Live data from Hacker News

Pirate Bay founder thinks Parler’s inability to stay online is 'embarrassing'

vice.com

541–550 of 640 posts

Re: Pirate Bay founder thinks Parler’s inability to stay online is 'embarrassing'

#541

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's not a strong point because you can make exactly the same argument for anything else you'd like to ban, including printable pistol schematics, anarchist cookbooks, terrorist propaganda, and so on. It's a cheap truism to say that if something is easily available this will make it more likely for people to become interested in it, will make certain people more inclined towards it, may create a market for it, and so…

Who gets hurt in the process of making pistol schematics? Or in the making of terrorist propaganda? The hard difference is: With CP, harm is done in the process of creating the material. With most other things, harm could potentially be done as a result of the content.

That wasn't your argument, though. There is no doubt that the production of CP is and should be illegal, as it involves child abuse. However, your original argument was about the possession of CP. There is a standard argument against the claim that this is a victimless crime, and that is that the children abused are harmed by the distribution of pictures that show them. I find that argument to some extent convincing, but not yours.

Re: Pirate Bay founder thinks Parler’s inability to stay online is 'embarrassing'

#542

I personally don't find their ability to remain online that surprising. The Pirate Bay and other torrent networks were built by people with a passion for building, maintaining and hacking things. People who, even without a solid CS background, would spend hours a day learning new things, developing distributed protocols, evading DNS blocks and hosting their content wherever they could to make it accessible - included…

> The Pirate Bay and other torrent networks were built by people with a passion for building

Also by people who know that what they were doing was straight-up illegal in a lot of countries, and grey-area in a lot of others. So this was a real risk.

Parler on the other hand, at its core was just a social network, and if you look at the founders/owners, they have a very disconnected interpretation of "free speech", so they were clearly thinking nothing bad could happen.

Re: Pirate Bay founder thinks Parler’s inability to stay online is 'embarrassing'

#543

I personally don't find their ability to remain online that surprising. The Pirate Bay and other torrent networks were built by people with a passion for building, maintaining and hacking things. People who, even without a solid CS background, would spend hours a day learning new things, developing distributed protocols, evading DNS blocks and hosting their content wherever they could to make it accessible - included…

top kek

Re: Pirate Bay founder thinks Parler’s inability to stay online is 'embarrassing'

#544

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Someone put together an animated heatmap of Parler photo locations along the Mall throughout the day of 1/6: https://www.reddit.com/r/dataisbeautiful/comments/kvx88n/oc_...

Looks like this aged poorly https://twitter.com/ggreenwald/status/1348619731734028293

[deleted]

Re: Pirate Bay founder thinks Parler’s inability to stay online is 'embarrassing'

#545

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Looks like this aged poorly https://twitter.com/ggreenwald/status/1348619731734028293

Indeed. Greenwald helped Snowden; he has the chops to see what's going on. To wit, his subsequent tweet: Glenn Greenwald @ggreenwald Jan 11 Do you know how many of the people arrested in connection with the Capitol invasion were active users of Parler? Zero. The planning was largely done on Facebook. This is all a bullshit pretext for silencing competitors on ideological grounds: just the start.

That tweet seems to be incorrect.

https://twitter.com/nickmartin/status/1349277932531847174

> Hi Glenn, I'm wondering if you would be willing to delete this tweet and issue a correction both on Twitter and your newsletter since a number of the people arrested last week, including Jacob Chansley and Nicholas Ochs, were active users of Parler. Thanks!

Re: Pirate Bay founder thinks Parler’s inability to stay online is 'embarrassing'

#546

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Given the speed I’m guessing it was towards S3 so there’s plenty of terabytes.

Yes probably. Wherever it is, that provider is in an interesting legal position by holding this data. Also, I assume there is content from EU citizens in there, and so GDPR violations galore.

Agree with the legal implications. I would not go anywhere near this data.

I don’t think this relates to GDPR though. There are some exemptions for personal use which I think there are arguments this could fall into (IANAL). But my opinion is this isn’t in the spirit of GDPR.

There are many other laws that are broad enough in most countries to cover gray area scraping sadly. CFAA in the US for example. This sounds similar to the AT&T weev case.

Re: Pirate Bay founder thinks Parler’s inability to stay online is 'embarrassing'

#547

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> "I'm fine with all this stuff getting taken down" I understand this on a visceral level, but I wish more people would look beyond that to the implications for communication on the web. This action by Amazon happens to correspond with what I think is right and just on first iteration, but what principle prevents Amazon from arsing some other group that we agree with?

Aye. Relevant SSC: https://slatestarcodex.com/2013/12/29/the-spirit-of-the-firs... https://slatestarcodex.com/2017/03/24/guided-by-the-beauty-o...

After reading these beautiful articles I'm sadly wondering if we've already put the golden age behind us.

I will dig a little deeper to support archive.org[1] this year. I'd love to run a mirror.

[1] https://archive.org/donate/

Re: Pirate Bay founder thinks Parler’s inability to stay online is 'embarrassing'

#548
post #502
post #478

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The common excuse is "billing is heavily distributed and every product does it differently, so it's impossible to implement limits", but yeah, you're probably not the target audience.

Yes. A hard cost limit isn't a hard cost limit unless they start deleting resources like databases which has its own problems. One can imagine a semi-hard cost limit that only cuts off stateless services like EC2 and data egress but AWS apparently just doesn't care enough about courting customers like the GP to implement. I agree that there is some financial risk to using AWS although my understanding is that they're…

A googler recently commented here that, in order to forgive "bigger" bills, you really need to know someone to pull some heavy strings for you - and that it doesn't happen in many cases.

This taught me to be very very careful with this stuff, and to not bet on Google or Amazon being nice to me when I am bound to mess something up at some point - because with the complexity these services carry, it's no wonder people fall into cost traps all the time.

Re: Pirate Bay founder thinks Parler’s inability to stay online is 'embarrassing'

#549

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Camera vendors are perfectly capable of storing a lot of metadata in the jpeg encoded image itself, in an steganographic way. If you want to really be sure, crop your image to a position that is not multiple of 8 on any direction, then scale it by a factor very close to 1, add some noise, and re-compress it again. Some steganography is yet robust to that, but only the really fancy stuff. Anyhow, if your image shows r…

> Anyhow, if your image shows recognizable landmarks with shadows, then it will be feasible to recover the exact point of view and the time of acquisition. With what level of accuracy? Are you claiming you can confidently assert 2020-12-21 15:12 over, say, 2020-12-22 15:15 via shadows

The arc of the sun through the sky, along with observable weather and variability in air quality could let you pin the date down with surprising accuracy. Two neighboring dates with similar weather would obviously be very hard, but even variation in cloud patterns could be enough to make an id.

Re: Pirate Bay founder thinks Parler’s inability to stay online is 'embarrassing'

#550

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You're not a customer they want.

I might be the future customer they would want, if I were able to learn with no risk of costly errors what their platform can do and how to operate it.

Free tier gives you a ton of usage across most of the services, but definitely not enough to fully host a side project. But e.g. you can use RDS (database hosting), S3, EC2, text to speech and do whatever you want in a small scale for a year. It's kind of enough to learn for certificates.

I forgot to remove NAT Gateway for a few weeks while learning bits and pieces of VPC usage and it ended up costing me 25$... what can you do.

Post reply on HN