Live data from Hacker News

U.S. to dismantle system tracking Atlantic currents that are at risk of collapse

e360.yale.edu

441–450 of 540 posts

Re: U.S. to dismantle system tracking Atlantic currents that are at risk of collapse

#441
post #267
post #233

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> if you were playing basketball and Lebron James walked by and you threw the ball to him Yes, this is a terrible analogy for the war in Iran. Hugely unpopular, costing Americans vast sums of money daily, headed for possible catastrophe. Very much not a low-stakes "Lebron walks by" situation. Better analogy with Lebron would be: championship game with a title on the line. He gets possession as time runs down and the…

I will remember from now on that you can compare war to Lebron playing in a championship game but not to him playing in a pickup game. But to be clear, the comment I replied to was one in which you made an abstract point that it doesn't make a difference to someone if you can do something but in practice don't/aren't willing to and I think that this is obviously wrong (just because Lebron didn't dunk doesn't mean he…

His statement about war and politics is a reference to Clausewitz, the famous military strategist that apparently you have not read nor have heard referenced, which is surprising given how often this quote comes up in military-political discussions, articles, and books.

(It’s ok, nobody in the administration has read him either. And before you accuse me of partisan hackery, the prior admin was just as incompetent.)

Re: U.S. to dismantle system tracking Atlantic currents that are at risk of collapse

#442

Earlier quoted context omitted.

He did not tell anyone to do these things nor do I claim he did. He did ask his staff to "look into" whether either of these sanitation methods "could be used inside the human body", which is a bit like if I asked my doctor if I could eat laundry soap and shampoo instead of showering and doing laundry. The very fact that these ideas exist inside a US president's skull is VERY SAD. THANK YOU FOR YOUR ATTENTION TO THIS…

Again, no quotes. But even as-is the idea of using ultraviolet to disinfect internal surfaces is not bonkers to any degree. Like I could see it working for nasal disinfection. In fact that's so obvious, that given you get very sad that someone else could even consider that tells me that you don't really know what you are talking about. Ironically, unlike Trump. Won't comment on the bleach one without a quote though.

It is absolutely bonkers to think about using UV to disinfect human skin, let alone the inside of the human body.

Any UV radiation strong enough to destroy the cells of bacteria is strong enough to destroy human cells. We know that UV-radiaton that's not strong enough to kill bacteria is already harmful to human skin (we call the phenomenon sunburn).

Re: U.S. to dismantle system tracking Atlantic currents that are at risk of collapse

#443

Earlier quoted context omitted.

No, climate is perhaps my least aligned issue with this administration. I may end up voting Democrats next time, we'll have to see how bad their platform is again. I just wish I could vote to protect our climate and our borders at once.

What's your second least aligned issue?

Tax cuts benefitting the wealthy, I suppose. It's not a close second though, I care a lot about the environment.

Re: U.S. to dismantle system tracking Atlantic currents that are at risk of collapse

#444
post #59
post #11

Earlier quoted context omitted.

For real. Cant fix stupid. Its so sad.

Assuming the interlocutor is stupid, at any scale, 1-1 to the whole of american politics probably just highlight that you don't fully grasp their point of view, because then it wouldn't be stupid. You'd be able to explain it to them and get them to see the matter from your perspective. If you can't do that, then you don't know you're right, you might be, but there's no way for you to know, truly.

So you are defending the move? Why rip out basic science for no benefit other than to signal that you don't care for it if it goes against your narrative? Seems 100% stupid but I am open to your interpretation.

Re: U.S. to dismantle system tracking Atlantic currents that are at risk of collapse

#445
post #397

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Not at all. Iran was rewarded with progressive sanction relief and progressive unblocking of their own money that was seized decades ago, as long as they continued cooperating.

They only had to cooperate until January 2026, then they were free to carry on with their nuclear ambitions.

This is a great example of where the Israeli perspective diverges from the American.

The classic American perspective wouldn't worry about that because being part of our market is so attractive. There is a win-win here, they are not mindless orcs.

Re: U.S. to dismantle system tracking Atlantic currents that are at risk of collapse

#446

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I mean, I guess? I don't really feel like I needed to be taught that tariffs would raise prices. I'm not some hypergenius, it really seems pretty obvious to me.

You are engaged in a hacker news debate after 11 PM. You are not exactly a spitting image of the average American adult.

