Live data from Hacker News

Reddit, Boston and the missing student

newstatesman.com

41–50 of 71 posts

Re: Reddit, Boston and the missing student

#41
post #19
post #8

Sunil Tripathi (or his parents) would do well to take legal action against Reddit for facilitating this garbage, if the final legal reports support the assessment that Sunil was not involved.

Didn't Reddit make a big show of banning doxxing a while back? Super effective. There should be multiple lawsuits here.

doxxing of usernames is banned. doxxing of non-Reddit entities is not covered by policy.

Re: Reddit, Boston and the missing student

#43
post #38

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's nothing to do with the free internet. Accusing someone of murder with absolutely no proof could be considered libel. Edi: I wasn't accusing Reddit of libel. It's just a platform. The individuals who posted the comments would be the ones committing libel.

It might be libel in the U.K., but the standard for such is a bit higher in the U.S. Which is probably a good thing, on the whole, as otherwise we'd have had to destroy the Internet ten years ago based on its usage as a libel-launching platform.

Is releasing photos of someone and accusing them of murder really not considered libel in the US? It seems like quite an extreme case of libel to me (although IANAL).

Re: Reddit, Boston and the missing student

#44

Earlier quoted context omitted.

To be fair though, 90% of reddit is the "reddit hivemind".

Yes, this seems to be the nature of communities both online and offline. A community becomes known for something like hipsters in Brooklyn, cat memes in Reddit, or motherhood paraphernalia in Pinterest. More people of the demographic with the same mindset join and stay, whereas everyone else feel unwelcome and gradually leave.

I left Reddit a while back because I felt this way. I'm a conservative and on that site it's like being a social pariah. I'd rather just keep my thoughts to myself from now on.

Re: Reddit, Boston and the missing student

#45
The reddit thread started with good intents. From what I saw (and I didn't follow it very much) the goal was to name possible suspects. They did this by look for people with large backpacks who were later seen without them.

The problem is that redditors are your average everyday people. Some people don't understand that "possible suspect" doesn't mean "this guy is a terrorist, get him". This mentality is not just reddit. It exist in our country already. Each time a suspect is pictured on TV, they already guilty in the minds of many viewers. It seems that most people don't understand our "innocent until proven guilty" justice system.

Re: Reddit, Boston and the missing student

#47
post #25

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm honestly surprised to see this opinion on HN, the defender of the free Internet. Should the family also take legal action against the ISPs of the Reddit users involved, simply for "facilitating" this garbage?

It's nothing to do with the free internet. Accusing someone of murder with absolutely no proof could be considered libel. Edi: I wasn't accusing Reddit of libel. It's just a platform. The individuals who posted the comments would be the ones committing libel.

Except that accusation has not been made by the entity "Reddit" but by individual people.

Making that distinction may be hard for fossilized media and politicians, but it should come natural to anybody on HN.

Re: Reddit, Boston and the missing student

#48
post #25

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm honestly surprised to see this opinion on HN, the defender of the free Internet. Should the family also take legal action against the ISPs of the Reddit users involved, simply for "facilitating" this garbage?

It's nothing to do with the free internet. Accusing someone of murder with absolutely no proof could be considered libel. Edi: I wasn't accusing Reddit of libel. It's just a platform. The individuals who posted the comments would be the ones committing libel.

Giving someone a medium for free speech is NOT the same as committing the act of libel. If they did want to sue it should be against the OP/commentors, not the site.

Re: Reddit, Boston and the missing student

#49
post #19
post #8

Sunil Tripathi (or his parents) would do well to take legal action against Reddit for facilitating this garbage, if the final legal reports support the assessment that Sunil was not involved.

Didn't Reddit make a big show of banning doxxing a while back? Super effective. There should be multiple lawsuits here.

Lawsuits based on what? Sure there could be lawsuits but none of them should be against the site itself.

Re: Reddit, Boston and the missing student

#50
If we are going to blame "reddit" and "the internet", are we also blaming "the media" for the cnn false report and the nypost cover photo?

I have a hard time finding the collective responsibility of "the internet" materially different from "the media".

Post reply on HN