Live data from Hacker News

HangoverApp – Share pics without Internet, only visible if all devices present

hangoverapp.com

61–70 of 76 posts

Re: HangoverApp – Share pics without Internet, only visible if all devices present

#61

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Ugh. "Throw feces at the wall and see if it sticks" is the culture that gave us post-a-day blog spam instead of sporadic thoughtful writing, and github spammers pushing out whatever half-done garbage they typed in on a manic Saturday to be abandoned by Monday. As the saying goes, "there's a reason you have two ears but only one mouth."

And what exactly is wrong with people getting lots of practice writing and lots of practice coding? You don't need to read what they've written.

I still need to determine whether it's worth reading. Private diaries/libraries are still useful, both for the writing and for the lack of publication.

Re: HangoverApp – Share pics without Internet, only visible if all devices present

#62

If you don't trust the other end of the communications, just don't hit send... Anything else is BS.

I think it's a neat concept that could be flushed out a bit. Maybe instead of pitching it as a way to take control of potentially embarrassing media, pitch as an excuse to get the group back together again. I'd love to see more social apps that encourage, well people being social.

You mean like the app Groups? :-)

Re: HangoverApp – Share pics without Internet, only visible if all devices present

#63
post #33
post #31

Everyone has to be in the same place? I can just hand my phone to someone else and let them see something, no data exchange or app required. Alternatively, the discussion below seems to point out that screenshot blocking is ineffective. If all devices are in the same room, a swift punch to the mouth and taking someone else's device could remove that possibility. It cuts both ways.

the point is that you have to be together to unlock the photos. It's not that you're sharing photos locally, as seems to be your issue with the app.

But why would I want to take a photo that needs to be "unlocked"? My phone already has a camera on it, and I can already not share photos. I genuinely don't understand what this app is doing.

Re: HangoverApp – Share pics without Internet, only visible if all devices present

#64

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It seems like you don't understand the idea. This ensures that all parties consent to the content being viewed by any other party.

Does installing this app somehow disable the regular camera app? Not sure how it ensures anything. Joe takes a picture. I want to see it. But, oops, Billy isn't here to complete the nuclear launch procedure. So I turn to Joe and say "hey, text me that funny picture of Billy." What happens next?

It might work if they delete the original photos (if that's still possible on modern devices).

Re: HangoverApp – Share pics without Internet, only visible if all devices present

#66
post #58
post #57

Doubt they got trademark permission from Warner Brothers.

Why would they have to? Just because there happens to be a movie called "The Hangover"?

It's pretty obvious that the name is playing off the movie.

Re: HangoverApp – Share pics without Internet, only visible if all devices present

#67
post #17

I don't hate the app really.. I just kinda hate the culture that produces this app. Am I just getting old?

I can see where you're coming from, but I don't know if that's a fair reduction.

In the app world we initially thought more everything was better. When apps that took things away (twitter took away characters, snap chat took away permanence) showed up, we realized that sometimes less creates a better social situation.

I love the sentimental value of photography but dislike it's massively redistributable nature. Consider for example this app for... sexual pictures taken with a lover.

Re: HangoverApp – Share pics without Internet, only visible if all devices present

#69
post #33

Earlier quoted context omitted.

the point is that you have to be together to unlock the photos. It's not that you're sharing photos locally, as seems to be your issue with the app.

But why would I want to take a photo that needs to be "unlocked"? My phone already has a camera on it, and I can already not share photos. I genuinely don't understand what this app is doing.

If you think about homemade porn, it makes some sense.

Re: HangoverApp – Share pics without Internet, only visible if all devices present

#70

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It seems like you don't understand the idea. This ensures that all parties consent to the content being viewed by any other party.

Does installing this app somehow disable the regular camera app? Not sure how it ensures anything. Joe takes a picture. I want to see it. But, oops, Billy isn't here to complete the nuclear launch procedure. So I turn to Joe and say "hey, text me that funny picture of Billy." What happens next?

Well, probably the photo is supposed to be taken with the Hangover app in the first place. I don't know app development, but does an app that accesses the camera _have_ to store the photo alongside photos taken with the normal camera app?

My impression was: group of friends are in vegas having a "Hangover (the movie)" style night and agree to only take photos with this app. That way, come the morning they can all review them, but only when they're all together.

Obviously, if they take photos with their normal camera, or if all apps have to save photos to the filesystem and can be seen by the built in photogallery app, this doesn't work. Maybe the app uploads them to the Hangover site and then automatically deletes them from the phone?

Post reply on HN