No one has ever accused me of being "average", I'm definitely a weird dude.

I don't think I'm that smart though.

Re: U.S. to dismantle system tracking Atlantic currents that are at risk of collapse

#447

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Again, no quotes. But even as-is the idea of using ultraviolet to disinfect internal surfaces is not bonkers to any degree. Like I could see it working for nasal disinfection. In fact that's so obvious, that given you get very sad that someone else could even consider that tells me that you don't really know what you are talking about. Ironically, unlike Trump. Won't comment on the bleach one without a quote though.

have a read for yourself: https://trumpwhitehouse.archives.gov/briefings-statements/re... As for me, I don't think you need a phd to read the warning stickers on bleach and isoproponal which say "do not injest" [2] [3] or warnings on germicidal lamps that say "do not expose to eyes or skin" [4]. If you do or have otherwise hidden knowledge why these should be ignored, say so. [2] https://www.thecloroxcompany.com/wp-c…

Why do I have to present evidence for something I'm not claiming? Your response fits the picture drawn by the comment on out of context.

> As for me, I don't think you need a phd to read the warning stickers on bleach and isoproponal which say "do not injest"

Yes, but you need more brainpower to understand that these warnings are for specific products and can't be generalized without research. The concept that dangerous substances are widely used in medicine in right quantities with right delivery methods is rather well known, and since you don't appear to grasp the connection after multiple comments alluding to it... well, that doesn't paint your opinion about Trump in a good light.

Re: U.S. to dismantle system tracking Atlantic currents that are at risk of collapse

#448
post #436

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The JCPOA agreements were set to expire in January 2026 - and then Iran could continue their nuclear ambitions. The only people who could support those agreements either: 1. Didn't read them and know that they expire in 10 years. 2. Think that 10 years is a long enough time in the future where whatever happens then doesn't matter to their current goals. 3. Would like to see a nuclear-capable Iran. For what it's worth…

Or alternatively, in 2026 Iran would have been hooked on closer economic cooperation and trade, (relative) reformers would be in power, and the deal would have been renewed. Yanking the deal all but guaranteed that the hardliners would go back in charge, because they were proven right - the US could not be trusted to keep its word, so negotiations don't matter, the only thing that would actually protect them is nucle…

  > Or alternatively, in 2026 Iran would have been hooked on closer economic cooperation and trade, (relative) reformers would be in power, and the deal would have been renewed.
Oh, so you expect to change their culture and their value system. And do that in only 10 years.

That's called imperialism. I believe it's no longer fashionable.

Re: U.S. to dismantle system tracking Atlantic currents that are at risk of collapse

#449

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Again, no quotes. But even as-is the idea of using ultraviolet to disinfect internal surfaces is not bonkers to any degree. Like I could see it working for nasal disinfection. In fact that's so obvious, that given you get very sad that someone else could even consider that tells me that you don't really know what you are talking about. Ironically, unlike Trump. Won't comment on the bleach one without a quote though.

It is absolutely bonkers to think about using UV to disinfect human skin, let alone the inside of the human body. Any UV radiation strong enough to destroy the cells of bacteria is strong enough to destroy human cells. We know that UV-radiaton that's not strong enough to kill bacteria is already harmful to human skin (we call the phenomenon sunburn).

What do you know, certain forms of UV are used to disinfect skin. Too bad the developers of the concept didn't care at the moment they are "bonkers".

https://www.canada.ca/en/public-health/services/diseases/201...

> UV-C has demonstrated the ability to effectively and safely inactivate the SARS-CoV-2 virus up to 99.9%

> There are four methods to disinfect the air with UVGI technologies: 1) ..., 2) irradiating the full room, whole-room far UV-C when rooms are occupied 3) ...

Truly, the lack of critical thinking in the left meme reposters was the main cause of dems losing the last election. You guys are pretty successful in demonstrating that.

Re: U.S. to dismantle system tracking Atlantic currents that are at risk of collapse

#450

Earlier quoted context omitted.

They only had to cooperate until January 2026, then they were free to carry on with their nuclear ambitions.

This is a great example of where the Israeli perspective diverges from the American. The classic American perspective wouldn't worry about that because being part of our market is so attractive. There is a win-win here, they are not mindless orcs.

>The Israeli perspective assumes the muslims are mindless orcs that can't be reasoned with as humans.

It seems that the American perspective after 9/11 has become more or less the same.

Post reply on HN