Live data from Hacker News

NFT misconception: JPEG aren't stored on the Blockchain

erickhun.com

31–40 of 264 posts

Re: NFT misconception: JPEG aren't stored on the Blockchain

#31
post #10

I'm very surprised that those (the JSON and the picture) are not stored in a decentralised way e.g. IPFS or Swarm. So if I buy an expensive NFT, and the domain goes down, the NFT is now worthless? We should be on the lookout for any of these domains expiring, then we will buy them and upload Rick Astley GIFs

They often are. For instance on Arweave

Re: NFT misconception: JPEG aren't stored on the Blockchain

#32

I hate to admit it but I’m still struggling to understand why people would pay so much for NFTs. I feel like I fully understand what they are and why most people want me to believe it has value but I still don’t agree. I’m waiting for my mind to change but it hasn’t happened yet. It’s frustrating because so many people I respect are leaving their high paying jobs to work in web3 startups around NFTs and I feel dumb f…

The most plausible conspiracy theories I've heard is that the big sales ($1 million plus) are wash trades, ("sell" an object to a confederate for 500 ETH, then they transfer the money right back via another route) and some classic money laundering

Now of course there's a mountain of clueless suckers kicking off a regular tulip mania-style bubble. I wonder how many more weeks it will last.

Re: NFT misconception: JPEG aren't stored on the Blockchain

#33
post #6

The only real future for NFT's is a coupling with the physical world. Like buying physical art. Or proofing ownership of an asset like houses.

Or an uncensorable domain name service which has both utility and rarity and cannot be downloaded and is stored on the blockchain.

Re: NFT misconception: JPEG aren't stored on the Blockchain

#35
post #6

The only real future for NFT's is a coupling with the physical world. Like buying physical art. Or proofing ownership of an asset like houses.

Which will require the authority to recognize it. Your NFT of house is worth nothing unless court/police recognize it to be so.

Re: NFT misconception: JPEG aren't stored on the Blockchain

#36

I hate to admit it but I’m still struggling to understand why people would pay so much for NFTs. I feel like I fully understand what they are and why most people want me to believe it has value but I still don’t agree. I’m waiting for my mind to change but it hasn’t happened yet. It’s frustrating because so many people I respect are leaving their high paying jobs to work in web3 startups around NFTs and I feel dumb f…

Money laundering.

Re: NFT misconception: JPEG aren't stored on the Blockchain

#37

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Proof of wasted space. Proof of space algorithms just fill hard drives with garbage.

Better than continuously burning electricity, yes? And if the stored data is actually useful, is the net result all that bad?

I mean, it's still worse than not doing any of this lol, and that's the null hypothesis we should be using. Yes, getting stabbed is better than getting shot, but maybe stay inside and fire up a nice S3 bucket.

The real problem is any proof of resource scheme immediately becomes a grey goo where folks are incentivized to consume literally all that resource wether it makes sense or not. It has no negative feedback loop. It cannot make sense.

Also, because of market pricing of the tokens businesses cannot actually leverage it (as they don't want wacky prices that vary by the minute) so you're left with, as usual, illegal content, gambling, speculation and other misc crime. Basically why Filecoin has a small rack of hard drives' worth of stored data and Chia has exabytes and exabytes of garbage - or did, does anyone care about that one anymore?

It makes more sense to just store garbage if your goal is to run a neat little pyramid scheme.

Re: NFT misconception: JPEG aren't stored on the Blockchain

#39

I hate to admit it but I’m still struggling to understand why people would pay so much for NFTs. I feel like I fully understand what they are and why most people want me to believe it has value but I still don’t agree. I’m waiting for my mind to change but it hasn’t happened yet. It’s frustrating because so many people I respect are leaving their high paying jobs to work in web3 startups around NFTs and I feel dumb f…

Hype. Hoping it will become even more popular to sell it for even higher.

Re: NFT misconception: JPEG aren't stored on the Blockchain

#40
post #6

The only real future for NFT's is a coupling with the physical world. Like buying physical art. Or proofing ownership of an asset like houses.

Would anyone buy a house if the proof of ownership was a URL to JSON file on a server you didn't control, with no regulation of the blockchain that the "proof" resides on?

I will genuinely put effort in to starting a company that provides a blockchain proof of real estate ownership if this ever happens, just so I can fraudulently sell everyone's houses while they live in them after a few years. It'd be hilarious.

Post reply on HN