Live data from Hacker News

China to begin two-child policy

bbc.co.uk

41–50 of 455 posts

Re: China to begin two-child policy

#41
post #20

Once-child policy was brutally enforced and cruel. It was also highly effective way to reduce poverty. China vs. India: GDP per capita versus fertility rate http://www.google.se/publicdata/explore?ds=d5bncppjof8f9_&ct...

Some states in India especially South Indian states have achieved fertility rates below 2 without one child policy.

Re: China to begin two-child policy

#42

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You mean like the problem of telling people they can't just drive cars or own firearms and need to meet some competence criteria first, i.e. licensing? If so, I totally support the idea of licensing human breeding.

Are you going to force women to abort "unlicensed" children? Force women to have birth control implants? Up until the 1990s in Spain, many thousands of children were systematically stolen from political activists and others with the wrong politics or wrong lifestyle. Parents were told that their newborn had died. http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/magazine-15335899

A less severe form would be financial incentives for licensed parents. You're still free to have children if you want, but you're only supported by the state if you got a license. Pair this with free birth control implants and abortions for everyone who wants them and you get most of the effect without the use of force. You could even pay men to get a vasectomy.

Re: China to begin two-child policy

#43
post #6

Middle-class in China is going to be fascinating to watch as it consumes all resources. (four times the entire population of the USA for perspective) I guess the logic is it will help their economy?

The interesting thing about humans is that they adapt. There's a reason economic growth exists, and not all of it relies on: suck up more oil, chop down more wood.

Re: China to begin two-child policy

#44
post #20

Once-child policy was brutally enforced and cruel. It was also highly effective way to reduce poverty. China vs. India: GDP per capita versus fertility rate http://www.google.se/publicdata/explore?ds=d5bncppjof8f9_&ct...

More ice cream is sold in the summer. Sexual assault also increases in the summer. We should stop selling ice cream in the summer.

This is HN. Please quit spewing ignorance.

Re: China to begin two-child policy

#45

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You mean, tinder?

Honestly, for Tinder-like service you just need to turn on WeChat in the evening and run "people nearby" search so that you pop up on a list with updated location. The offers stream themselves.

> The offers stream themselves.

Interesting turn of phrase there...

Re: China to begin two-child policy

#48
post #20

Once-child policy was brutally enforced and cruel. It was also highly effective way to reduce poverty. China vs. India: GDP per capita versus fertility rate http://www.google.se/publicdata/explore?ds=d5bncppjof8f9_&ct...

Rather, reducing poverty is a highly effective way of reducing the birth rate.

Re: China to begin two-child policy

#49
post #20

Once-child policy was brutally enforced and cruel. It was also highly effective way to reduce poverty. China vs. India: GDP per capita versus fertility rate http://www.google.se/publicdata/explore?ds=d5bncppjof8f9_&ct...

>It was also highly effective way to reduce poverty. Citation needed; correlation does not equal causation. Other East Asian countries showed similar reductions in fertility in spite of no similar policies, and much greater reductions in poverty. China vs. India vs. Asian Tigers (Hong Kong, Singapore, Korea): GDP per capita versus fertility rate http://www.google.se/publicdata/explore?ds=d5bncppjof8f9_&ct... Taiwan e…

[deleted]

Re: China to begin two-child policy

#50

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You mean like the problem of telling people they can't just drive cars or own firearms and need to meet some competence criteria first, i.e. licensing? If so, I totally support the idea of licensing human breeding.

> "If so, I totally support the idea of licensing human breeding." That sort of licensing is ripe for abuse. What would happen if someone in power took that license away from you just because they didn't agree with your political views?

[deleted]
Post reply on HN