Live data from Hacker News

Facebook Wants You To Snitch On Friends Not Using Their Real Name

paulbernal.wordpress.com

51–60 of 164 posts

Re: Facebook Wants You To Snitch On Friends Not Using Their Real Name

#51
post #5

If nothing else this might help put the kibosh on the intensely annoying way Facebook users tend to use cutesy fake names so that you don't know who the hell they are when they comment on your posts.

Or you could unfriend people you don't like to hang out with on Facebook.

Re: Facebook Wants You To Snitch On Friends Not Using Their Real Name

#52
post #51
post #5

If nothing else this might help put the kibosh on the intensely annoying way Facebook users tend to use cutesy fake names so that you don't know who the hell they are when they comment on your posts.

Or you could unfriend people you don't like to hang out with on Facebook.

I'd rather have Facebook fix the problem.

Re: Facebook Wants You To Snitch On Friends Not Using Their Real Name

#53
post #11

FTA: Indeed, under the terms of the Snoopers Charter, it wouldn’t just be Facebook who could access this kind of information: the authorities could potentially set up a filter to gather data on people who don’t confirm the names of their friends Yes, and I could potentially sprout wings from my ass and become a travel carrier. The rest of this article is nothing more than a ton of thinly veiled fallacies, slippery sl…

What is a "real" name vs. one that is not "real"? Did you mean legal name? And if so does that exclude legal aliases? What about Madonna, is that her 'real' name?

Apparently the name "Madonna" is real enough for Facebook (though they probably have exemptions for famous people).

https://www.facebook.com/madonna

Re: Facebook Wants You To Snitch On Friends Not Using Their Real Name

#54
post #41

Hey folks - I work on the Site Integrity team at Facebook. We work to keep people safe from scams, spam, fake accounts, and having their account taken over. We're always looking for ways to better understand how people represent themselves online and improve the design of our service. We look at the results of this kind of experiment in aggregate - the responses doesn't have any impact on the user account or that of…

[deleted]

Re: Facebook Wants You To Snitch On Friends Not Using Their Real Name

#55
We're setting a really bad precedent for the future here and these sorts of things need to stop now. Unfortunately, people don't seem to want to fight this.

Now we have people getting turned down for jobs because they DON'T have a facebook account[1]. What's next?

1. http://www.reddit.com/r/AskReddit/comments/109ipi/no_faceboo...

Re: Facebook Wants You To Snitch On Friends Not Using Their Real Name

#56
post #41

Hey folks - I work on the Site Integrity team at Facebook. We work to keep people safe from scams, spam, fake accounts, and having their account taken over. We're always looking for ways to better understand how people represent themselves online and improve the design of our service. We look at the results of this kind of experiment in aggregate - the responses doesn't have any impact on the user account or that of…

The best way people, especially kids, have to protect their future selves from things they write or post today, is by assuming a fake identity.

Kids are quickly learning that everything on the Internet is forever. Take the option of hiding their identity away from them, and I think they will move to a service that will allow this.

Re: Facebook Wants You To Snitch On Friends Not Using Their Real Name

#57
post #21

Enforcing real names has pros and cons. For Facebook as a business, the pros certainly outweigh the value lost when accounts can't be mapped directly to real people. Names are a key part of that mapping. In general, I prefer an option for pseudonymity, because it is much more inclusive (allowing certain people at the fringes to feel more comfortable joining in -- victims of abuse, political dissidents, etc), and is m…

One can also make the argument that the level of discourse is much higher on services where people are more personally accountable for what they say, and where confusing or offensive usernames don't get in the way of conversations. Based on the level of discourse here on hacker news and even on reddit, I don't think one can reasonably say that.

I don't personally agree with the argument, but I've seen it come up numerous times, first on Google Plus and now on Facebook.

Re: Facebook Wants You To Snitch On Friends Not Using Their Real Name

#58
post #41

Hey folks - I work on the Site Integrity team at Facebook. We work to keep people safe from scams, spam, fake accounts, and having their account taken over. We're always looking for ways to better understand how people represent themselves online and improve the design of our service. We look at the results of this kind of experiment in aggregate - the responses doesn't have any impact on the user account or that of…

Why are you deleting accounts of people who cosplay? It's mostly kids having fun playing dress up and taking photos and making plans to appear at conventions, all while calling themselves by anime-inspired names. When these kids lose their accounts, they also lose their connections with each other, connections which they spent a great deal of time and energy cultivating, and what's even worse is that it's difficult for them to reconnect, after creating new accounts with their real names, because they know each other only by their cosplay names. It's a nonsensical policy, which does little-to-nothing to keep these kids safe, and which rather effectively kills existing social circles.

example: http://japanimeclarinetist.deviantart.com/journal/They-delet...

article: http://dailydot.com/news/facebook-purges-cosplay-accounts (Facebook Purges Cosplay Accounts)(08/21/12)

Re: Facebook Wants You To Snitch On Friends Not Using Their Real Name

#59
post #55

We're setting a really bad precedent for the future here and these sorts of things need to stop now. Unfortunately, people don't seem to want to fight this. Now we have people getting turned down for jobs because they DON'T have a facebook account[1]. What's next? 1. http://www.reddit.com/r/AskReddit/comments/109ipi/no_faceboo...

No social media presence? Clearly you are a psychopathic recluse unfit for normal work.

We only want employees who do normal things, like obsessively refreshing a particular website all day long.

Re: Facebook Wants You To Snitch On Friends Not Using Their Real Name

#60
post #59
post #55

We're setting a really bad precedent for the future here and these sorts of things need to stop now. Unfortunately, people don't seem to want to fight this. Now we have people getting turned down for jobs because they DON'T have a facebook account[1]. What's next? 1. http://www.reddit.com/r/AskReddit/comments/109ipi/no_faceboo...

No social media presence? Clearly you are a psychopathic recluse unfit for normal work. We only want employees who do normal things, like obsessively refreshing a particular website all day long.

Brilliant!
Post reply on HN