Live data from Hacker News

YouTube top earners: A seven-year-old making $22M

bbc.com

51–60 of 325 posts

Re: YouTube top earners: A seven-year-old making $22M

#51
post #29

My 7 year old son watches Dude Perfect on YouTube, which I had never heard of. Apparently its all the rage, in elementary schools and he heard about it via other kids. I watched a few to make sure they were ok, but they mostly came off as older guys doing elaborate stunts that kids would do on a much smaller scale (like throwing balls off tall buildings, fat suits on cars, etc ) I'm not shocked they are making $20M o…

My six year old has started running around the house without his shirt, lifting things and drinking milk so that he can be all swole. That or he watches chrisfix videos on how to repair the car.

I highly recommend the chrisfix videos, btw. We've both learned a lot about cars.

Re: YouTube top earners: A seven-year-old making $22M

#52
There are so many things wrong with youtube such as accountability, standards and advertising value. These problems get even weirder when kids are involved.

Obviously the reason this kid is making 22m is because other kids are watching. Which isn't bad. This kid basically won the lottery and good for him.

But then you have things like elsagate which is/was (idk if it's over) so weird. I still don't know what the hell was going on there. I can only assume that, once again, kids are mindlessly watching these videos and that's fairly disturbing.

Also I am curious about what people that buy ad spots on youtube think about the fact that a lot of the views they're paying for are kids that won't care about products like their makeup or adult oriented products/services.

Re: YouTube top earners: A seven-year-old making $22M

#53

What I find interesting is that many of these youtubers have created personas to appeal to their audience, like true entertainers. However loyal viewers are fooled into this false sense of reality, where they are friends with content creator and this is not a persona at all, he's my friend. Over time, the content creator and the audience share so many moments together, it becomes an emotional bond and a substitute fo…

> Over time, the content creator and the audience share so many moments together, it becomes an emotional bond and a substitute for people's social needs. I've wondered about this for podcasts too. I noticed a scary habit where I would play podcasts when I was feeling lonely. Over time, you feel like you're pals with the hosts and something about the audio format checks the social needs box in your brain, thinking th…

I do this with The Office. Playing The Office on Netflix feels a bit like having friends over.

Re: YouTube top earners: A seven-year-old making $22M

#54

What I find interesting is that many of these youtubers have created personas to appeal to their audience, like true entertainers. However loyal viewers are fooled into this false sense of reality, where they are friends with content creator and this is not a persona at all, he's my friend. Over time, the content creator and the audience share so many moments together, it becomes an emotional bond and a substitute fo…

> Over time, the content creator and the audience share so many moments together, it becomes an emotional bond and a substitute for people's social needs. I've wondered about this for podcasts too. I noticed a scary habit where I would play podcasts when I was feeling lonely. Over time, you feel like you're pals with the hosts and something about the audio format checks the social needs box in your brain, thinking th…

There is a good reason why the Kardashians are incredibly successful. They are able to convince their viewers they are part of the family with their shows. I think its because you feel included since most of the show is back-and-forth gossip on family issues where its common for the people in the scene to try and find a solution to a problem where the problem person is excluded from the conversation. As a result, I think the viewer feels more welcome than even one of their family members.

Once hooked, the kardashians make bank because they can sell their fans laxative teas or hair growth gummy bears on instagram through huge ad endorsements

Re: YouTube top earners: A seven-year-old making $22M

#55
post #30

I just watched a few minutes of "Ryan disappear[s] through a Secret Portal in the house to the North Pole" and am thoroughly impressed. Clearly a lot goes into the concepts, sets, and overall production of these videos. I don't know all of the details, but I can imagine how building a business like this could be one of the cooler ways for a family to spend quality time together.

These YouTube families are great. I hope they keep perspective though and don't go all Disney child actor. I mean maybe they can have hollywood careers etc but kids need to be kids.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FamilyOFive

Except when the youtube families use child abuse to generate controversy and views...

Re: YouTube top earners: A seven-year-old making $22M

#56
post #29

My 7 year old son watches Dude Perfect on YouTube, which I had never heard of. Apparently its all the rage, in elementary schools and he heard about it via other kids. I watched a few to make sure they were ok, but they mostly came off as older guys doing elaborate stunts that kids would do on a much smaller scale (like throwing balls off tall buildings, fat suits on cars, etc ) I'm not shocked they are making $20M o…

Which isn't too bad because it's basically a tv show at that point. They have multiple hosts, cameramen, sets, etc. There's probably quite a few people working on those shows and they probably burn through that 20m pretty quick.

Re: YouTube top earners: A seven-year-old making $22M

#57

Something still feels wrong about something that takes comaparatively so little effort making so much money. I’m not saying it’s easy but it’s much much easier than many other proffesions. Think of software engineers slaving over brilliant designs staying up night after night for a few hundred thousand per year, or even NFL stars that expose their brains to permanent damage. It’s almost like a new form of the lottery…

Or think of villagers in rural Africa or India, doing intense manual labor all day for little playoff and a premature death. Unfortunately, life's brutal and unfair. You could take your savings and put it all on 28 in roulette, and hey, maybe you too can have massive payout for minimal effort.

Re: YouTube top earners: A seven-year-old making $22M

#58

Something still feels wrong about something that takes comaparatively so little effort making so much money. I’m not saying it’s easy but it’s much much easier than many other proffesions. Think of software engineers slaving over brilliant designs staying up night after night for a few hundred thousand per year, or even NFL stars that expose their brains to permanent damage. It’s almost like a new form of the lottery…

So much of life is just blind luck. Like finding a big source of oil on a bunch of land in the middle of nowhere worth nothing.

Re: YouTube top earners: A seven-year-old making $22M

#59

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm not sure if you're being serious, but that video was honestly minimal amount of effort when it came to effects, sets and production. There are channels on Youtube with a fraction of the following that produce content orders of magnitude more professional than that. This kind of video can be made by some amateur producer in their bedroom. Considering they make 22M, you'd really think they'd spend money on at least…

OTOH, maybe the family enjoys doing as much as possible themselves. If everything needs to be professionalized, where does that leave the hobbyists and the amateurs? Should there not be room for them? If not, why?

Not disagreeing with you per se, but if you're making $22 million off something, I'm not sure the terms "hobbyist" or "amateur" apply there.

Re: YouTube top earners: A seven-year-old making $22M

#60

I just watched a few minutes of "Ryan disappear[s] through a Secret Portal in the house to the North Pole" and am thoroughly impressed. Clearly a lot goes into the concepts, sets, and overall production of these videos. I don't know all of the details, but I can imagine how building a business like this could be one of the cooler ways for a family to spend quality time together.

That's not my experience with Ryan's Toy Review videos.

My son watches these, a little less than he used to, but still.

They're mostly about him goofing off (using toys) with his family. I'm sure there're some that are scripted, but a large majority of them are just him being a kid.

Post reply on HN