Live data from Hacker News

Google breaks 2005 promise never to show banner ads on search results

theguardian.com

41–50 of 211 posts

Re: Google breaks 2005 promise never to show banner ads on search results

#41

This isn't a banner ad. This is essentially a branded search. It's not like Google is targeting users with Flash-based crud here. To call it a banner ad is kind of silly.

What exactly would you call it then, if not a banner ad? It's a large, colorful, rectangular 5:1 panel that advertises a company. Cut the doublespeak.

Re: Google breaks 2005 promise never to show banner ads on search results

#42
The full quote is still true.

"There will be no banner ads on the Google homepage or web search results pages. There will not be crazy, flashy, graphical doodads flying and popping up all over the Google site. Ever." -Marissa Mayer

That "banner" is not a "crazy, flashy, graphical doodad". That is pretty much the company's logo.

Re: Google breaks 2005 promise never to show banner ads on search results

#43

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Only one ad without Adblock. http://i.imgur.com/pQqF9uz.png Maybe check to see if you have some malware inserting ads?

Google's result do not follow a person-agnostic algorithm, so he may get 20 ads and you only 1. As a matter of fact, I get none.

Language is the biggest influencing factor, at least for me.

I get zero ads if I search for “trash can” but an ridiculous amount of ads if I search for “Mülltonne” (German for “trash can”), all because I’m searching on http://google.de/.

Screenshots: http://imgur.com/a/Yco1R#0

(Hey, the German results leak the city I’m currently staying at. The first organic result is a form to sign up for the city’s garbage collection.)

Re: Google breaks 2005 promise never to show banner ads on search results

#45

Corporate promises aren't worth a dime as history has shown repeatedly. In fact, corporations (especially large ones) can't ever be trusted for pretty much anything and anything they say or do you should always react sceptically by default. They just don't care, and this lack of caring is an inevitability for growing corporations. Granted some might consider this to be a minor breach of a promise, some might not. The…

No, no, no.

You can absolutely trust them if they are say "we are doing this to maximize profits for our share holders / owners".

Then, what is this expectation that one should be able to trust them to do anything else at all? Surely the mere existence of consumer law should tell us something.

Re: Google breaks 2005 promise never to show banner ads on search results

#46

Over the years Google is way more aggressive with ads then it used to be. For any query less and less percentage of first page is dedicate to organic example. E.g. a silly example: https://www.google.com/search?q=trash+can 25-30% organic, rest are the adds.

Only one ad without Adblock. http://i.imgur.com/pQqF9uz.png Maybe check to see if you have some malware inserting ads?

[deleted]

Re: Google breaks 2005 promise never to show banner ads on search results

#47

Not the first time, I must add. When Orkut was all the rage, Google claimed that Orkut would never be merged with the Google core and would remain separate to Google. The same seems tobe happening with YouTube. Sure, they still allow users to keep their YT & Google identities separate but IDK how long that will last. Remember when they claimed their motto was 'Don't be evil'? (NB: Before you come screaming at me for…

Umm they forced me(as in I wasn't able to use youtube otherwise) to connect my Google account to my Youtube so...that is pretty much combining the accounts in my book.

I think, they just needed that to collect my aggregate search+video watching behavior for ad targeting, which they got.

Re: Google breaks 2005 promise never to show banner ads on search results

#48

This isn't a banner ad. This is essentially a branded search. It's not like Google is targeting users with Flash-based crud here. To call it a banner ad is kind of silly.

It's an ad with a picture as a banner across a significant portion of the browser window. Ducks, quacking, etc.

Re: Google breaks 2005 promise never to show banner ads on search results

#49

The full quote is still true. "There will be no banner ads on the Google homepage or web search results pages. There will not be crazy, flashy, graphical doodads flying and popping up all over the Google site. Ever." -Marissa Mayer That "banner" is not a "crazy, flashy, graphical doodad". That is pretty much the company's logo.

Google ran a crazy flashy graphical doodad ad for nexus 7 on the Google home page.
Post reply on HN