Live data from Hacker News

Pirate Library Mirror: Preserving 7TB of books (that are not in Libgen)

pilimi.org

351–360 of 438 posts

Re: Pirate Library Mirror: Preserving 7TB of books (that are not in Libgen)

#351

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I can't imagine getting rid of it completely would have good effects, as it would make any large scale production impossible. You might still get a few blog post, but getting books produced will be tricky and something big like a movie might be outright impossible. This is doubly true in the modern digital world were everything can be copied in a fraction of a second and where the piracy site, not the authors, will b…

As a jumping-off point for thought: Piracy-by-default would work very well in a world where access to a work is not charged, but the social custom is that revenue is collected via pre- or during-production crowdfunding You may see lower revenues, but how much cost is currently poured into resolving licensing / investing in DRM / etc, all for works to be pirated anyway?

Many ebook vendors I use (InformIT, Packt, No Starch Press, Pragmatic Bookshelf, Manning, O'Reilly Back in the day), work at piracy-by-default mode. Only InformIT watermarks PDF copies, and there's no DRM to talk about.

So, when you have good content with reasonable prices, people also come and buy.

Also, there are some eBooks in Kobo store devoid of any DRM. So, publishers are not forced to use DRM on Kobo, as well.

Re: Pirate Library Mirror: Preserving 7TB of books (that are not in Libgen)

#352
post #307

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Interesting, but being very opposite of socialist myself I am wholeheartedly with you here on limiting timeframe of IP. It partially solves the problem. And this arguably should be extended to tangible assets as well - I like Singapore model where housing property is sold for specific timeframe. It simplifies a lot of redevelopment.

Something like the homestead principle?

Not precisely so.

We tend to think of ownership as in absolute owning of an asset for indefinite time. For a lot of things in Singapore you can ownership (i.e. own it) in that sense, but after sone time you have either to return it or stop using (rendering it useless). This applies to assets like homes, cars, etc.

If it’s not feasible to enforce those policies, government just imposes hefty tax on assets, ensuring you extract (or contribute) sufficient added value from asset.

Re: Pirate Library Mirror: Preserving 7TB of books (that are not in Libgen)

#353
post #105

Earlier quoted context omitted.

HTTP connections can be used as a weapon against others. One example is China’s Great Cannon. https://citizenlab.ca/2015/04/chinas-great-cannon/

That's quite dated by now. If you are in a position to inject traffic, you are likely also able to simply use that uplink to send traffic of your own. I'd be surprised if this is still in use, especially outside of China (or a poor not-so-tech-savvy country like North Korea) and wasn't just a quick hack at the time.

It's only dated if the vulnerability has been patched. In this case, the only way to patch it is to serve over HTTPS.

If it was a quick hack, then that makes it even worse. Difficulty is a mitigating factor.

Re: Pirate Library Mirror: Preserving 7TB of books (that are not in Libgen)

#354

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Imagine for a split second an idea of value that doesn't start and end with private profit

I get what you're saying by this, but I think OC is just being practical. This is the world we live in. It's shit and I hate it, but if you want something done, 9 times out of 10 you need to consider these questions

Maybe if you read the right books you would cultivate a worldview where you don't "need to consider these questions" so much. Maybe if more people died that we would even help build a world like that.

Re: Pirate Library Mirror: Preserving 7TB of books (that are not in Libgen)

#355

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Freenet is built around similar ideas, combined with encryption an anonymization. Which hopefully adds the benefit of you not being legally liable of distributing CSAM. The gist of Freenet is that you can operate a freesite or upload files, and the content is redundantly dispersed in encrypted parts among a number of other Freenet peers. They don't know what they're hosting and neither do you, the client just fills u…

My idea is similar but slightly different. You'd run your client and then choose whose provider's data to seed, eg you'd add the Internet Archive and Libgen to your datasets. Only those entities would be able to push data to you, nobody else, so if you trust the providers you specified, you should be good.

I remembered that I read about something like that before. I think this was it: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Storage@home

Further this lead me to distributed data stores: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Distributed_data_store#Peer_ne...

Re: Pirate Library Mirror: Preserving 7TB of books (that are not in Libgen)

#356
post #153

I see things like this, and I wonder why the following software doesn't exist: I want a piece of software to which I can add a collection of files, say multiple TB. The software will then behave a bit like a BitTorrent tracker, and know which peer has which files. A peer joining this swarm will be able to say "I want to donate X GB of space", and the tracker would tell it "OK, then download and seed these files, whic…

Have always thought this would be a great way for many people to share well organized Plex libraries. Many semi-overlapping libraries basically creating a virtual Netflix, with some way to stream in Plex from the whole library no matter if you actually have the content locally or not

>virtual Netflix

this already exists with addons for Kodi

Re: Pirate Library Mirror: Preserving 7TB of books (that are not in Libgen)

#357

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Insane in the abstract, but not exactly unfathomable. Who would make money off of that, and who else makes money off of it's absense?

Imagine for a split second an idea of value that doesn't start and end with private profit

[deleted]

Re: Pirate Library Mirror: Preserving 7TB of books (that are not in Libgen)

#358

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Only a few works are actually illegal to distribute in Germany. Not the whole site. Project Gutenberg chose to block the whole site instead. Source: https://cand.pglaf.org/germany/index.html

The lawsuit has been settled. Gutenberg has been unblocked in Germany since late October. The site was completely blocked for three years, from 2018 on. Now, a total of 19 German language books are blocked, per the "terms of the settlement are confidential." Everything else works. https://cand.pglaf.org/germany/index.html Gutenberg was blocked in Italy in early 2020. I don't know if this block still persists. https:/…

> Gutenberg was blocked in Italy in early 2020. I don't know if this block still persists.

afaict, it resolves and loads fine here. Now on mobile tethering via the Iliad (.it) local operator. When I get home I'll also check it on broadband.

Re: Pirate Library Mirror: Preserving 7TB of books (that are not in Libgen)

#359

Earlier quoted context omitted.

My idea is similar but slightly different. You'd run your client and then choose whose provider's data to seed, eg you'd add the Internet Archive and Libgen to your datasets. Only those entities would be able to push data to you, nobody else, so if you trust the providers you specified, you should be good.

I remembered that I read about something like that before. I think this was it: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Storage@home Further this lead me to distributed data stores: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Distributed_data_store#Peer_ne...

That's interesting, I'll read up on it, thanks!

Re: Pirate Library Mirror: Preserving 7TB of books (that are not in Libgen)

#360
post #124

Again, it's just insane to me that we don't even much have a meaningful discussion of: "Hey, wait, literally everyone could have the entire library of Alexandria in their house for a couple hundred bucks per person. Like, all the knowledge ever. Maybe that should be considered the good default of things. At least one in every town that everyone could use, for free, forever, without restriction to ANY of the knowledge…

As a kid, my parents had a full copy of the Library of Alexandria on the coffee table. Everyone else just called it an ashtray. (Sorry, too soon?)

It likely didn't burn and was mostly destroyed by purging of scholars and abandon. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Library_of_Alexandria
Post reply on HN