Live data from Hacker News

My favourite German word

vurt.org

41–50 of 96 posts

Re: My favourite German word

#41
I find it mildly amusing that the article makes the following point regarding "Gegenstand":

> Objects aren’t just inert stuff – they do something.

...while many words in Germany are just "stuff" (Zeug). A plane is a Fly-Stuff (Flugzeug). A lighter is a Fire-Stuff (Feuerzeug). A vehicle is a Drive-Stuff (Fahrzeug). A toy is a Play-Stuff (Spielzeug). And the list goes on!

Re: My favourite German word

#43
Gegenstand would probably be better translated as “a stand around”.

A “stand against” would be a Widerstand, which also exists.

Update: Interestingly the etymology is really “ stand against”, you always leans something here.

Re: My favourite German word

#45
post #36

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Wiederstand - resistor https://generalatomic.com/teil1/index.html

*Widerstand Wider = gegen (against) Wieder = noch einmal (again) Kinda important to get the spelling right in context of "Gegenstand"

Thanks for the correction

Re: My favourite German word

#48

I loved this article. My fiancée recently remarked that she'd been doing more writing on paper because it made her more productive. She theorized that she takes an editor's mindset in the face of WYSIWYG renditions of her spelling mistakes. The same goes for her design work. The industry tools make it too easy to recognize "wrong" as it's happening. That sounds like a singing endorsement of these tools, but our exper…

I've definitely found I'm way faster sketching with pencil than I am digitally. When doing digital sketches ctrl-z is right there. doing it with pencil means getting an eraser involved and it'll never quite get everything.

I find myself redrawing the same like like 12 times when doing digital, but only once with a pencil. So there's definitely something about "worse" tools being better sometimes, just because sometimes the wrong things get made easy.

Re: My favourite German word

#49

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Object has "against" in it, that's the ob- part. The other part is "throw". The German comes from the Latin. (Why did they go for -stand instead of a word for throw?)

Once you get into learning German, it’s surprising how many compound words like this are actually direct translations of the Latin or Greek roots of the same English words. Hydrogen = Wasserstoff (water material); television = Fernseher (distance seer) and so on. It’s almost as if they had their own uncleftish beholding moment.

Your examples are relatively modern, but there is a huge number of compound German words that are calques of French words, Latin words or Greek words, and which have been coined several centuries ago.

For instance: circumstance => Umstand, or depend => abhängen, or expression => Ausdruck, or participate => teilnehmen.

German looks unfamiliar for English speakers mostly because all the words that English has borrowed as such from French or from classical languages have been translated into compound German words.

Re: My favourite German word

#50

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> What makes the documentation good isn’t, however, related to people’s ability to navigate information spaces. Then what's the point? If nobody can use the documentation properly, then the term "good documentation" is meaningless.

I think the article is saying that good documentation is objective, and is not defined by ease of use. You will ingest this difficult documentation and you will like it, because it is good for you. You might reasonably ask "in what way". > this is how documentation is, because this arrangement is part of its integrity, and this is how you must learn to use it and work with it. The word "integrity" comes up six times.…

Yeah, this isn't something you put your name on. It's something the company pays you to do, to make the product better. Good documentation significantly improves a product. Which means making that information accessible to web natives.

Luckily, unlike web natives, LLM's have read lots of documentation cover to cover. Likely a good way to teach LLM's about your product is to write good documentation.

Post reply on HN