Live data from Hacker News

Reddit, Boston and the missing student

newstatesman.com

11–20 of 71 posts

Re: Reddit, Boston and the missing student

#12
post #2

Really? Someone in the news media pointing fingers at others for reporting bad information?

Yes? And the criticism is somehow invalid? Now, with CNN's fuckups as of late, I could see getting livid about them specifically pointing fingers. While I hate mainstream media organs, I'm perfectly fine with anyone taking on mob justice. Even hypocrites.

Re: Reddit, Boston and the missing student

#13
post #6

I find it funny when people talk about reddit, 4chan, etc as a single group. "Reddit should really not do this". Really? It's like saying Brooklyn should really stop being so hipster. Not only is it a very small portion of the entire group, but they aren't about to stop doing what they're doing because of a few articles.

To be fair though, 90% of reddit is the "reddit hivemind".

Yes, this seems to be the nature of communities both online and offline. A community becomes known for something like hipsters in Brooklyn, cat memes in Reddit, or motherhood paraphernalia in Pinterest. More people of the demographic with the same mindset join and stay, whereas everyone else feel unwelcome and gradually leave.

Re: Reddit, Boston and the missing student

#15
This will be a new facet of our culture. This crisis has been a landmark crisis, one that has paralyzed Boston for 5 days and which highlights all these systems for information distribution. I can't imagine how many new users Reddit will have after today.

People needed a way to deal with this. I also went through all the reddit examples. I found them to be unconvincing but the act of looking for the guy made me feel much better.

Until you walk the mile to work looking at every single person with a backpack hoping they are not about to bomb a T station, you don't know what that it is like.

The police and media need to deal with reddit by making better information available faster. Reddit is their competition now and they should recognize it as a disruptive force. Just like Uber, I don't want it regulated away.

Blaming "reddit" is ridiculous. We should put the blame on inept reporting and far too slow of reporting from police. Had they done their jobs faster, Reddit would have been worthless.

[edit] phrasing

[Added] Clearly from the up and down voting I have been getting, my comment is highly polarizing for this community.

My point is simple: Reddit, digital cameras and the internet is here to stay. This new reality means that we need to embrace natural human behavior as best as possible and only attempt to adjust it whenever 100% necessary. I get that people here think it should be adjusted, but I feel that the police and media should change their strategy first, then see what happens on reddit etc. over the long term.

The release of random information to different media groups including leaks and not maintaining constant contact with the public through an official forum should be viewed as unacceptable.

Re: Reddit, Boston and the missing student

#16
post #6

I find it funny when people talk about reddit, 4chan, etc as a single group. "Reddit should really not do this". Really? It's like saying Brooklyn should really stop being so hipster. Not only is it a very small portion of the entire group, but they aren't about to stop doing what they're doing because of a few articles.

To be fair though, 90% of reddit is the "reddit hivemind".

Source?

Re: Reddit, Boston and the missing student

#17
I feel so sorry for the Tripathis. Apart from their son/brother being missing they just got put through hell for 24 hours. Sadly, Reddit can't offer up a collective apology.

In light of what we know, this Reddit thread makes for such sad reading. http://www.reddit.com/r/boston/comments/1cn9ga/is_missing_st...

Re: Reddit, Boston and the missing student

#18
post #4

[deleted]

And anyone in the vicinity of the dartboard is going to get hurt. And they were wrong on all counts. No bullseyes.

>> And they were wrong on all counts. No bullseyes.

The silver lining to this 0% hit rate is that it might actually provoke some soul searching among the respective communities. That would probably be less possible if there had been a bullseye hidden away somewhere.

Re: Reddit, Boston and the missing student

#19
post #8

Sunil Tripathi (or his parents) would do well to take legal action against Reddit for facilitating this garbage, if the final legal reports support the assessment that Sunil was not involved.

Didn't Reddit make a big show of banning doxxing a while back? Super effective. There should be multiple lawsuits here.
Post reply on HN