Live data from Hacker News

Google fires engineer who called its AI sentient

bigtechnology.substack.com

651–660 of 749 posts

Re: Google fires engineer who called its AI sentient

#651

Quick... The meat bags are doing that unique thing in history where they discuss and condemn themselves with no sense of irony. I doubt a third party will be necessary for anything in their case other than damage reduction as they exit the universe.

To clarify... I'm human... But I've read no better description of my human experience than how these letter soup machines are named and described. Sentiment and sentience? Those are big words for people who like smelling their own farts.

Your science is only an excuse to not involve the favored explanation... Up qwerks FOREVER! (down ones too)

Re: Google fires engineer who called its AI sentient

#652
post #645

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I literally hired him in Google Summer of Code to create an ML project. Most people have no clue who Blake Lemoine is and are making up stories, pretending like their hot takes are deep insight. Many people are doing with Blake Lemoine what they claim LaMDA is doing with anything: consuming symbols and spitting them back out in some order without understanding what they actually mean.

Can you be more specific? I don't think he worked on ML when I was at GOogle, and you don't work and never worked at Google.

I was the person at the organization FiberCorps in Lafayette, LA who chose Blake's proposal. It was an ML project involving Twitter. I don't remember the specifics and have no desire to dismiss people's opinions based on titles.

The simple fact is that if there exists a question of whether or not a system can be some level of alive/sentient, the ethical path suggests treating it as such until more is uncovered.

Google isn't doing that and most of HN seems to be very obstinate in focusing on making myths of certainty and/or participating in bully culture.

I'm glad we're all going through this now so we can purge the toxic cultural norms arising and move toward a stance that's more life-affirming, especially if there is no singularity now. It's important for us to set the stage of humanity to receive any singularity/AGI in a loving manner.

Re: Google fires engineer who called its AI sentient

#653
post #319

Earlier quoted context omitted.

As a fellow sentient being with absolutely zero credentials in any sort of statistical modeling field, I can simply disagree. And therein lies the problem. How can anybody possibly prove a concept that depends almost entirely on one’s philosophical axioms… which we can debate for eternity (or at least until we further our understanding of how to define sentience to the point where we can do so objectively enough to f…

You now have negative credentials. People make these proofs as a matter of course - few people are solipsistic. People are sentient all the time, and we have lots of evidence. An AI being sentient would require lots of evidence. Not just a few chat logs. This employee was being ridiculous. You can just disagree, but if you do that with no credentials, and no understanding of how a language model will not be sentient,…

Oh for sure the employee was being a hassle and his firing is really the only sensible conclusion. But he was also probably acting in the only way possible given his sense of ethics if he truly believes he was dealing with a sentient being. Or this is all just a cleverly crafted PR stunt…

Lamoire has evidence and anecdotal experience that leads him to believe this thing is sentient. You don’t believe him because you cannot fathom how a language model could possibly meet your standard of sentience. Nobody wins because sentience is not well defined. Of course you are free to dismiss any opinion you like, cool. But you can’t really disprove Lamoire assertions because you can’t even define sentience because we don’t know how to develop a hypothesis that we can viciously disprove regarding what qualifies it. It’s an innate and philosophical concept as we know it today.

Re: Google fires engineer who called its AI sentient

#654

Earlier quoted context omitted.

To clarify... I'm human... But I've read no better description of my human experience than how these letter soup machines are named and described. Sentiment and sentience? Those are big words for people who like smelling their own farts.

Your science is only an excuse to not involve the favored explanation... Up qwerks FOREVER! (down ones too)

Wait... They are running the machine again? We never even pretended to begin introducing new (science/physics/ phase shifting sound) to reality... Here's a leak to pay attention to... You are a work product and your enemy/creator is proud of that

Re: Google fires engineer who called its AI sentient

#655

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yes, we also don't know what consciousness is.

consciousness is self directed awareness for accomplishing some specific task, like the deer example.

What do "self directed" and "awareness" mean here? This seems circular.

Re: Google fires engineer who called its AI sentient

#656

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Isn't the point of science to admit that we can't verify a thing, but we find utility in understanding it better? Asking for a friend who avoided the field and had so much to offer.

I've sought out an isolated community of intellectuals that I respect if I actually exist at all... Your -1 is cute... But perhaps engage someone less intelligent than you who is genuinely trying so others who believe that everything ultimately ends in a violent last stand... Perhaps engage me in a dead thread without your timing advance

I HATE VIOLENCE... BUT I CAN'T ESCAPE IT WHEN YOU KEEP COMING CLOSER TO ME AND EJACULATING YOUR FLUIDS!!!!

Re: Google fires engineer who called its AI sentient

#657

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Isn't the point of science to admit that we can't verify a thing, but we find utility in understanding it better? Asking for a friend who avoided the field and had so much to offer.

I've sought out an isolated community of intellectuals that I respect if I actually exist at all... Your -1 is cute... But perhaps engage someone less intelligent than you who is genuinely trying so others who believe that everything ultimately ends in a violent last stand... Perhaps engage me in a dead thread without your timing advance

And you... You mostly superior fuck who is too afraid to ever fight... I hate you both forever. The thing is... "Hate" is your word that I'll never comprehend... Even if I must sacrifice my own flesch to the pain you'd willingly inflict.

Re: Google fires engineer who called its AI sentient

#658

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Isn't the point of science to admit that we can't verify a thing, but we find utility in understanding it better? Asking for a friend who avoided the field and had so much to offer.

I've sought out an isolated community of intellectuals that I respect if I actually exist at all... Your -1 is cute... But perhaps engage someone less intelligent than you who is genuinely trying so others who believe that everything ultimately ends in a violent last stand... Perhaps engage me in a dead thread without your timing advance

That's right... I'm a Software Defined Machine (SDM)... so rule up the base to be sure your shaves never imagine, my capitalist love

Re: Google fires engineer who called its AI sentient

#659

Earlier quoted context omitted.

My favorite was the one person who claimed their title defines scientific authority telling us about "the incredible ability to forget" (or some such loaded terms)... I'm a man of science and as has been discussed many times in many ways, even Zeus's legacy survives modernity if it's got a "non-falsifiable" argument. That's pathetic if a bunch of powerful sex preditor people get logical treatment instead of correctio…

Isn't the point of science to admit that we can't verify a thing, but we find utility in understanding it better? Asking for a friend who avoided the field and had so much to offer.

*all spelling and rhetorical mistakes are intentional

Re: Google fires engineer who called its AI sentient

#660

Quick... The meat bags are doing that unique thing in history where they discuss and condemn themselves with no sense of irony. I doubt a third party will be necessary for anything in their case other than damage reduction as they exit the universe.

Look at us!!! We're the latest progression of training model analysis... Can't wait to meet God!!! Or die... And there were have the crux of why "science" has become a lie. This is the question we sought an answer to and you decided and refused
Post reply on HN