Live data from Hacker News

Trump: 'A lot of people' think Edward Snowden 'not being treated fairly'

nypost.com

51–60 of 85 posts

Re: Trump: 'A lot of people' think Edward Snowden 'not being treated fairly'

#51

Earlier quoted context omitted.

EFF, who I do follow, has not criticized the withdraw. I don't know enough about Bernie or Clinton to know where they stand on the issue. Clinton's de-endorsement was probably not genuine so I'd bet she has criticisms of the withdraw. My main point is that an issue that was popular on the left (enough for Clinton to flip-flop on) seems to now be mostly the voices of the left criticizing the withdraw. There might be s…

Changing your mind or evolving your opinion is just "flip-flopping"?

In the immortal words of John F Kerry, “I did actually vote for it before I voted against it”

Re: Trump: 'A lot of people' think Edward Snowden 'not being treated fairly'

#52

Earlier quoted context omitted.

EFF, who I do follow, has not criticized the withdraw. I don't know enough about Bernie or Clinton to know where they stand on the issue. Clinton's de-endorsement was probably not genuine so I'd bet she has criticisms of the withdraw. My main point is that an issue that was popular on the left (enough for Clinton to flip-flop on) seems to now be mostly the voices of the left criticizing the withdraw. There might be s…

Changing your mind or evolving your opinion is just "flip-flopping"?

There was enough written about this specific issue to suggest it might be political opportunism. Of course it's also not fair to not let people actually change their mind.

https://www.politico.com/story/2016/10/hillary-clinton-trade...

Maybe flip-flopping is too loaded of a word and I shouldn't have used it.

Re: Trump: 'A lot of people' think Edward Snowden 'not being treated fairly'

#53
post #2

>In a 2013 tweet, Trump wrote: “Snowden is a spy who should be executed-but if it and he could reveal Obama’s records, I might become a major fan.” good god, that's one of the most Trumpish Trump tweets ever.

He's the same guy who endorsed the use of hydroxychloroquine as Covid-19 treatment by falsely claiming that it was safe and the FDA had approved it, and at least one person died after following his advice, so no surprise at all. He says what at the moment brings more approval without any care of the consequences. https://www.forbes.com/sites/tarahaelle/2020/03/23/man-dead-... ps. to 45' fanboys: a nice side effect of…

> at least one person died after following his advice

Correction: at least one democrat donor murdered her husband and used that advice as an excuse [1].

[1] https://nypost.com/2020/04/29/homicide-cops-investigate-deat...

Re: Trump: 'A lot of people' think Edward Snowden 'not being treated fairly'

#54
post #14

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If that were to happen I can imagine at least some people who were for his pardon in ‘14 would denounce the pardon if it came to be.

Trump should pardon Snowden because it's the right thing to do. He should also not be undercutting the post office, assassinating Iranian generals, enforcing tariffs on allies like Canada and Europe. Pardoning Snowden is a meaningless gesture, it does nothing to stop the military industrial complex and the intelligence apparatus that he supports

The only one I disagree with is cutting funding to USPS. Europe and Canada (nor anyone not specially exempted) should not enjoy advantage in trade. People were beside themselves over rumors of Russian snipers, this guy was directly responsible for troop deaths and much more instability in the ME. We’ve just seen peace agreements begin to bear fruit in the ME —would that have been possible with that guy stirring up hornets’s nests?

Re: Trump: 'A lot of people' think Edward Snowden 'not being treated fairly'

#55

Can someone explain why the GOP wants this? Isn't Snowden a disaster for them?

In no particular order.

1) Trump is very much not of fan of the sorts of shadowy warrant-less surveillance that snowed exposed (because he feels it was used against him) so this could be a dig at that apparatus.

2) Obama didn't pardon him despite doing so being far more popular on the left than right (at least up until present, no telling what will happen going forward) and this could force Biden in a tricky situation especially with the current public opinion situation

3) Snowden is controversial on the right (the anti-government crowd loves him) so this might be a move to strengthen his appearance among the fraction of the party who are alarmed by his authoritarian tendencies (cue joke about an NY Democrat in Republican's clothing).

