Live data from Hacker News

A dad took photos of his toddler for a doctor – Google flagged him as a criminal

nytimes.com

571–580 of 609 posts

Re: A dad took photos of his toddler for a doctor – Google flagged him as a criminal

#571
post #29

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Puritans. We “banned” alcohol for 13 years. America’s greatest battle is with our dark religious past. We claim to be secular but really it’s an aspiration.

eh, I feel like alcohol bans were fashionable in the past. USSR did it, Finland did it...

Alcohol ban makes a lot of sense.... alcohol has been proven scientifically to adversely harm humans in any amount.

Re: A dad took photos of his toddler for a doctor – Google flagged him as a criminal

#572
post #479
post #417

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Well, it's really not straightforward to know what would be the outcome of such a lawsuit. Google's ToS is one thing but the main point is that random user uploading family photos is not a protected group, so Google refusing service is very much their right. The state usually cannot force otherwise.

The state should. Otherwise, what’s the point of having it.

unfortunately consumer protection is basically nonexistent in the US. (besides a lot of reporting requirements, that should be streamlined and automatic anyway.)

Re: A dad took photos of his toddler for a doctor – Google flagged him as a criminal

#573

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Haha yeah, in Europe there are often naked children running around at the beach. In Germany, there are places (especially lakes) where everyone is walking around, swimming and sunbathing naked - Sometimes the whole family. For me it was quite a shock initially but now I think it's fine.

I find that a bit weird tbh. I mean, if we look at human tribes throughout the world/history, and even what is the most common nowadays in african tribes which maintain their dressing habits, they usually cover their genitals. It indicates to me it is human nature to do that. It seems to me, in some countries for several reasons, they are going against the grain, purely out of culture. But there's something weird abo…

Europeans don't go around naked all day. It being acceptable to see a person in the nude in certain scenarios is not the same as a complete lack of inhibition towards private parks. You talk about African tribes covering their genitals but I'm pretty sure you're gonna see them being uncovered (and being okay with it) for certain activities for a larger percentage of their day than westerners.

Re: A dad took photos of his toddler for a doctor – Google flagged him as a criminal

#574

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What are you talking about? Which "certain" states? Iran, my old country, may be the 9th largest consumer of alcohol per capita [1,2]. There are hundreds of deaths due to wood-alcohol poisoning every year [3], mostly from people making moonshine from raisins and not being diligent enough to remove the stems, in lieu of access to safe drinking alcohol. I personally know many people who abuse alcohol just to be able to…

> puritan Christians I’ve lost track of how many people in this thread have blamed Christians. Why? Christian’s do not have a ban on alcohol. Where is this idea coming from, or are we just spreading hate?

The keyword is “puritan.” I don’t see how you can not blame a school of thought that labels most human activities as “vice.”

Re: A dad took photos of his toddler for a doctor – Google flagged him as a criminal

#575

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Autopay is simple to set up with any hosting provider. If you're in a financial place where the $5/mo and $10/yr payments might bounce... yeah, probably don't pay for email. As far as the social engineering goes, personally I gladly take that risk in order to bring my email firmly into my control. If I'm going to lose access to my email, I want it to be because I did something stupid, not because an algorithm flagged…

I'm not fully confident that I'll never cancel a credit card that pays annual subscription. Generally it's fine because alert email would come on my inbox, but it's email infrastructure so I need extra attention.

I’m not big on PayPal but I have some domain names set up for recurring PayPal payments (with cc as a backup) because PayPal is insidious with regards to how far they go to fund your account (charging multiple cards, goopy your bank account, sending you letters for debt collection, etc) which, for most things, would be exactly the opposite of what I want but for domain names it’s a huge burden lifted.

Re: A dad took photos of his toddler for a doctor – Google flagged him as a criminal

#576
post #522

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm not fully confident that I'll never cancel a credit card that pays annual subscription. Generally it's fine because alert email would come on my inbox, but it's email infrastructure so I need extra attention.

You can prepurchase a domain for 10 years. Set a calendar reminder 9 years from now to renew for another 10..

Most providers don’t offer that, though. I can recommend Hover.com for multi-year leases without crazy rate upcharges.

