Live data from Hacker News

California Supreme Court Moves to Make Bar Exam Easier to Pass

nytimes.com

71–80 of 83 posts

Re: California Supreme Court Moves to Make Bar Exam Easier to Pass

#71
post #37

Coming from a lawyer who passed Illinois in 2004 and took California's bar in 2014, I can say that for my CA test, the passage rate for attorneys barred in other states was around 20% (if I recall). California has differences in its laws that make it naturally harder than the "collective norm." Further, part of that low passage rate is because of two factors: 1) most attorneys already barred work full time, thus stud…

Sounds like tech coding interview process.

Except lawyers do it once, and they're done. We do it every time we change jobs.

Re: California Supreme Court Moves to Make Bar Exam Easier to Pass

#72
post #43
post #29

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Probably because it's pedantic. At most schools, if you want to major in computer stuff, you major in some sort of computer science major. In some universities, it's in the engineering school. In others, it's associated with other science programs, math in particular. There are various historic reasons for this. People who then go to build software systems are at least hopefully applying at least some engineering pri…

Is it pedantic? I think Computer Science should be taught by Computer Scientists, which is a different set of people than Software Engineers. I say this AS a Software Engineer.

It is pedantic because at some schools the degree program for people whose intention is to write software in exchange for money is "computer science" while at other schools it's "software engineering" and at yet other schools it's almost certain to be something else. Which means that arguing about which is the theoretically "correct" term has no relevance, since the names are used so interchangeably by the schools themselves.

Re: California Supreme Court Moves to Make Bar Exam Easier to Pass

#73
post #69
post #37

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Sounds like tech coding interview process.

Except after you're done, you get paid like $500 per hour

Isn't that more like "the firm you work for charges" rather than "get paid"?

Re: California Supreme Court Moves to Make Bar Exam Easier to Pass

#75

Because the schools are passing/producing more bad grads than ever, probably, regardless of total enrollment numbers. There are two rough ways to take this: A. The bar is needlessly high, its just gatekeeping credentialism B. The median school output (the median grad) is increasingly worse. I think the actual issue is B. I think its worse than most people want to admit. It stuck out to me when I was doing a little re…

Yes it's B, read law school scam blogs to get the full impact.

What do you mean by scam? Do you have any links to support this assertion?

Re: California Supreme Court Moves to Make Bar Exam Easier to Pass

#76

As someone not from the US - do all lawyers in the US have to pass a bar exam or just those who want to appear in court? In the UK only specialised court lawyers (barristers and advocates) are called to the bar.

In the US there is also a large class of legal workers called paralegals that don't need to pass the bar. They usually (always?) work under a lawyer, though. The paralegal is generally responsible for running the day-to-day part of some specific aspect of a legal practice. They are analogous to nurses or physician's assistant in a medical practice, but for the legal profession. So they are not layers, exactly, but often do the same kind of things.

Re: California Supreme Court Moves to Make Bar Exam Easier to Pass

#77

Earlier quoted context omitted.

In NY, you can only take 3x. In CA, you can take it as many times as you want. This is one of the reasons that the "repeat taker rate" and the "aggregate rate" in CA are much worse than in NY. CA simply has a different proportion of first-time takers, since repeat takers are not cut off at any point. When I took the bar in 2007, there was a guy who blogged about taking the bar. After learning he had failed, he contin…

Reminds me of the joke "what do you call the guy who got LAST PLACE in medical school" Doctor If you set a standard, the last place guy is just as much a part of it as the first place guy. Now it might not look so good on resumes, but he is legal.

It's a pointless joke. For a high enough standard, last place is plenty good. The fact that someone is in last place says nothing about how difficult the cutoff is.

To reverse the joke: you know what they call last place in the award ceremony? Bronze medalist.

Re: California Supreme Court Moves to Make Bar Exam Easier to Pass

#78
post #77

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Reminds me of the joke "what do you call the guy who got LAST PLACE in medical school" Doctor If you set a standard, the last place guy is just as much a part of it as the first place guy. Now it might not look so good on resumes, but he is legal.

It's a pointless joke. For a high enough standard, last place is plenty good. The fact that someone is in last place says nothing about how difficult the cutoff is. To reverse the joke: you know what they call last place in the award ceremony? Bronze medalist.

Or to go along further,

Do you know what they call the guy who got last place at the 100m dash in the olympics? Last place / slowest / loser

Despite being the 8th fastest person on the planet.

Re: California Supreme Court Moves to Make Bar Exam Easier to Pass

#79
post #77

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's a pointless joke. For a high enough standard, last place is plenty good. The fact that someone is in last place says nothing about how difficult the cutoff is. To reverse the joke: you know what they call last place in the award ceremony? Bronze medalist.

Or to go along further, Do you know what they call the guy who got last place at the 100m dash in the olympics? Last place / slowest / loser Despite being the 8th fastest person on the planet.

Then why do you make the joke? It's misleading.

Re: California Supreme Court Moves to Make Bar Exam Easier to Pass

#80

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yes it's B, read law school scam blogs to get the full impact.

What do you mean by scam? Do you have any links to support this assertion?

http://insidethelawschoolscam.blogspot.com/?m=1
Post reply on HN