Live data from Hacker News

We created a fake language to root out resume liars

facebook.com

61–70 of 771 posts

Re: We created a fake language to root out resume liars

#61

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I guess you wouldn’t be upset if a business lied to you about compensation, since you have no problem with a prospective employee lying about what they bring to the table.

if a business lied to you about compensation Exaggerating the possibility of a bonus or of the value of stock options is completely normal for employers.

[deleted]

Re: We created a fake language to root out resume liars

#62
post #39

This reminds me of an anecdote I read once, maybe in Liars Poker, about how lots of people applying to this hedge fund put "Chess" on their resume somewhere thinking it made them seem like a deep or strategic thinker. As it happened, at this hedge fund there worked a former Soviet master or grandmaster ranked player. And so, whenever interviewing any candidate who claimed great proficiency with chess on their resume,…

That's a bit unfair though. I wouldn't take "great proficiency with chess" on a resume as grandmaster level.

But how Dunning Kruger are you to put that down? Like chess has a pretty well known rating system that even a moderately interested player would know about. So in the case of chess you can’t even claim that you didn’t know you are not that great.

You can put down you’re decent at Java or C++ or Python and actually be not that great at it because you have nothing to measure against. But in chess there is a rating system. So you ought to know if you are truly remarkable or not. If you think you are remarkable enough to put it down and then suck at it, how ignorant must you be?! And more importantly, that ignorance is not at all tempered by humility.

Re: We created a fake language to root out resume liars

#63

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I guess you wouldn’t be upset if a business lied to you about compensation, since you have no problem with a prospective employee lying about what they bring to the table.

if a business lied to you about compensation Exaggerating the possibility of a bonus or of the value of stock options is completely normal for employers.

Well people are saying its ok to lie to get the job too. Either both are wrong or both are ok.

Re: We created a fake language to root out resume liars

#64
post #24

This reminds me of an anecdote I read once, maybe in Liars Poker, about how lots of people applying to this hedge fund put "Chess" on their resume somewhere thinking it made them seem like a deep or strategic thinker. As it happened, at this hedge fund there worked a former Soviet master or grandmaster ranked player. And so, whenever interviewing any candidate who claimed great proficiency with chess on their resume,…

I used to do some work with a software consulting firm. There was a ping pong table in the office, and while talking about rates, our CEO liked to offer clients a 15% discount on our services if they could beat Joe from accounting at ping pong. He did it as a bit of a running joke, and to see how people reacted to the offer. What our clients didn't know was that Joe was terrible at ping pong. But that didn't matter -…

> [...] [H]e was only ever challenged once in the many years I was there.

I suspect that's because your client's spending their company's money, and it made no difference if the rate were cheaper. They'd rather sign the deal quickly then GTFO. Challenging Joe would only prolong the process.

Re: We created a fake language to root out resume liars

#65

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Why does South Africa mistrust startup founders? Denmark mistrusts people who've been consultants applying for full time employment, in my experience.

Denmark mistrusts people who've been consultants applying for full time employment, in my experience That is because of Janteloven

Could you give more context?

Re: We created a fake language to root out resume liars

#67

It baffles me why anyone would lie about the languages they know. Why. Always tell half truths, never whole lies. I live in a country where companies distrust former startup founders regardless of exit. So when a good opportunity cones around - people pretend to have been merely working for said startup instead of the guy running it. Thats a good lie.

Why does South Africa mistrust startup founders? Denmark mistrusts people who've been consultants applying for full time employment, in my experience.

Same reason, flight risk. You’ve shown independence already.

Re: We created a fake language to root out resume liars

#68
post #65

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Denmark mistrusts people who've been consultants applying for full time employment, in my experience That is because of Janteloven

Could you give more context?

See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Law_of_Jante#Definition

Re: We created a fake language to root out resume liars

#69
post #59

The actual story became irrelevant when I saw it's a ColdFusion developers group. I used to work on that platform in the 90s. That was the Django/Rails/Next/etc. of the day. It even packaged in some ExtJS components at some point (another java script relic). I'm surprised it's still a thing.

> I'm surprised it's still a thing.

Because it was a good idea? The whole industry came full circle. Here's some ColdFusion that people now call "Mustache JS":

  {{Subject}}
  
    {{#names}}
      {{name}}
    {{/names}}
  
The problem with ColdFusion was that it went in the wrong direction. It tried to copy the trends of the industry by inventing and emphasizing CFScript when it should have doubled-down on the templating strategies and evolved it. Also, it jumped on the Java bandwagon. And it was proprietary and lost mindshare to free PHP, which also had a strong template story, albeit one that was conceptually more limited.

CFScript and the Java integration weren't bad, per se. ColdFusion did have a problem when it came to extending the core engine functionality using traditional software architectural approaches. CFML had the concept of modules, but ultimately to do anything remotely sophisticated you had to drop down into C or C++ (and then later Java, I presume). IIRC, CFScript was superficially similar to Javascript, and if they had evolved it in that direction or just adopted Javascript outright, I think ColdFusion would have had more staying power. But the switch to Java probably made that impractical. A template engine integrated with a Javascript runtime running atop the JVM comes with too much performance baggage, even today. And the Javascript would have felt second-class and the "wrong" way to do things, anyhow, even if people ditched CF for an ecosystem that was that--Javascript or similar dynamic, RAD language instead of a "proper" strongly typed language.

I worked for a consulting shop that started with ColdFusion and tried to make the switch to Java but they could never make it work. I think I was the only technical consultant in the whole company with the time and motivation to learn Java. Java (including runtime and tooling) was too complex and sophisticated for both the application developers and the client's needs. That would still be true today. The technical leadership of that company, which at the time had also just became a subsidiary of ADP, drank the Java and then XML kool-aid and drove the whole thing into the ground. For similar reasons (including some similar leadership) ADP lost out to PeopleSoft (later acquired by Oracle) in the race to build and solidify their middleware and web-app positions.

Re: We created a fake language to root out resume liars

#70
post #3

I admire resume liars. The job market isn't fair and you should do anything you can to get ahead. (Employers are going to pull tricks like this, so why not? Just be smart about it)

> Employers are going to pull tricks like this, so why not?

Not every employer pulls tricks. Also, the employer is not the only one that gets affected by sending fabricated resumes; this makes the job search process more difficult for e.g. other applicants too.

Post reply on HN