Live data from Hacker News

Audacity 3.0 called spyware over data collection changes by new owner

appleinsider.com

71–75 of 75 posts

Re: Audacity 3.0 called spyware over data collection changes by new owner

#71
post #7
post #2

It's not called a spyware, it turned into a spyware after acquisition

Who would aquire a piece of pretty niche software to use strategically as a spying platform? Is the information that can be gained really worth that much?

I mean, it's the default audio software in many Linux distros, Tails included.

Re: Audacity 3.0 called spyware over data collection changes by new owner

#72

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> people complain about Firefox as well Not nearly as vehemently as with Audacity.

If Firefox had told people they would collect data for law enforcement there would be more noise there as well. There are good and legitimate reasons for collecting user data, but many of us think it should be voluntarily, minimal and at least not shared with anyone for anything but its original purpose. In fact we had a very interesting court case in Høgsterett (kind of Supreme Court) here last week where it was fin…

> If Firefox had told people they would collect data for law enforcement there would be more noise there as well.

Erm... Firefox has told people that they would hand data to law enforcement. They have to! Everyone has to!

https://www.mozilla.org/en-US/privacy/

> When do we share your information with others?

> When the law requires it. We follow the law whenever we receive requests about you from a government or related to a lawsuit.

Re: Audacity 3.0 called spyware over data collection changes by new owner

#73
post #18

Is it like, Audacity is widely used by whistleblowers, so by tracking down its users, authorities could prevent human rights violation from being uncovered? What else are these features useful in context of “law enforcement”?

3-letter agencies will explore and exploit any and all available avenues for obtaining information on anyone of interest. you can rest assured it has come to their attention.

Re: Audacity 3.0 called spyware over data collection changes by new owner

#74
post #65
post #58

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It seems more natural for the app to create a UUID for the purpose, then stash it in a prefs file for later use?

That's how I would do it as well, but that doesn't mean that Audacity's developers do.

They do hash IPs before sending them.
Post reply on HN