Live data from Hacker News

Google no longer providing original URL in AMP for image search results

twitter.com

41–50 of 566 posts

Re: Google no longer providing original URL in AMP for image search results

#41
post #27

Earlier quoted context omitted.

For reportedly being there to accelerate the web, AMP pages remain consistently slower and less reliable than the original websites for me.

With amp I basically do "find the page, edit url to remove amp, load again" dance. It is definitely not faster.

There's an extension for this. Works on mobile (at least until Mozilla kills extensions on their mobile app) https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/amp2html/

Re: Google no longer providing original URL in AMP for image search results

#42

AMP results are annoying enough on mobile that I switched my default search engine to duckduckgo on my phone.

For reportedly being there to accelerate the web, AMP pages remain consistently slower and less reliable than the original websites for me.

I'm still against AMP on a conceptual ground, but it is so much faster and more reliable than traditional page loading on my phone. Pages can't have megabytes of JavaScript and huge images. It's served by Google's fast CDN instead of some far-away server.

Re: Google no longer providing original URL in AMP for image search results

#43
post #26

AMP really has to go away, its a MITM attack on the internet. Google discontinues so many services, why is AMP not one of them yet?

AMP keeps people on Google owned properties longer[1], so it's a revenue driver.

[1] Via things like taking over swipe motions and the back button on carousel launched pages, for example.

Re: Google no longer providing original URL in AMP for image search results

#44

I switched all my default search to DuckDuckGo a few months ago because of stuff like this. No regrets here. If you haven't tried it recently, give it a shot. It's gotten tons better in the past few years. Once you get used to it, it's as good as Google search.

And there are so many nice features, like the !bangs search prefixes, and the ability to store and sync your preferences as a passphrase, without requiring an actual account.

The dark scheme is also quite good.

Re: Google no longer providing original URL in AMP for image search results

#45
post #26

AMP really has to go away, its a MITM attack on the internet. Google discontinues so many services, why is AMP not one of them yet?

because it's a useful MITM attack on the internet

useful to whom?

Re: Google no longer providing original URL in AMP for image search results

#46
post #26

AMP really has to go away, its a MITM attack on the internet. Google discontinues so many services, why is AMP not one of them yet?

I agree that AMP is a major attack on the internet, not to mention the fact that it makes it way slower [1] and hard to understand what you're browsing. The worst part is that my friends send me AMP links all the time even though I use DDG to avoid this stuff.

[1]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18893808

Re: Google no longer providing original URL in AMP for image search results

#47
I never looked deep into this but I remember that back in the day there was the "View original image" link in image search and I think they got rid of it because of some EU directive that stated that they can't link an image directly but rather provide a link to the original source, that is the website? Or am I completely wrong?

Re: Google no longer providing original URL in AMP for image search results

#48

This is pretty much what we've been saying would happen since the day AMP was fire presented to the public. I really hope this AMP thing never becomes anything mainstream, it's an atrocious attempt at monopolizing the internet as a whole.

I believe it’s already mainstream :(

Re: Google no longer providing original URL in AMP for image search results

#50
Correction:

The original URL is provided by the Share button on the right. But it's not a link. (To visit it, you'd have to copy and paste back into the browser. You can't share a link to the app you are shared from )

So the URL is available as always, but the link is not.

Post reply on HN