Live data from Hacker News

My mom and dad’s house might explode, but Comcast wants its cable box back

sethclifford.me

71–75 of 75 posts

Re: My mom and dad’s house might explode, but Comcast wants its cable box back

#71
post #4

I know this is going to be unpopular, but... Comcast is a business, and their goal is to make ever increasing profit. Yes it's horrible your family and hundreds of others lost everything due to a natural disaster, but that's not Comcast's fault or problem. When you signed up for service from them, I'll bet it's in the fine print that you are responsible for returning the cable box. If it got stolen, that's not Comcas…

The reality of things is that there are no rules.

Re: My mom and dad’s house might explode, but Comcast wants its cable box back

#72
post #57

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Sure, and the credit bureaus will not side with you. Because you actually do owe the debt.

The credit bureaus have sided with me every time I've made a dispute.

really? I did not even know this was a thing? do you have examples? can i pm?

Re: My mom and dad’s house might explode, but Comcast wants its cable box back

#73
post #66

I posted this because while I was not affected by Sandy, I did lose my apartment to a fire a few years ago and had to deal with the same thing from Direct TV. I got send to collections for the cost of the satellite, the receivers, and the failure to maintain the last part of the contract even though I was homeless. I am a business person and I understand that profitability is the bottom line, but these companies make…

On the other hand, imagine the effort Comcast would have to make to verify each such claim. If they don't verify such claims, I bet they will get at least a hundred scammers for every real claim, once their leniency becomes known. In this case, the only thing I see is that this may not be the best moment to bring that message, but I also wonder how anybody would even think of giving Comcast a call so short after this…

haha, that was my first thought too. But thinking back, I was on the phone within a day or two... I guess we all deal with stress differently.

"Honey, the house is on fire..."

"I better call Comcast and cancel internet for the winter."

Re: My mom and dad’s house might explode, but Comcast wants its cable box back

#74
Curiously, why in the world wouldn't Comcast have insurance on equipment the rent out? Sure, primary coverage may/should be with the renter, but why in the world won't they have secondary coverage in the event of total loss (including death of the renter, etc.)

Could it simply be that at the rates they charge, a box is easily paid off in a couple of years, and any additional rental fees are pure profit?

Re: My mom and dad’s house might explode, but Comcast wants its cable box back

#75

This isn't the first time something like this has happened: http://www.wsfa.com/Global/story.asp?S=14672228 You would think that would have a procedure in place to address these types of situations, for good PR at least.

Exactly. The country experiences multiple such natural disasters each year, although most are much more localized.

Where it the/a reasonable policy for dealing with them?

Surely, this is an area where a little application of oft vaunted "best practices" might actually be appropriate?

(Local crews and crew management should be able to at least approximately validate the legitimacy of such claimed circumstances.)

Post reply on HN