Live data from Hacker News

Japanese Education: Amae, Stress, and Perseverence

tofugu.com

41–47 of 47 posts

Re: Japanese Education: Amae, Stress, and Perseverence

#41
post #39
post #37

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Where you choose to help out is up to you?

That's not the meaning behind the word "volunteering".

You are 100% correct and it's actually 40 hours of mandatory community involvement. [1] Everyone around me just called it volunteer hours and I co-opted it. Thank you for pointing it out. :)

http://www.edu.gov.on.ca/extra/eng/ppm/124a.html

Re: Japanese Education: Amae, Stress, and Perseverence

#42
post #34

Earlier quoted context omitted.

>mandatory volunteer Is it volunteering if it's mandatory?

Yeah, it's oxymoronic. They should just call it duty or something, a euphemism is better than an oxymoron.

http://www.edu.gov.on.ca/extra/eng/ppm/124a.html

It is in fact called community involvement! It was my mistake.

Re: Japanese Education: Amae, Stress, and Perseverence

#43
I'm rather wary of culturally based strengths. They DO exist. For example, being a good students is like being a star quarterback in the US. There simply isn't a way for US culture to have better academic performance with just this one cultural difference.

I'm wary because I think culture as a whole exists only to stabilize social stratification. Under normal circumstances layers will naturally mix, but if the mobility channels are clearly specified, you have order. In the US this is the mythos if hard work, in many Asian cultures there are establish systems based around tests. Indian and European systems had no mobility, being caste and nobility based.

Hard layers eventually lead to revolt, but soft layers didn't cordone wealth. Soft layers with prescribed channels are more stable.

So the existing channels are actually purposely inefficient and mostly stupid.

Entrepreneuship for example used to be forced. It was what you must do when given too much freedom. It was freedom in the sense of far too much, being ostracized in the desert.

Technology though provides the tools to survive in excess freedom. The desert can become a plain, once you have your endless water supply and teleporter that is.

The side effect is that these tools eat culture. It doesn't destroy the bike, but invents the car. Culture becomes a weekend thing.

Cultural praising often reminds me of hipster-ish praising of things like traditional razors and single gear fixies. People going backwards while claiming to be going forwards.

Re: Japanese Education: Amae, Stress, and Perseverence

#45
post #31

The part about amae is a bit off. I would go a step further than translating it just as "to wish to be loved." That's still normal even in western culture. Amae is closer to "nagging to be pet over the head while doing a cute face" or "whining" and "talking in a high pitch voice on purpose to sound cute so that you can get what you want". "Amaeruna!" is heard often and for good reason. It means stop acting like a chi…

Reminds me of,

https://medium.com/@patricksherriff/how-to-write-about-japan...

Re: Japanese Education: Amae, Stress, and Perseverence

#46
post #14

This resonates a bit with me. The relationship with my mother defined who I am, things like my work ethic, perseverance and so on came from her. She sacrificed her career giving up being printer to work a as a janitor, delivering mail, a security guard just to make sure she was home when I came back from school. Saved money for quite a while out of the little we had to buy me a computer I've been wanted. If it wasn't…

That should've taken quite a bit of courage. Where did you grow up, if you don't mind me asking ?

Re: Japanese Education: Amae, Stress, and Perseverence

#47
post #14

This resonates a bit with me. The relationship with my mother defined who I am, things like my work ethic, perseverance and so on came from her. She sacrificed her career giving up being printer to work a as a janitor, delivering mail, a security guard just to make sure she was home when I came back from school. Saved money for quite a while out of the little we had to buy me a computer I've been wanted. If it wasn't…

That should've taken quite a bit of courage. Where did you grow up, if you don't mind me asking ?

In the Soviet Union as it was falling apart.
Post reply on HN