Live data from Hacker News

Tell HN: Facebook Messenger is testing in-call video ads

news.ycombinator.com

51–60 of 87 posts

Re: Tell HN: Facebook Messenger is testing in-call video ads

#51

This makes 0 sense to me. There's literally no lock in with FB messenger. The second I get a video ad - that's it for FB video calls for me.

What do you mean? It's a messaging platform with built-in integration to the largest social network in the world. I couldn't possibly imagine a more textbook example of lock-in.

because it happens on a mobile phone, which already has a built-in way to do it.

"Hey mum, I decided to call you because that video ad bullshit is bullshit".

Re: Tell HN: Facebook Messenger is testing in-call video ads

#52

that's amazing... there are people in a meeting room at facebook believing this will increase revenue and the product owner of fb messenger said yes. lol

If the meeting was virtual they could "enjoy" being interrupted by their own adds. Dogfooding!

Re: Tell HN: Facebook Messenger is testing in-call video ads

#53

Assuming this is true, who comes up with ideas like this? If I was an advertiser do I really want to pay to have my ad (video nonetheless) shown to someone while they're actively trying to have a phone call? As a user, I'd just be pissed off at the advertiser plus im not looking at my screen when talking. I guess technically this increases ad "views" metrics. But advertisers are just wasting their money. I hope the f…

I wonder what would happen if there would be more "Karens", that would complain about this?

Looking at the screenshot, let's say it's a cat food ad... if that "Karen" would call the cat food company and complain that their ad wasted her time with an old relative, or whatever, and in turn waste that companies time... and multiply that with 10.000 karens,... but it needs people to actually be proactive about stuff like that.

Re: Tell HN: Facebook Messenger is testing in-call video ads

#54

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Is there a reason Signal couldn't put ads in their video call product?

I believe it is non-profit currently, so making money is not their top priority.

So why did they think they had to do the crypto token thing?

Re: Tell HN: Facebook Messenger is testing in-call video ads

#55
post #51

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What do you mean? It's a messaging platform with built-in integration to the largest social network in the world. I couldn't possibly imagine a more textbook example of lock-in.

because it happens on a mobile phone, which already has a built-in way to do it. "Hey mum, I decided to call you because that video ad bullshit is bullshit".

But that doesn't include video part of a videocall and in many cases (internationall calls) cost quite a lot still.

The main push from sms/mms and calling to messaging services was the free price and additional features.

Re: Tell HN: Facebook Messenger is testing in-call video ads

#57

that's amazing... there are people in a meeting room at facebook believing this will increase revenue and the product owner of fb messenger said yes. lol

Just tells you a lot a lot what to expect in Metaverse and the experience there.

Re: Tell HN: Facebook Messenger is testing in-call video ads

#59
Seems like a terrible idea. As others have pointed out, there are plenty of alternative platforms at hand that you can use for videochats, and I can't think of any that show intrusive video ads like this.

In the past, I've used Jitsi for when Facebook Messenger wasn't working for whatever reason.

Re: Tell HN: Facebook Messenger is testing in-call video ads

#60

Assuming this is true, who comes up with ideas like this? If I was an advertiser do I really want to pay to have my ad (video nonetheless) shown to someone while they're actively trying to have a phone call? As a user, I'd just be pissed off at the advertiser plus im not looking at my screen when talking. I guess technically this increases ad "views" metrics. But advertisers are just wasting their money. I hope the f…

This looks like the layout for the "Watch Together" feature: https://messengernews.fb.com/2020/09/14/feel-together-messen...

There's a bottom section that slides up and if a user clicks on one of the videos it will play for all participants. If anyone sees this and didn't intentionally click on one of those videos please file a bug!

Post reply on HN