4) His advisors who are paid to think about this stuff 40+hr a week have thought of something I haven't.

Re: Trump: 'A lot of people' think Edward Snowden 'not being treated fairly'

#56
post #37

That sounds suspiciously like he's considering pardoning Snowden. Also... going from calling for Snowden's execution to potentially pardoning him is one hell of a 180.

I think Snowden is a hero. Sadly, this feels more like Trump’s perverse “everything Obama did was bad so I’ll do the opposite” logic, instead of acknowledging that Edward Snowden made a difficult choice to protect our republic.

Trump's tweet, referenced at the end of the article, suggests that the decision on whether to execute or support Snowden depends on whether the revelations are politically useful to Trump's campaign:

> In a 2013 tweet, Trump wrote: “Snowden is a spy who should be executed-but if it and he could reveal Obama’s records, I might become a major fan.”

I still hope there is a pardon in the works though.

Re: Trump: 'A lot of people' think Edward Snowden 'not being treated fairly'

#57

Why now?

Well, if you start to think that there is something seriously wrong with State and the CIA, and they hate Snowden then you might want to consider that maybe you should look at the whole thing differently. Plus, he has some Republicans telling him to pardon Snowden.

That, and enough time has passed with Snowden in exile that it still carries the message the Intelligence Community wanted sent - ie. don't do this!

So, bringing him back to the US and pardoning him with "time served in exile", might be sufficient to make it more acceptable to a broader audience versus a 2014 pardon.

Re: Trump: 'A lot of people' think Edward Snowden 'not being treated fairly'

#58
post #54

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Trump should pardon Snowden because it's the right thing to do. He should also not be undercutting the post office, assassinating Iranian generals, enforcing tariffs on allies like Canada and Europe. Pardoning Snowden is a meaningless gesture, it does nothing to stop the military industrial complex and the intelligence apparatus that he supports

The only one I disagree with is cutting funding to USPS. Europe and Canada (nor anyone not specially exempted) should not enjoy advantage in trade. People were beside themselves over rumors of Russian snipers, this guy was directly responsible for troop deaths and much more instability in the ME. We’ve just seen peace agreements begin to bear fruit in the ME —would that have been possible with that guy stirring up ho…

The US has countless examples of covert operations that de-stabilised nations and killed other soldiers. Perhaps a cruise missile should be aimed at one of our generals, I'm sure you'd support that.

> We’ve just seen peace agreements begin to bear fruit in the ME —would that have been possible with that guy stirring hornets’s nests?

Syria is still a cluster, Palestine is more oppressed than ever, endless war in Yemen, slave labor in Qatar for the world cup. Kurds abandoned and slaughtered by Turkey. Iran has major instability issues, Pakistan and India have had a major skirmish (granted, not the ME, but it's close enough.)

Re: Trump: 'A lot of people' think Edward Snowden 'not being treated fairly'

#59

Can someone explain why the GOP wants this? Isn't Snowden a disaster for them?

In no particular order. 1) Trump is very much not of fan of the sorts of shadowy warrant-less surveillance that snowed exposed (because he feels it was used against him) so this could be a dig at that apparatus. 2) Obama didn't pardon him despite doing so being far more popular on the left than right (at least up until present, no telling what will happen going forward) and this could force Biden in a tricky situatio…

> because he feels it was used against him

It's seeming like this is quickly turning from a "he feels it was used against him" into an unequivocal "it was used against him".

Re: Trump: 'A lot of people' think Edward Snowden 'not being treated fairly'

#60
post #45

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I would love him to do so. We really need another wake up call in this country that the government routinely lies to us and that trusting our officials requires them proving they can be trusted. Remember, Snowden has been out of this country since May of 2013 and the last Administration did not pardon him but instead did pardon Manning whose actions were more reckless. It really comes down to the fact Snowden really…

Manning stood to face her her crimes like a long line of revered civil disobedients before her. Snowden ran away into the arms of a hostile foreign power. That has just as much to do with pissing off the government as what either of them revealed.

The laws that would out Snowden and Manning in prison for life are unjust and there's nothing wrong with what either of them did. I don't blame Snowden for leaving a country full of idiots calling for his death
Post reply on HN