Live data from Hacker News

Amazon One – Palm recognition for Amazon Go

blog.aboutamazon.com

81–90 of 151 posts

Re: Amazon One – Palm recognition for Amazon Go

#81
post #28

Researcher in biometrics working on contactless palm/finger recognition here. 1) A new innovation ok. People have been doing that for more than a decade, my group included. 2) Given the sensors look, it's almost certainly near infrared (NIR) camera, probably 850nm illumination and the dark surface is a NIR filter. 3) It certainly capture a mix between palm veins (850nm quite absorbed by de-oxygenated hemoglobin) and…

5) Are there any anti-spoofing measures already out there? It sounds like if there are, they can be easily bypassed...

Re: Amazon One – Palm recognition for Amazon Go

#82

Will this service have a "forget me" button? I think this should be the first question addressed in their FAQ.

It's not the first question addressed in the FAQ, but there is this answer:

"Yes, you can request to delete data associated with Amazon One through the device itself or via the online customer portal at one.amazon.com. We believe customers should always be in complete control of when and where they use the service, and we designed Amazon One with this in mind."

Perhaps, as the sibling comment suggests, this was an architectural decision made based on the requirements for operating in the EU.

Re: Amazon One – Palm recognition for Amazon Go

#83
post #78
post #68

This is a continuation of Amazon's remove all inconvenience strategy. And it'll work. You're waving your hand and walking through now, no more scanning, no more opening up an app, no more tinkering with your phone. By chipping away at each of these friction points, no manner how minor, their moat grows and customers will notice a difference between an Amazon retail store vs. a competitor's.

What I think is interesting is that I suspect they’ll eagerly license this to competitor stores. A palm reader does not turn your local Safeway into Amazon Go, and they know that. Having a slice of every point of sale could be huge; imagine how much better this is than having to use FaceID during a pandemic. (Tap tap, pin, pin, tap is a LOT more friction than “hover.”) I’d pay for it if I ran a retail store. I wonder…

"I wonder if Amazon will ever compete with..." Yes has to be the assumption at this point

Re: Amazon One – Palm recognition for Amazon Go

#84

Interesting time to launch a product that involves everybody touching something.

FTA: It’s contactless.

Is that your professional medical opinion, Dr. Handshake?

More seriously, how successful do you think people will be at holding their palm above the device at a close enough distance for an accurate reading?

Re: Amazon One – Palm recognition for Amazon Go

#85
post #61

My college uses these to control entrance to the dining halls. The technology has been around for years and it works consistently and effectively. They want you to think this is something highly innovative but I’m pretty sure they’re just licensing already existing palm scanners.

Were those dining hall scanners using a palm-on-glass technology, or mid-air like what Amazon is showing?

Mid-air, exactly like Amazon's

Re: Amazon One – Palm recognition for Amazon Go

#86
post #78

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What I think is interesting is that I suspect they’ll eagerly license this to competitor stores. A palm reader does not turn your local Safeway into Amazon Go, and they know that. Having a slice of every point of sale could be huge; imagine how much better this is than having to use FaceID during a pandemic. (Tap tap, pin, pin, tap is a LOT more friction than “hover.”) I’d pay for it if I ran a retail store. I wonder…

"I wonder if Amazon will ever compete with..." Yes has to be the assumption at this point

Visa can't be bothered to innovate. 90% of what Amazon has done should have been done by industry incumbents.

Re: Amazon One – Palm recognition for Amazon Go

#87

Earlier quoted context omitted.

"I wonder if Amazon will ever compete with..." Yes has to be the assumption at this point

Visa can't be bothered to innovate. 90% of what Amazon has done should have been done by industry incumbents.

Well hopefully amazon will push enough of them to the brink of extinction that they to will innovate or suffer the fate of negative selective pressure.

Re: Amazon One – Palm recognition for Amazon Go

#89
post #78
post #68

This is a continuation of Amazon's remove all inconvenience strategy. And it'll work. You're waving your hand and walking through now, no more scanning, no more opening up an app, no more tinkering with your phone. By chipping away at each of these friction points, no manner how minor, their moat grows and customers will notice a difference between an Amazon retail store vs. a competitor's.

What I think is interesting is that I suspect they’ll eagerly license this to competitor stores. A palm reader does not turn your local Safeway into Amazon Go, and they know that. Having a slice of every point of sale could be huge; imagine how much better this is than having to use FaceID during a pandemic. (Tap tap, pin, pin, tap is a LOT more friction than “hover.”) I’d pay for it if I ran a retail store. I wonder…

The biggest competitors will never license something like this. They'd be basically giving (or creating an untenable risk of giving) their customer data over to Amazon.

"But AWS etc etc.." Trust me, the retail landscape is very different. Source: I work in it

Re: Amazon One – Palm recognition for Amazon Go

#90
post #74

So far what Apple and other companies did is to keep the biometric auth tied to the device and not let leak out. Now Amazon is saying leaking it is the feature. They are using the hand as the identifier, so the biometric id is what is used to identify a person, not an email address, not a random number or a handle. The biometric data that cannot be changed ever is the identifier. It's very troubling. - The privacy an…

This is the door you didn't hope was opened? So many other more terrible doors are open. Not saying this is great. But look at what social media is doing to the social fabric. This is just shopping.
Post reply on HN