Live data from Hacker News

BBC Sound Effects made available to download for use under RemArc Licence (2018)

bbcsfx.acropolis.org.uk

71–80 of 135 posts

Re: BBC Sound Effects made available to download for use under RemArc Licence (2018)

#71
post #67
post #61

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm missing something, obviously. I know the "commercial" BBC made a killing from Top Gear show sales to other regions, but surely the rights to sell it were not given to them for free by the nonprofit arm? If the license fee pays to make show x, who _eventually_ profits from the sale of x to the US?

I've no idea where the profits made by the commercial subsidiaries eventually go, except that the BBC itself is not allowed to operate for profit. That said, you seem to be missing that giving something away for free and selling it for a profit are not exhaustive of the possibilities. (-:

Profits from commercial subsidiaries goes to fund the BBC budget and reduce the reliance on License fee.

For example last year BBC Studios paid £200m as dividend to the BBC.

http://downloads.bbc.co.uk/aboutthebbc/reports/annualreport/...

Re: BBC Sound Effects made available to download for use under RemArc Licence (2018)

#72
post #13
post #10

These used to be released on vinyl, there was once an incident in Ireland whereby a record player was hidden in a tree and BBC sound effects records were played at night to scare some of the sheep that were part of a "King of the Sheep" competition. It was a big scandal at the time.

Wow this sounds very funny and pretty interesting. I can't find anything about it from some cursory DDG/Googling. Would love to read about it if you have any links.

It was believed to be a monster of sorts. It was called "The Beast of Craggy Island".

Re: BBC Sound Effects made available to download for use under RemArc Licence (2018)

#73

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Both TV and Radio output quality has been absolutely eviscerated in the last 10 or so years Who was in power all that time?

Are you suggesting the editorial direction has been set by the government? Please provide evidence if so

The BBC is overseen by a government minister

Re: BBC Sound Effects made available to download for use under RemArc Licence (2018)

#74
post #51

Anything the BBC releases has to pass a market distortion test to make sure that it doesn't affect the competition - even commercial projects built by the commercial arm of the BBC (which doesn't receive any license fee funding) BBC Jam for example was a project back in 2006 offering multi-media educational resources free across the UK. This was 2 years before Khan Academy. http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/education/465529…

That seems quite a contrast to the early 80s, when they sponsored/commissioned their own branded home computer, promoted it on half the TV channels in the country and got it into every school in the country.

Re: BBC Sound Effects made available to download for use under RemArc Licence (2018)

#75
post #16
post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> where you may earn some revenue through adverts This is commercial use and paid.

It really isn't as clear as that. Most youtube videos are not monetised, but the status could change years later. Further, in an hour long video, using a 5 second audio clip with an advertising revenue of £0.10 is considered commercial and a payment?

Even if they are not monetised by the uploader, the video will still be monetised by Google, so this is still commercial use, even if they only earn 0.0001c

Re: BBC Sound Effects made available to download for use under RemArc Licence (2018)

#76
post #73

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Are you suggesting the editorial direction has been set by the government? Please provide evidence if so

The BBC is overseen by a government minister

The BBC is fully independent and there are multiple levels of oversight to ensure that. I'm sure you can furiously Google a more apt response than that. Evidence please

Re: BBC Sound Effects made available to download for use under RemArc Licence (2018)

#77
post #50

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That's only BBC One. BBC Two, BBC Four, and BBC News also exist. Of course, if one only looks at one channel things seem lopsided. Providing different services on different channels was partly the point.

> Providing different services on different channels was partly the point. No, BBC one's remit is not to just show fluffy nonsense It's remit is in fact: > BBC One’s remit is to be the BBC’s most popular mixed-genre television service across the UK, offering a wide range of high quality programmes. It should be the BBC’s primary outlet for major UK and international events and it should reflect the whole of the UK in…

No. The BBC One service description is actually:

> a mixed-genre channel, with versions for Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland and variations for English regions and the Channel Islands, providing a very broad range of programmes to a mainstream audience;

As I said, the different channels are different services, which is partly the point. BBC Four's service description is, for example:

> a channel providing an intellectually and culturally enriching alternative to mainstream programming on other BBC channels;

Re: BBC Sound Effects made available to download for use under RemArc Licence (2018)

#78

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Are you saying that Labour controls print media and the BBC in the UK?

> Are you saying that Labour controls print media and the BBC in the UK? No, how did you arrive at that invalid summation?

Possibly because:

"The unelected Labour opposition proposed activist shills"

is difficult to understand.

Re: BBC Sound Effects made available to download for use under RemArc Licence (2018)

#79

I think all of these are available on piratebay. When I was into sound production, I found lots of high quality dumps there. There's way more than 16k floating around on piratebay, more like 500k+. And the quality of some of them is amazing. Never used 'em for commercial applications, obviously, because hobby. But it's a lot of fun remixing them. Another interesting source of sound effects are pirated games. Last of…

Well there is more in the BBC library that are commercially available, something like 30,000. A lot of which are not just short samples.

Re: BBC Sound Effects made available to download for use under RemArc Licence (2018)

#80
post #51

Anything the BBC releases has to pass a market distortion test to make sure that it doesn't affect the competition - even commercial projects built by the commercial arm of the BBC (which doesn't receive any license fee funding) BBC Jam for example was a project back in 2006 offering multi-media educational resources free across the UK. This was 2 years before Khan Academy. http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/education/465529…

That seems quite a contrast to the early 80s, when they sponsored/commissioned their own branded home computer, promoted it on half the TV channels in the country and got it into every school in the country.

The government today is ideologically and politically opposed to the existence of the BBC, go figure. I don't think Thatcher was exactly a fan back in the 80s but equally they had more pressing matters to attend to
Post reply on HN