Live data from Hacker News

Overloaded: Is there simply too much culture?

theguardian.com

71–80 of 110 posts

Re: Overloaded: Is there simply too much culture?

#71
post #43

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Related to this, I wonder how the average age of HN readership has changed over time. My guess is it has shifted towards an older audience continually since the beginning. To that end what new things are "against the order of things" today.

At 42 I'm still pretty hip to the fun of change.

Said using lingo older than yourself.

Re: Overloaded: Is there simply too much culture?

#72

Earlier quoted context omitted.

but why? I already have the title to my house

All other examples of things being done electronically that were done physically go here.

Property ownership is already recorded electronically.

Re: Overloaded: Is there simply too much culture?

#73
post #58
post #4

It's just one of the costs of individualism. With so much to consume, instant personal choice, and no consistent conduit, there is little chance we have all seen the same stuff. A way around it is explicitly discussing the issue with mates. I keep some close friends who keep in close parity because we all understand that if we don't all play the same game we will end up playing nothing together. Rando internet friend…

What do you mean by individualism in this context?

Individualism in the sense that gives us the framework to find our own paths and explore what we personally want from life in a context that can transcend the immediate communities we live in.

One of the downsides is that we don't have to be a big part of those communities anymore, especially with the internet. This results in more fractured cultural diaspora, even amongst people from the same town. I've rarely watched, listened or enjoyed anything my co-workers have because we can select from the near infinite library of the internet. Previously this wasn't an issue even with individualism, because everyone had to watch the same few TV channels and listen to the same few radio stations.

I think it's amazing how diverse the world has become, how niche media can be, and how free we all are to explore what we want from life. But that's just one of the costs.

Re: Overloaded: Is there simply too much culture?

#74

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This does feel like my opinion on NFTs / Cryptocoins.

Extend the idea of NFTs to actual registered ownership of a thing you care about, like the title of your house, or your rental agreement, rather than a fucking pixelated jpg a child would be ashamed of, and it might look like something a bit more representative of a worthwhile future.

> the title of your house

This is the ultimate example of where you want a centralised database run by the state. Preferably properly "cadastral", so you can drop a coordinate pin anywhere and look up the owner.

Re: Overloaded: Is there simply too much culture?

#75

"Too many books" was apparently a problem already 2000 years ago; here's Seneca advising his friend against it, in his letter-2: [quote] Be careful, though, about your reading in many authors and every type of book. It may be that there is something wayward and unstable in it. You must stay with a limited number of writers and be fed by them if you mean to derive anything that will dwell reliably with you. One who is…

This is a sentiment that resonates strongly with me. I've tried to keep up with the latest - whether it's books, movies, or programming libraries - and inevitably, I spread my attention too thin and learn too little about too much.

Now, I've swung the other direction, and begun really dedicating my attention to a narrow set of things in just about every facet of my life.

It's... an interesting difference.

Re: Overloaded: Is there simply too much culture?

#76

This reminds me of a Douglas Adams quote - although he was talking about technology, it seems appropriate here also :) “I've come up with a set of rules that describe our reactions to technologies: 1. Anything that is in the world when you’re born is normal and ordinary and is just a natural part of the way the world works. 2. Anything that's invented between when you’re fifteen and thirty-five is new and exciting an…

I've actually turned on a number of things invented before I was 35. Including a lot of what my career is in.

Re: Overloaded: Is there simply too much culture?

#78

"Too many books" was apparently a problem already 2000 years ago; here's Seneca advising his friend against it, in his letter-2: [quote] Be careful, though, about your reading in many authors and every type of book. It may be that there is something wayward and unstable in it. You must stay with a limited number of writers and be fed by them if you mean to derive anything that will dwell reliably with you. One who is…

This is a sentiment that resonates strongly with me. I've tried to keep up with the latest - whether it's books, movies, or programming libraries - and inevitably, I spread my attention too thin and learn too little about too much. Now, I've swung the other direction, and begun really dedicating my attention to a narrow set of things in just about every facet of my life. It's... an interesting difference.

Can you elaborate? I’m interested to know how you’ve done this, and what differences you’ve noticed, good and bad.

Re: Overloaded: Is there simply too much culture?

#79

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This does feel like my opinion on NFTs / Cryptocoins.

Extend the idea of NFTs to actual registered ownership of a thing you care about, like the title of your house, or your rental agreement, rather than a fucking pixelated jpg a child would be ashamed of, and it might look like something a bit more representative of a worthwhile future.

What happens when the chain devotes from reality? Let’s take the house title. I stop paying but refuse to sign a transaction giving up ownership. I get a divorce and destroy the key out of spite. I sell the house but have lost the key, can I never transact with my property again?

The chain will drift from reality, in an uncorrectable way, reducing its usefulness over time.

Re: Overloaded: Is there simply too much culture?

#80

Earlier quoted context omitted.

but why? I already have the title to my house

All other examples of things being done electronically that were done physically go here.

I think this isn't quite as implementable as they say it is. If someone breaks into a house, steals the crypto phrase from a little old lady, and moves a house into his name/address, should he really own it?

If a Blockchain contract needs to be ratified by an external entity, is the Blockchain really worth it over a database owned by that external entity?

Post reply on HN