army so he can take the rest without the fight.

Re: EU aims to shift European arms industry to 'war economy mode'

#82

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Finland faced way worse population odds in the Winter war, yet still managed to stop the Soviets. They had to concede some territory, but it was very far from a surrender.

[flagged]

When did Soviet troops parade in Helsinki? When did Finland join USSR as one of its republics? Because that's what would happen if Finland surrendered. Finland was part of Russian empire just 20-something years ago, Stalin wouldn't be happy with just sliver of the land unless he was forced to a compromise.

Re: EU aims to shift European arms industry to 'war economy mode'

#83
post #20

Sure, we will hire a few thousand contractors to form a network of committees and prepare multiple sustainability plans and guidelines for the next seven years. We will also declare war illegal and fine violators with 70% of their gdp. Whoever dares to challenge european sovereignty will be met with the collective wrath of our cookie prompts The EU is not only materially incapable of war mode (too many second rate ca…

>One of its members is occupied by a nato country, and hasn't been supported when threatened. Can you explain?

https://www.euronews.com/my-europe/2022/10/11/the-eus-tolera...

Re: EU aims to shift European arms industry to 'war economy mode'

#84
post #58

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That "peace deal" would have required that Ukraine permanently recognize Russian sovereignty over Crimea and the Donbas (on top of other concessions). This is why Russia is called "expansionist". Because it likes to expand its territory. Before Boris arrived to scupper it. That's not what happened. I know you read some snippet somewhere that made it sound like that's what happened. But simply put, you're being played…

Naftali Bennett (former Israeli premier): https://www.hungarianconservative.com/articles/current/russi... Watch the interview if you don't like the source. Ukrainian negotiator David Arahamiya: https://europeanconservative.com/articles/news/official-john... Video here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6lt4E0DiJts More than snippets

Every link of yours is a well-known spin. For example, Bennett has clarified that his words have been taken out of context and misrepresented, and Arahamiya has said that no-one on Ukrainian side belived that Russian peace plan was genuine and not a stalling tactic.

Perhaps it would be a good idea to switch to sites that don't have "conservative" in their URL.

Re: EU aims to shift European arms industry to 'war economy mode'

#85

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Being "defence friendly" means also cultivating the mentality that lying in the trenches for your country/culture/values might be necessary. Forget arms industry or military budget as a percent of GDP. The main problem is that Europe lacks the fighting spirit (with some exceptions like Poland). Countries like Germany will fold / capitulate to any demands if they suffer thousands of casualties.

I lack fighting spirit, don't want to spend money for weapons and I'm not afraid of Russia (live in Germany). There is a lot of fear mongering. Ukraine should make a deal instead of sacrificing people without limits. So many people died, for loosing later. If they wait too long there won't be any deal.

> (live in Germany)

East or West? :)

Re: EU aims to shift European arms industry to 'war economy mode'

#86

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This is a lie

[flagged]

> There is quite a bit of evidence

No, there isn't, the whole conspiracy theory lies on a few sentences taken out of context. Spend an hour vetting sources and you'll find that it's a Russian PR spin without any substance.

Anyone can "prove" with public statements from top officials that the US goverment is run by aliens from outer space, if they can take three sentences of their choice out of context and freely ignore everything else.

Re: EU aims to shift European arms industry to 'war economy mode'

#87
post #32
post #4

There was an incredibly stubborn post-Cold War "end of history" complacency in Europe that really should have ended after the annexation of Crimea in 2014. Instead it lasted until the full invasion in 2022. What's been starkly revealed since is that Europe is woefully unprepared to respond to any kind of aggression, and aside from France's nuclear weapons, wholly reliant on America. At some point you have to get seri…

That's not complacency, that's a feature. The key to peace in Europe is the unified free trade zone on one hand, but on the other it's also disarmament while relying on NATO. Besides putting territorial questions aside, one of the main requirements of joining NATO was to discontinue the draft! The entire security failure is by design, one that has been made a long time ago when the US force was way more capable and t…

Are you sure? Estonia still has compulsory defense forces draft of 8 or 11 months for young men.

Re: EU aims to shift European arms industry to 'war economy mode'

#88
post #4

There was an incredibly stubborn post-Cold War "end of history" complacency in Europe that really should have ended after the annexation of Crimea in 2014. Instead it lasted until the full invasion in 2022. What's been starkly revealed since is that Europe is woefully unprepared to respond to any kind of aggression, and aside from France's nuclear weapons, wholly reliant on America. At some point you have to get seri…

Lol, what ended exactly?

Re: EU aims to shift European arms industry to 'war economy mode'

#89

Earlier quoted context omitted.

And after you give up on Ukraine what's next? Georgia? Moldova? Estonia? Poland? Lithuania? More? They're all fair game for Russia are they? Russia will find your submissiveness very helpful.

[flagged]

Russian deals don't look like what reasonable people think they should look like. They are only ever made to serve propaganda needs, you have fallen for it.

Re: EU aims to shift European arms industry to 'war economy mode'

#90
post #84

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Naftali Bennett (former Israeli premier): https://www.hungarianconservative.com/articles/current/russi... Watch the interview if you don't like the source. Ukrainian negotiator David Arahamiya: https://europeanconservative.com/articles/news/official-john... Video here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6lt4E0DiJts More than snippets

Every link of yours is a well-known spin. For example, Bennett has clarified that his words have been taken out of context and misrepresented, and Arahamiya has said that no-one on Ukrainian side belived that Russian peace plan was genuine and not a stalling tactic. Perhaps it would be a good idea to switch to sites that don't have "conservative" in their URL.

"Clarified" -- yes he walked it back under intense pressure. His words were in a long podcast you can listen to.
Post reply on HN