Live data from Hacker News

Why Does Everyone Hate Monsanto? (2014)

modernfarmer.com

71–72 of 72 posts

Re: Why Does Everyone Hate Monsanto? (2014)

#71
post #69

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It is not a marketing scheme, it is customer information just like the usual ingredients labels. As I said in another comment, declaring what is in a product should really be the norm, GMO labeling opponents should justify why it is okay or better to hide this information from customers.

It's very simple. Food ingredients are on the label for safety reasons. There are no measurable safety effects of GMO, Halal, etc. What criteria do you use to determine if a property should be on a label? Should foods with homosexuals or muslims involved in production also get a warning label? If not, why not? Or do you believe every random bias of consumers is something that every possible producer must account for?

What criteria do you use to determine if a property should be on a label?

Simple, if a substantial fraction of the consumers cares about it.

Should foods with homosexuals or muslims involved in production also get a warning label? If not, why not? Or do you believe every random bias of consumers is something that every possible producer must account for?

People already avoid products from specific companies, countries and whatnot because they disapprove their ethics, labor conditions and so on. If people cared about the race or religion of the people producing the products they buy, then it should be on the label. I would actually almost bet there were products advertising that they were produced by white Americans only or something similar. That it was never a mandatory labeling probably just means that people never cared enough about it, not that it is something totally unimaginable.

If this is really the only argument against GMO labeling, that it would be kind of a random addition amongst many other possible addition to the labels, that seems a pretty weak argument.

Re: Why Does Everyone Hate Monsanto? (2014)

#72

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You can't stop people from making presuppositions about life. This is a silly statement since people already question GMO's even without the label. For example: "If Organic is safe, why is it labeled?"

more interestingly "if ingredients are safe, why are they listed?"

Not a fair comparison at all. Some people may be allergic to certain ingredients. Some ingredients are also obviously less healthy than others.

There is literally zero distinction between a GMO and non-GMO ingredient that is not completely fabricated or imagined.

Post reply on HN