Live data from Hacker News

Why We're Pulling Our Recommendation of Wyze Security Cameras

nytimes.com

51–60 of 115 posts

Re: Why We're Pulling Our Recommendation of Wyze Security Cameras

#51

Anyone have a recommendation for the an affordable security cameras that would works without a cloud? I want to replace a collection of Blink cameras. Looking for doorbell cam, indoor and outdoor. Home Automation integration a plus.

Reolink and Ubiquiti have good options that don't need the cloud.

Re: Why We're Pulling Our Recommendation of Wyze Security Cameras

#52

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The market for a product that requires the buyer to setup a VPN is not going to be very large. You seriously overestimate the average tech competence of people. It needs to be something you just plug in and it works.

I could, however, imagine you buying a "$BRAND hub" for your "$BRAND camera" and other $BRAND IoT that ostensibly set-ups a tailscale kinda thing you can access via the $BRAND App, all while not touching the cloud. It's ostensibly the same UX as the current cloud set-up, only without the operational costs of running a cloud service.

> I could, however, imagine you buying a "$BRAND hub" for your "$BRAND camera" and other $BRAND IoT that ostensibly set-ups a tailscale kinda thing you can access via the $BRAND App, all while not touching the cloud.

I'm confused by the use of the word "ostensibly" there. Do you mean that the makers would claim that it would set up a tailscale kinda thing for you while doing something completely different to avoid the cloud?

Re: Why We're Pulling Our Recommendation of Wyze Security Cameras

#53
I have a bunch of wyze gear, given the price I never assumed they were meant to replace a security system. What I have been doing with these cheap little cameras is getting me closer to nature.

We have a bunch of these outside and we've been watching the cats, possums, raccoons, and even turkeys frolic as they cross through our property. We even set up a little victorian style dog hours with solar panels in the backyard and the wild animals have been using it to rest. We have a ton of video of these little animals just relaxing and stretching out in the dog house too. The family loves it, every morning we get to see what the critters were up to.

Before that we were doing hydroponics and we had cameras on the fruits, the instruments for things like ph, ec, and a camera in the reservoir so we could monitor water levels.

I don't use them to watch my home, but they have been pretty solid in terms of watching other things that aren't security related or sensitive.

Re: Why We're Pulling Our Recommendation of Wyze Security Cameras

#54
post #51

Anyone have a recommendation for the an affordable security cameras that would works without a cloud? I want to replace a collection of Blink cameras. Looking for doorbell cam, indoor and outdoor. Home Automation integration a plus.

Reolink and Ubiquiti have good options that don't need the cloud.

Unfortunately Ubiquiti now requires you to buy into their proprietary NVR :/

Re: Why We're Pulling Our Recommendation of Wyze Security Cameras

#55
Wyze is honestly great. These cameras are a fraction of the price of everyone else. Their cloud service is a couple dollars a month per camera.

I have 2 looking out my windows at the front door and car. I move those to watch the dog when she stays home. I have one over my pool table to record shots. I've used them in the past to watch stray cats outside.

I am least happy with their outdoor cam since it doesn't do continuous recording and it requires a separate hub. I recommend the plugged in ones to everyone though.

Re: Why We're Pulling Our Recommendation of Wyze Security Cameras

#56
post #49

I hate Wyze so bad. They sell this really lovely and cheap IP-enabled camera, perfect for figuring out which cat was pissing in the basement. But to activate it requires your phone number, and then they spam you, forever after, with text messages from different numbers advertising their shit. Hate hate hate.

I have 6 of these and can't recall ever being texted. Just send STOP or update your preferences.

Same...

Re: Why We're Pulling Our Recommendation of Wyze Security Cameras

#57
They mention a 2023 report about unintentional access of others' cameras but this dates back to 2019 (I know this since I saved a video about it from an owner who demonstrated it, which is no longer on Youtube afaict). The video showed that while the official app couldn't display the feed if they asked Amazon Alexa to, it would.

Re: Why We're Pulling Our Recommendation of Wyze Security Cameras

#58

Anyone have a recommendation for the an affordable security cameras that would works without a cloud? I want to replace a collection of Blink cameras. Looking for doorbell cam, indoor and outdoor. Home Automation integration a plus.

amcrest is the best I found. 100 dollars, HD, power over ethernet. built-in http interface to grab videos / stream video. So you I just plugin ethernet cable camera gets an IP, and you can configure it to push videos at some interval to any server, or connect to stream for a live stream.

Aren't Amcrests just rebadged Dahuas with all the baggage?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dahua_Technology#Cybersecurity...

Re: Why We're Pulling Our Recommendation of Wyze Security Cameras

#59
post #51

Anyone have a recommendation for the an affordable security cameras that would works without a cloud? I want to replace a collection of Blink cameras. Looking for doorbell cam, indoor and outdoor. Home Automation integration a plus.

Reolink and Ubiquiti have good options that don't need the cloud.

Reolink is great. I'm about to add their PoE Video Doorbell. I already have two of their cameras connected to my Synology.

Re: Why We're Pulling Our Recommendation of Wyze Security Cameras

#60
post #2

I mean, any security camera that does anything with the cloud should never make it onto a recommendation list in the first place. I'm not sure if the product exists, but something that replicates a homemade setup would be amazing. Think of a bundled camera(s) + raspberry pi + 1tb backup drive or whatever that you can only access over your own dedicated personal wireguard vpn (or tailscale, something like that), but s…

Imagine the customer support costs of trying too help users troubleshoot VPN connection issues to their phones when they don't get their alerts.

And the huge mess of bad publicity, when someone breaks into a home, and as part of the theft, steals the device that has all the video of their crime.

Post reply on HN