Live data from Hacker News

Never buy a .online domain

0xsid.com

511–513 of 513 posts

Re: Never buy a .online domain

#511
post #424

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Sometimes intent and outcomes matter, but the aphorism is simply not a good guide to understanding reality. It should be discarded. The classic example is a hospital for treating cancer patients. Suppose that one third of the patients are successfully treated, while the other two thirds die of their cancer. Is the purpose of the hospital to kill two thirds of the patients? Clearly not, but that is the outcome.

No, that is not what the hospital does, and thus based on this heuristic, it is not its purpose. What a system does is not the same as the context-free outcome. It is the outcome compared to the outcome that could be expected without the system. You have to define your priors. However, if the expected 5 year mortality for the cancer was 50%, and with this treatment 2/3 died, then the rule would apply. A choice to con…

Good! You are thinking! In principle something like this should be the right answer. (But we can simplify it by simply saying that we expect the hospital to improve outcomes, even though it cannot cure every patient.)

But no, the truth is that this hospital was built to provide jobs for civil servants https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x-5zEb1oS9A>. The purpose of a thing does not have to be related to the outcome.

Re: Never buy a .online domain

#512
The culprit here is the TLD operator. Why on Earth would they suspend a domain because of some private web browsing blocklist? FWIW, the client may not even bother with the web browsing; there are hundreds of other things we use DNS for.

Alas, the .tech domain is quite popular.

Re: Never buy a .online domain

#513
post #272
post #251

It's not about the .online TLD being "weird". The problem is that it was free. That's going to attract a swarm of fraudsters, spammers, etc, and then turn into a strong "this is probably fraud" signal in all kinds of fraud scoring systems. There are lots of domains out there other than .com that are just fine.

.online, .top, .xyz. info and .shop are some of the top TLDs that scammers use, precisely because of their rock bottom registrar fees that make them attractive for sites that have a shelf life of a few hours or a few days before being blocked. As a result, many places have a blanket "suspicious" flag for fresh domains under these TLDs. If you plan on building a legit site, do not use any of these cheap TLDs.

[dead]
Post reply on HN