Live data from Hacker News

My Custom Stream Deck Toolkit

peterhajas.com

41–43 of 43 posts

Re: My Custom Stream Deck Toolkit

#41
post #40

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It should be noted that there's not much fancy tech in a streamdeck, it's just clever use of pretty old tech. It's an LCD and touchscreen with a mask and the buttons are optical-grade-ish plastic with a pad that triggers the touchscreen when the button is pressed. Ford uses something similar in some of their center console screens; there's a wiper under a dial glued to the screen. They do not use individual screens,…

Interesting, I had no idea they were so simple. That could help explain why they haven't produced bigger devices like a full keyboard. The costs likely don't scale as well when you need a screen the size and shape of a keyboard as opposed to the commoditized screens they are using in the smaller devices.

Yep! Very simple and absurdly cheap to make and program. There are ton of display controllers that have more than enough capability to handle to do this all without needing a separate uC, even.

I think what you're really paying for is the software on the host computer side, and how many companies they've gotten to interface with them.

I'd be willing to bet that streamdeck makes a lot of money off sale of metrics they collect - what programs are running, what games people are playing, what they're streaming, and probably more.

Re: My Custom Stream Deck Toolkit

#42

Stream Decks are super neat, but the official software is complete trash. Rolling your own is basically the only way to win here. I use a library for .NET called StreamDeckSharp which is pretty nice.

What are specific concerns you have? I've been using the Stream Deck software for a couple of years now and other than a few freezes that required me to relaunch the application. I haven't had any issues.

For me, some combination of it, my Mac, and the software my IT organization runs made it so my Mac wouldn't boot, for one side of anecdata. My experience with the app wasn't as bad as some others here, but I'd much rather use something lightweight (and a multitasker) like Hammerspoon over running their app all the time. It also feels way more natural to me to configure it with a script that I can move between machines, where I wasn't able to find a good way to share config between computers with their software (but admittedly didn't try hard). My deck is connected through a KVM, and it's nice for it to work the same way between my two computers.

Re: My Custom Stream Deck Toolkit

#43
post #33

is there a tried-and-tested ipad app anyone can recommend that does what the stream deck does? stream decks have always interested me, but the price has always seemed a bit steep. compared to their XL model, for ~50$ more (with an educational discount) you can get a base ipad, and unless you really want the tactile feedback, i can’t think how that wouldn’t be a better buy.

There is the Stream Deck Mobile app. https://www.elgato.com/en/stream-deck-mobile

i have an old iphone SE lying around. it seems like perfect use for this instead of buying a stream deck :D
Post reply on HN