Live data from Hacker News

Ex-GitHub CEO launches a new developer platform for AI agents

entire.io

401–410 of 625 posts

Re: Ex-GitHub CEO launches a new developer platform for AI agents

#402

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What kind of barrier/moat/network effects/etc would prevent someone with a Claude Code subscription from replicating whatever "innovation" is so uniquely valuable here? It's somewhat strange to regularly read HN threads confidently asserting that the cost of software is trending towards zero and software engineering as a profession is dead, but also that an AI dev tool that basically hooks onto Git/Claude Code/termin…

> HN threads confidently asserting I have never seen any thread that unanimously asserts this. Even if they do, having HN/reddit asserting something as evidence is wrong way to look at things.

  > if you can't see the value in this, I don't know what to tell you
Okay, but I'm legitimately unclear on the argument for $60M - $300M value here, given it isn't articulated at all.

Re: Ex-GitHub CEO launches a new developer platform for AI agents

#403

Earlier quoted context omitted.

the best time to learn anything is tomorrow when a better model will be better at doing the same work doesn’t that presume no value is being delivered by current models? I can understand applying this logic to building a startup that solves today’s ai shortcomings… but value delivered today is still valuable even if it becomes more effective tomorrow.

I think it also presumes that the skills of today won't be helpful in making you better, faster, stronger at knowing what to learn tomorrow. Skateboarding ain't snowboarding but I guarantee the experience helps.

Yeah but neither makes a difference to taking a taxi.

And your skills at catching a cab don't matter for booking a self driving car online.

Re: Ex-GitHub CEO launches a new developer platform for AI agents

#404

> Checkpoints are a new primitive that automatically captures agent context as first-class, versioned data in Git. When you commit code generated by an agent, Checkpoints capture the full session alongside the commit: the transcript, prompts, files touched, token usage, tool calls and more. This thread is extremely negative - if you can't see the value in this, I don't know what to tell you.

What kind of barrier/moat/network effects/etc would prevent someone with a Claude Code subscription from replicating whatever "innovation" is so uniquely valuable here? It's somewhat strange to regularly read HN threads confidently asserting that the cost of software is trending towards zero and software engineering as a profession is dead, but also that an AI dev tool that basically hooks onto Git/Claude Code/termin…

> What kind of barrier/moat/network effects/etc would prevent someone with a Claude Code subscription from replicating whatever "innovation" is so uniquely valuable here?

You are correct, that isn't the moat. Writing the software is the easy part

Re: Ex-GitHub CEO launches a new developer platform for AI agents

#406

I had a similar, admitted poorly thought out idea a few months back. I wanted to more or less build Jira for agents and track the context there. If I had to guess 60 million is just enough to build the POC out. I don't see how this can compete though, Open AI or Anthro could easily spin up a competitor internally.

In what world do you need $60M to build a POC of whatever this is supposed to be?

Re: Ex-GitHub CEO launches a new developer platform for AI agents

#408
post #372
post #56

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Founder here. I built commercial insurance software for Windows 95 in the 1990s, driver assistant systems at Mercedes and at Bosch in the early 2000s, dozens of iPhone apps as contractor, a startup called HockeyApp (acquired by Microsoft), and various smaller projects, mostly in Ruby on Rails. And of course, when I left Microsoft & GitHub, 10 years of green boxes were removed from my GitHub profile.

Glad to see you commenting here despite the, er, unsubstantive disposition of some of the commenters! (I'm a mod here btw.) We really don't like it when the audience responds to new things with snark and dismissiveness, and there are rules in https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html to make that clear. In this case I think the root problem is that the OP ( https://entire.io/blog/hello-entire-world/ ) is the w…

Makes sense, and we definitely will have more technical posts coming soon and on a regular basis. And I am German, I am used to snark. :P Joking aside, thanks for the response and appreciate your work as a mod!

Re: Ex-GitHub CEO launches a new developer platform for AI agents

#410

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's the dead internet theory in action. Every time I see slop I comment on it. I've found people don't always like it when you comment on it.

Yes I usually just bite my tongue and downvote, but with the launch of open claw I think the amount of slop has increased dramatically and I think we need to deal with it sooner than later.

Do you really think openclaw is to blame? I shudder to think of how few protections HN has against bots like that.
Post reply on HN