Re: A dad took photos of his toddler for a doctor – Google flagged him as a criminal

#577
post #454

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The Apple who caused an immense controversy with its CSAM scanning debacle? All of Big Tech is ultimately not so different.

They cancelled the CSAM scanning project. In contrast, Google has been doing CSAM (and apparently AI porn detection) for years. Also, the bone-headed Apple plan had safeguards that would have prevented the victim in the article from losing their account. The two policies aren't remotely comparable.

You’re right, they’re not comparable: Apple was going to be scanning for CSAM on your device, without the photos even reaching their servers (by uploading a backup, texting a copy, etc). Google, so far as I can tell and as corroborated by the article, doesn’t do that. Apple and Google both already scan anything uploaded to your Photos account for CSAM and report to authorities.

Re: A dad took photos of his toddler for a doctor – Google flagged him as a criminal

#578
post #357

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I run a server at home and I’ve set up Nextcloud. I don’t trust it to be more reliable than a paid service. The thing about self hosted solutions is you’re completely on your own if something goes wrong. You need to make sure you’re backing things up, that you can restore your Nextcloud configuration if your sql database takes a dump or you fat finger and delete some config files (I’ve done both). Or if you have a po…

If something goes wrong with your google account (or other SaaS that would lose your data, or ban you without recourse), you are not even on your own, you're just trully fucked. It's poof gone and no local/internet tech geek will be able to help you. If something goes wrong with your at home nextcloud, you still have the data/hw, and you can either get help troubleshooting from someone who understands what they're do…

Yeah totally agree with this. I back up all my important data, but I’d still prefer to Apple/Fastmail/Dropbox be the primary provider of a service and back it up to my server (and other cloud services) than run and rely on my own nextcloud.

Re: A dad took photos of his toddler for a doctor – Google flagged him as a criminal

#579

Earlier quoted context omitted.

slip of the tongue/keyboard. It was obviously supposed to read "There's no such thing as cloud storage, just somebody else's computer." It's a fairly well known phrase[0][1]. It's even a laptop sticker[2]. And no, they're not going to spin up a VM. They should buy their own NAS and back everything up to that if they care enough about privacy to avoid cloud storage. [0] https://pocketnow.com/no-such-thing-as-the-cloud…

Just because it is well known doesn’t make it true. S3 alone is made up of 100+ microservices

Sure, but we're talking about cloud storage here for a laymen, who's hardly likely to know what AWS is, and we're also talking about a laymen who just wants to backing up a file, they're not using thinking about any of that. They just want to put their file on a drive somewhere. I'm arguing that if they care that much about privacy they should back it up to a device they own, and not use on a cloud provider. You're not providing a defence against any of that. You're saying that instead of storing their files on Google's computer they should use Amazons, or Microsofts? Why? If they truly value their own privacy they should back things up to a device they own such as a NAS, and/or a trusted family members NAS.

I've also just seen, which you didn't disclose, that you work at AWS[0]. Not disclosing a vested interest doesn't exactly lend confidence to your impartiality. Either way, I'm still not sure how your argument is a rebuttal to my proposal. SO far it seems to amount to "other cloud providers exist" and "Your mistype wasn't accurate"?

[0]https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32556018

Re: A dad took photos of his toddler for a doctor – Google flagged him as a criminal

#580
post #490

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Criticize the US President all you like on every social network: not a problem. given that this [1] already happened in my country, and also this [2] also happened (just to name a couple) and nobody paid, that there are 13,000 American soldiers on my Country's soil and that this [3] man has been POTUS and is probably running again for election, I wouldn't say "not a problem". US could reach me at my house if they w…

Here's an example of a chinese Univerity of Minnesota grad student that tweeted Winnie the Pooh (among other things) while in the US, and was later imprisoned in China for it: https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/news/university-of-minnes...

a Chinese student.

I don't support China methods, but mocking the president of your country in public, from abroad, when you know what your Country is is capable of is not a smart move, ever.

It happens everywhere, different solutions, same goal: censorship and setting an example.

https://time.com/4644297/saturday-night-live-katie-rich-susp...

Post reply on HN