Live data from Hacker News

How Aging Research Is Changing Our Lives

aging.nautil.us

61–63 of 63 posts

Re: How Aging Research Is Changing Our Lives

#61
post #52

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If you have no symptoms then what on earth would you have to talk about with your GP twice a month? I think you overestimate the insider-expertise the medical profession possesses when it comes to optimizing health.

> If you have no symptoms then what on earth would you have to talk about with your GP twice a month? I feel like this illustrates my point quite nicely. I'm not sure, but the addition of "on earth" makes your sentence sound incredulous and rhetorical rather than a genuine question, more of a statement that without symptoms there can't possibly be anything to discuss. Are you by chance under 30? The definition of whe…

I debated whether or not to include "on earth". While I am genuinely curious as to what you'd have to talk about with a doc twice a month I also think it seems extreme given what resources we have available to us as patients outside of the medical professionals we (the insurance co's) pay for.

Many of your examples/analogies fall outside 2x/month. Yes, I do perform maintenance on my car and computer, but not 2x a month.

When I've had medical issues that warrant seeing a doctor I first do my own research online so I know what questions to ask. Very rarely has the doc revealed something to me that I didn't already learn as part of my research. The only real value I've received is if tests were needed or procedures or medication was indicated. These have never required twice monthly contact.

I have similar issues to you (sans the surgeries) and when I consult with my doc he (my GP is male) gives me the information I need. Unless something significant changes then there's nothing new he can tell me two weeks later.

Completely agree we have sick care, not health care. Then again if suddenly 2x consults with a doc were made available for free that wouldn't change anything. Medical science still has a lot to figure out in terms of 'health'. Many of the treatments prescribed aren't actually backed up by good empirical evidence. My brother-in-law is an MD and he reminds me of this often.

I'm 50 years old.

Re: How Aging Research Is Changing Our Lives

#62
post #45
post #44

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I suppose this is pretty subjective and depends on your level of knowledge on the issues, but I feel that healthy living is more or less a solved problem from a "what to do" standpoint. The main problem is breaking people of unhealthy lifestyle habits while educating them on healthier habits (see books like Power of Habit for habit formation and modification). I don't have links handy (edit: apparently I have a few)…

What you are describing is a level of fitness that maybe 1% of the male population have at a young age. It is not realistic to keep that level throughout a full life. And it is probably unconstructive to try.

I had that level of fitness for many years, until I did a startup at 40. Now I am trying to get it back at 59 thru a progressive calisthenics program. I can't even do ONE pull up at this point, but I am getting closer!

Re: How Aging Research Is Changing Our Lives

#63
post #44

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> There is a ton of information of healthy living Where is this "ton of information on healthy living" and what level of evidence do you have for it? I don't doubt that there is a set of things that people can do to be healthy. I do not think that there is much information about what those steps are. Again, there is plenty of writing on the topic, but little information.

I suppose this is pretty subjective and depends on your level of knowledge on the issues, but I feel that healthy living is more or less a solved problem from a "what to do" standpoint. The main problem is breaking people of unhealthy lifestyle habits while educating them on healthier habits (see books like Power of Habit for habit formation and modification). I don't have links handy (edit: apparently I have a few)…

One of the best short but to the point set of suggestions I have seen. All known but it helps to reinforce them frequently! Thanks.
Post reply on HN