Live data from Hacker News

Indian lawmaker arrested after tweet criticising Narendra Modi

theguardian.com

41–50 of 213 posts

Re: Indian lawmaker arrested after tweet criticising Narendra Modi

#41
post #11

I admit I'm not super familiar with India's freedom of speech, is this a backslide or has it always been like this?

I remember stories of people beaten up for not standing for the anthem in the cinema, one of them was disabled wheelchair user. So I guess it is like that for a while especially after the Hindutvas got into power.

Oh yeah, freedom of speech flourished under Congress rule /s

Who was the only prime minister to invoke emergency?

Re: Indian lawmaker arrested after tweet criticising Narendra Modi

#42
post #6

Boris Johnson arrived in India. Rabble-rousers know that the world's media attention will follow; and they use this opportunity to garner some of the spotlight. It's just a shameless ploy to get their names out. Such is democracy, I guess. And the Guardian doesn't help by adding flame bait such as this: "In the capital, Delhi, bulldozers have demolished the homes of Muslims accused of rioting." Illegal construction,…

> Illegal construction, encroachment on public land will sometimes get this response.

Illegal construction is rampant in india. Please contextualize the act of bulldozing with the riots that happened. Let's not be blind to the clear use of power and authority to specifically root out people of a certain cast.

The level of politics being played out in India is nearing to the intellect of a badly scripted bollywood movie and people are turning the other way or even worse making excuses for it.

Re: Indian lawmaker arrested after tweet criticising Narendra Modi

#46

Earlier quoted context omitted.

India never had freedom of speech. Opposition newspapers are often harassed and shut down. They have a law criminalizing offending religious feelings. This is not an exaggerated paraphrase, that’s what the law says. A scientist was convicted under this law a few years ago for demonstrating that a “weeping” statue of the Virgin Mary was not actually weeping blood. The truth was offensive, so the law applied. EDIT: I r…

Your point still stands, but there was never a formal prosecution or conviction (he fled to Finland before it got that far): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Weeping_crucifix_in_Mumbai

Thanks for the clarification (I was going by memory). So he was arrested, and presumably would have been prosecuted had he not escaped.

Re: Indian lawmaker arrested after tweet criticising Narendra Modi

#47

I admit I'm not super familiar with India's freedom of speech, is this a backslide or has it always been like this?

India never had freedom of speech. Opposition newspapers are often harassed and shut down. They have a law criminalizing offending religious feelings. This is not an exaggerated paraphrase, that’s what the law says. A scientist was convicted under this law a few years ago for demonstrating that a “weeping” statue of the Virgin Mary was not actually weeping blood. The truth was offensive, so the law applied. EDIT: I r…

He was gone after not because of proving it false, but because he accused the church of purposefully lying I believe. One could call it not much different but it isn't the exact same as being prosecuted for debunking a "miracle"

From wikipedia: he skeptic-rationalist author Sanal Edamaruku proved that the water stemmed from a faulty sewage system, which seeped due to capillary action. However, Edamaruku also accused Latin Christian priests of regularly scamming devotees and defrauding miracles to make money, and build bigger and newer churchs or convents,[1] and mocked the Pope as "anti-science".[2] A church representative admitted Edamaruku had the "right to doubt", and Christian activists said that the backlash was not for debunking the alleged "miracle" but for the defamatory statements made live on television.[3]

Re: Indian lawmaker arrested after tweet criticising Narendra Modi

#48

Quoted post unavailable.

UK is half way to Sharia?! It's not true, but even it is, why has that got to do with the criticism? There are continuous calls in India for genocide of Muslims, publicly. Past two weeks, religious processions have been undertaken by Hindu extremist orgs in front of mosques with swords and Guns, mocking Muslims. And PM of the Nation has been silent, with no calls whatsoever for peace. It's not 'funny' to criticize PM of Nation to do his duty to people of the nation. And it's not funny that Guardian is reporting it. People living in India know how terrifying the situation has become due to these repeated calls for Violence against Muslims

Re: Indian lawmaker arrested after tweet criticising Narendra Modi

#49

Quoted post unavailable.

Guardian is not 'The west'. It's a News organization. It is neither a representative or an official mouthpiece for 'The west'. Guardian is not finger pointing as well, It's doing it's job, which is reporting the events. And the criticism is absolutely valid. This deflection and tangential remarks are not suitable for Hacker News.

Re: Indian lawmaker arrested after tweet criticising Narendra Modi

#50
post #42
post #6

Boris Johnson arrived in India. Rabble-rousers know that the world's media attention will follow; and they use this opportunity to garner some of the spotlight. It's just a shameless ploy to get their names out. Such is democracy, I guess. And the Guardian doesn't help by adding flame bait such as this: "In the capital, Delhi, bulldozers have demolished the homes of Muslims accused of rioting." Illegal construction,…

> Illegal construction, encroachment on public land will sometimes get this response. Illegal construction is rampant in india. Please contextualize the act of bulldozing with the riots that happened. Let's not be blind to the clear use of power and authority to specifically root out people of a certain cast. The level of politics being played out in India is nearing to the intellect of a badly scripted bollywood mov…

And bulldozing happens in non Muslim areas as well. Sometimes even middle class homes illegally built. Just as cities in the US clear homeless encampments.
Post reply on HN