Hacker News Board Hacker News, browsed like a classic message board
Live data from Hacker News

My open source project got stolen by a HN user

news.ycombinator.com

Post reply on HN
Print view View original

41–50 of 68 posts

Re: My open source project got stolen by a HN user

#41

Post by AndreVitorio »

dun44 wrote: post #36
ricardobeat wrote: post #27

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This a comparison of the src folders using Meld: https://postimg.cc/sM2HDP7G In the scrollbars on the right, blue is modified, green is new, black is equal. Only a handful of hooks, helpers and simple components are still the same. 90% sounds quite far from reality. Not that I think the lack of credit given to the original project isn’t scummy, but… it’s just someone being an asshole, not much you can do about that.

Have you verified that those changes are not something trivial like formatting?

Also have into account at what point the code was merged. We have made changes to our code base, and he probably did as well. I'm not mad he is using the code, my problem is with removing credits and claiming the work as his own.

Basically doing stuff like this: https://www.reddit.com/r/developersIndia/comments/14m3evc/i_...

The video is him basically showing our CMS with the logos swapped.

Re: My open source project got stolen by a HN user

#42

Post by codeptualize »

I wonder what you want to get out of this, and what damage his clone is causing you and your project?

I've had my website cloned before and I totally get the feeling and absurdity of the situation, but realistically there is not a lot you can do without it (negatively) impacting you as well.

I think it's good to message this person, as they probably should include your license, maybe indeed make people aware, but at some point it might be better to let it rest and focus your energy towards your project.

Especially if it's not really a threat to your project (and it doesn't look like it is as your project seems like it's doing quite well, congrats!) you could wonder if the best course of action is to just not give it any attention at all.

Re: My open source project got stolen by a HN user

#43

Post by meiraleal »

AndreVitorio wrote: post #39
ipaddr wrote: post #31

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Your coming off as childish. Anyone can take your code and use it in whatever way they want. If you wanted to use a license where you keep ownership choose a different license. If an investor will give them money good for them. If devs gives them praise good for them. You gave the code away in the hopes someone would use it. Someone is.. you were the author to the first guy who took it. He is the author to the next g…

In your example, he is claiming he came up with the joke. That's different isn't it?

I didn't see he claiming he developed your project. He uses it and developed a solution on top of it. What do you want from people using your code to compose other projects, pay you royalties? Make an altar for you?

Re: My open source project got stolen by a HN user

#44

Post by AndreVitorio »

codeptualize wrote: post #42

I wonder what you want to get out of this, and what damage his clone is causing you and your project? I've had my website cloned before and I totally get the feeling and absurdity of the situation, but realistically there is not a lot you can do without it (negatively) impacting you as well. I think it's good to message this person, as they probably should include your license, maybe indeed make people aware, but at…

Definitely, I agree with you. I tried reasoning with the person and at no point he expressed any sentiment of doing something wrong, to the contrary, he said he doubled down on the fact that he was being generous by offering me a chance to become the "cofounder" of his project. But I didn't decide to come public just because of that, that's only one example among many of ill intent and just not caring.

Re: My open source project got stolen by a HN user

#45

Post by AndreVitorio »

meiraleal wrote: post #43
AndreVitorio wrote: post #39

Earlier quoted context omitted.

In your example, he is claiming he came up with the joke. That's different isn't it?

I didn't see he claiming he developed your project. He uses it and developed a solution on top of it. What do you want from people using your code to compose other projects, pay you royalties? Make an altar for you?

What about this?

https://www.reddit.com/r/developersIndia/comments/14m3evc/i_...

One of many examples...

Re: My open source project got stolen by a HN user

#47

Post by elliotwu »

Elegant-cli's author's mistake was not including a full-text copy of your MIT license (which has your name) in the repository (his own MIT license does not count as a "proxy"). That is precisely what the MIT license requires, and hence a direct non-compliance by Elegant-cli.

However, the MIT license does not dictate how Outstatic should be mentioned in Elegant-cli's marketing materials (like their website or README file).

Though poor etiquette, it is permissible for Elegant-cli to not mention you or Outstatic anywhere else, so long as full-text license copy with your name is included in the repository.

If you needed that kind of attribution, you should have picked something like the BSD-4-Clause (https://spdx.org/licenses/BSD-4-Clause) or MIT-advertising (https://spdx.org/licenses/MIT-advertising.html) licenses, instead of the MIT license.

Re: My open source project got stolen by a HN user

#49

Post by AndreVitorio »

ipaddr wrote: post #32
lijok wrote: post #29

What damage is this person causing you exactly?

He told people to use this code however you want... Until you become more successful with it then he was. Then it becomes his code again.

Use the code however you want. Until you start recording videos telling the world you wrote the code from scratch, removing any references to the original project, telling people to join your project and asking investors to put money in your "genius" idea...
Post reply on HN