Live data from Hacker News

NFT misconception: JPEG aren't stored on the Blockchain

erickhun.com

41–50 of 264 posts

Re: NFT misconception: JPEG aren't stored on the Blockchain

#41
post #10

I'm very surprised that those (the JSON and the picture) are not stored in a decentralised way e.g. IPFS or Swarm. So if I buy an expensive NFT, and the domain goes down, the NFT is now worthless? We should be on the lookout for any of these domains expiring, then we will buy them and upload Rick Astley GIFs

IPFS doesn’t guarantee safety either, it’s still possible for the link to rot and no longer be accessible.

Re: NFT misconception: JPEG aren't stored on the Blockchain

#43
post #33
post #6

The only real future for NFT's is a coupling with the physical world. Like buying physical art. Or proofing ownership of an asset like houses.

Or an uncensorable domain name service which has both utility and rarity and cannot be downloaded and is stored on the blockchain.

You might be thinking of Namecoin, the first fork of Bitcoin.

Re: NFT misconception: JPEG aren't stored on the Blockchain

#44
post #33
post #6

The only real future for NFT's is a coupling with the physical world. Like buying physical art. Or proofing ownership of an asset like houses.

Or an uncensorable domain name service which has both utility and rarity and cannot be downloaded and is stored on the blockchain.

cannot be downloaded

I can't help thinking this criteria makes the DNS service a bit less useful.

Re: NFT misconception: JPEG aren't stored on the Blockchain

#45

I hate to admit it but I’m still struggling to understand why people would pay so much for NFTs. I feel like I fully understand what they are and why most people want me to believe it has value but I still don’t agree. I’m waiting for my mind to change but it hasn’t happened yet. It’s frustrating because so many people I respect are leaving their high paying jobs to work in web3 startups around NFTs and I feel dumb f…

The analogy that helped me understand it (even though I would still not buy one myself and think the hype is way over the top):

Think of a booth at Comic Con, where an artist hands out signed copies of their comic books. The comic book itself is nothing special, but the signature is. But there is a problem: if you ever want to sell the signed comic book, how do you prove it's a real signature? NFTs solve that problem.

Re: NFT misconception: JPEG aren't stored on the Blockchain

#47

This means that NFTs still don't denote much without a centralized authority. Doesn't that defeat the point? (That might not make them worthless, since value is socially constructed, but it makes the claims of decentralization seem less impressive.)

All the trading hubs like OpenSea are centralised to the point that some NFTs will get blacklisted if a famous enough person in the community gets scammed out of theirs.

Re: NFT misconception: JPEG aren't stored on the Blockchain

#48
post #4

I'd expect at least a hash of the image to be stored on the blockhain..

NFT is low tech scam. I'm surprised so much money were attracted. Must be very good marketing campaign.

The idea of NFT is not scam, but the current scene is more like it. Not exactly like scam but more like a super-hyped balloon.

Re: NFT misconception: JPEG aren't stored on the Blockchain

#49

I hate to admit it but I’m still struggling to understand why people would pay so much for NFTs. I feel like I fully understand what they are and why most people want me to believe it has value but I still don’t agree. I’m waiting for my mind to change but it hasn’t happened yet. It’s frustrating because so many people I respect are leaving their high paying jobs to work in web3 startups around NFTs and I feel dumb f…

The most plausible conspiracy theories I've heard is that the big sales ($1 million plus) are wash trades, ("sell" an object to a confederate for 500 ETH, then they transfer the money right back via another route) and some classic money laundering Now of course there's a mountain of clueless suckers kicking off a regular tulip mania-style bubble. I wonder how many more weeks it will last.

Like this $500,000,000 flash loan backed wash trade of punk 9998. [1]

[1] https://news.artnet.com/art-world/crypto-punk-500-million-sa...

Re: NFT misconception: JPEG aren't stored on the Blockchain

#50
post #5

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Wait, is this not how it works? Seemed like a safe assumption...

Yeah it's an encrypted thing pointing to a URL which has a JSON file in it that contains a URL of an image.

It's not even encrypted.
Post reply on HN