Live data from Hacker News

Say goodbye to search analytics

getclicky.com

61–67 of 67 posts

Re: Say goodbye to search analytics

#61

Earlier quoted context omitted.

My thoughts, exactly. Why would they use more resources and slow down page load for users who couldn't care less?

They made Gmail default to HTTPS, and the same argument could apply for both.

Emails are rather more sensitive than search terms though.

Re: Say goodbye to search analytics

#62

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Adsense uses behavioral targeting, of which a part is based on the search queries you enter into Google (as in, when you're searching for "christmas toys" on Google, for a certain amount of time you become a hot target for relevant ads in Adsense). Other ad providers were able to mimic this by analyzing the referrer urls from which people were being redirected. This is not possible anymore. If Adsense doesn't disable…

> a part is based on the search queries you enter into Google Can you prove that? Because I have looked for proof of that and have not found any. There seems to be a fair sized Chinese wall between google search and google adsense/adwords. To the extent that they indeed use another crawler, if they shared data with search that would be the first place to see it.

Apparently you're correct, I have looked up the privacy policy and was unable to find any indication they're using the keywords you're searching for for Adsense.

I apologize for making wild claims.

Re: Say goodbye to search analytics

#65
post #63

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Strong disagree.

So search terms regularly contain highly sensitive things like password reset verifications for your online banking?

No, they simply regularly contain highly sensitive things. Not password reset verifications.

Re: Say goodbye to search analytics

#66

Earlier quoted context omitted.

But search engines shouldn't block referrer by default. Majority of users don't care about telling web masters what they were searching for. So search engines should only let users who do care about privacy to block referrer, block it by default is a poor choice (unless you are DDG and privacy is your differentiator)

I would actually really like for my search engine referrer headers to be blocked, even without the privacy concerns, for one simple reason: some web sites highlight the search terms they find in search engine referrer headers. That annoys the crap out of me, and I usually end up either closing the tab or going to the URL bar and adding and deleting a space in there, then reloading the page without referrer headers. W…

Honest question: Is adding and deleting a space necessary? I think it is sufficient in all browsers just to focus the address bar and press Enter.

Re: Say goodbye to search analytics

#67
post #41

So giving people the option to hide their searches from tyrannical regimes, snooping schools and overbearing corporate IT firms, let alone a kid with a copy of wireshark at a local café is evil? Grow up. It's in beta and will unlikely ever become the default due to the extra latency and server load. Ignore all that and seek for attention anyhow.

SSL won't hide anything from anyone who really wants to see it, as they can set up an SSL proxy using a certificate that is trusted by your browser. The address bar will turn blue, and the certificate info will say something like, "issued to www.gmail.com, issued by [IT-obsessed corporation name here]".
Post reply on HN