Live data from Hacker News

We Are All Confident Idiots (2014)

psmag.com

71–80 of 135 posts

Re: We Are All Confident Idiots (2014)

#72
post #3

Interestingly those who tend to be more realistic in their self expectations are more prone to depression. False confidence may be the route to happiness or at least optimism.

>those who tend to be more realistic in their self expectations are more prone to depression.

No, depression comes when you are only applying logic to life and essentially seeing that there is no meaning to it. Logic can not live without meaning, but life is tremendously bigger that our limited logic, regardless how fanciful we make it.

>False confidence may be the route to happiness or at least optimism.

No, this comes from the same point of view. Actually there is no route to happiness because it's here already. There are only routes away and making logic dominating in your life is one of them.

Re: We Are All Confident Idiots (2014)

#73
post #48
post #23

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I have grown in confidence over 20 years not by building capabilities but realizing that everyone else is guessing just as much as I am. And I'm at least an above-average guesser in my field of "expertise".

Knowing how to ask intelligent questions is the hallmark of a successful bluffer. Out your comrades lack of knowledge by exposing your own as a very clever question

This helped me in quite a few interviews, and I'm only 39yo. Thanks for putting it in a clear, logic and fun way. My brain had guessed the basic mechanism, but hadn't formulated it in words yet.

For that, I humbly concede you the title of my "BS Master".

Re: We Are All Confident Idiots (2014)

#74
post #3

Interestingly those who tend to be more realistic in their self expectations are more prone to depression. False confidence may be the route to happiness or at least optimism.

Would you rather be a happy idiot or a miserable know-it-all?

Can you really know-it-all? I mean really, whole Universe with its infinity in all depth and dimension? No, this is what makes you miserable not the knowledge itself - but taking on an impossible quest and knowing it but pretending you don't know.

Re: We Are All Confident Idiots (2014)

#75
post #46

I may have been faking it and making it till I caught on. I was faced with a trade-off I don’t know how to make. Do I prioritize urgent work or important work when not doing either has tragic consequences along similar timelines? Oh! We invented two words that mean the same thing so we can fake our own inability to prioritize? sigh

Urgent does not mean the same thing as important. Urgent tasks can be important or unimportant, but what makes them urgent is that they must be done soon/now rather than later, or that their value drops greatly if left to later.

Armed with this knowledge, we can categorise tasks in four: urgent-important, urgent-unimportant, unurgent-important, and unurgent-unimportant. Urgent-important tasks are always the highest priority, and unurgent-unimportant tasks the lowest. Where it gets interesting is between unurgent-important and urgent-unimportant tasks, the former should be prioritised if you do not have time to complete all the tasks, and the latter should be prioritised if you do.

Re: We Are All Confident Idiots (2014)

#76
post #20

Hey, I built a 40 year career on 'fake it until you have to leave or learn how to make it' -So don't knock this. And, all you young whippersnappers remember that its only old fools like me messing up in the code which gives you meaningful jobs fixing bugs in the future.

Wayne, is that you? I hated you at first for modifying the core libraries to break standard fuctionality, writing 500-line SQL statements full of string concatenations and using mutable globals all over the place, but now I see your point. Thanks, I have been earning an above average salary fixing your bugs and I will have a job for life. Still, fuck you man.

Bob, Is that you?

Whenever I go to the pub and meet old timers still working there keep telling me funny stories about how you swear loudly every time you open a code file I've touched.

Thanks for all the laughs.

Re: We Are All Confident Idiots (2014)

#77
post #5

How do you work with an individual who _insists_ they understand how it all works? Even when faced with hard evidence that contradicts their assessments, I'm still told I don't understand or I misinterpreted their words - basically gas-lighting me. Arguing leaves me unmotivated and frustrated. Giving in is the wrong path. Going to others doesn't seem to move the needle. Help.

Have you tried sarcasm? Works a treat. Little by little, undermine them by agreeing but disagreeing with subtle sarcasm until they doubt themselves. Works, but don't become an asshole yourself.

I'm not certain that 'doing the wrong thing for the right reasons' is justifiable. Especially gaslighting another person.

When you stare into the abyss, the abyss not only stares back, but also pulls you in...

Re: We Are All Confident Idiots (2014)

#79
Our school system.. We don't dare to be honest we do not know stuff. For our entire youth we are punished for that with bad figures and bullying.

Therefore the picture at the top of the article is so fitting. Especially lots of people that are graduated have some kind of air around them. Our educational system fucks the mind and ego. Is Einstein not enough prove for the 'being educated' fallacy? He despised the educational system, and I think he was also very right about that.

Re: We Are All Confident Idiots (2014)

#80

We are all confident idiots and this is why the ego was created in evolution. Ego is needed to make you think you are better than others at something, eventhough initially you may not be. Without ego, people would be Marvin The Paranoid Android but depressed because we didn't have the capabilities or opportunities to compete with all the smarter people around or in history. People that are laser focused and don't lis…

>Ego is needed to make you think you are better than others at something, eventhough initially you may not be.

No, ego creates a sense of separation, competition you create on your own.

>Without ego, people would be Marvin The Paranoid Android but depressed because we didn't have the capabilities or opportunities to compete

No, without ego people would do fantastically great. At least they would not do silly competition. Does an apple tree competes with a palm and thinks it's no good because it's not that tall?

>The reason why childhood is so nice is that you can dream and imagine on becoming anything

No, you can dream and imagine at any age, childhood is so nice because your mind is not yet set into straight jacket of logic.

>but break the rules and don't listen to others

The rules you are talking about are only created by you, there is nothing to break just stop creating them.

>Competition was only your local tribe before the internet, now it is worldwide

Only for those who see life this way. There is a plenty of people who are happy like kids and play competition to have fun.

>Everyone can be good at something, time and focus, as well as competition can push you.

If you enjoy life and what you are doing - do you really need a push? A push is only needed to do some crap which you have no interest about.

>Without ego humanity may not have made it this far.

What is "this far"? With all the technological advancements can we claim we are the happiest and most joyous generation ever? How far did we make from ancient civilizations in how profound our lives are?

The rest is too messy to comment about :)

Post reply on HN