Live data from Hacker News

Choose the browser that best suits your privacy needs

tuta.com

341–350 of 728 posts

Re: Choose the browser that best suits your privacy needs

#341

I keep seeing Edge mentioned as a worthy alternative, and I just don't get it. First, all Chromium-based browsers will eventually block uBlock Origin for the sole reason that they can't maintain Manifest v2 on their own, and they all rely on Chrome's Web Store anyway. This won't happen immediately because Manifest v2 will probably stick around for longer because of enterprise users, but the writing is on the wall. Th…

None of that is a problem in Firefox.

Re: Choose the browser that best suits your privacy needs

#342

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yeah, you're switching browsers not 3D modelling software. It's easy people. Switch to Firefox today.

I don't use 3D modeling software, but I use a browser for like... 95% of my day. Any minor UX differences are going to be like nails on a chalkboard, given that. It's no wonder why people don't want to switch, really.

I went from Netscape to IE to Firefox to Chrome and back to Firefox. Sure they're different, but it's not jarring. It's like switching to another car. You can just hop in and drive away. Then you gradually adjust the seat just how you like it and install your favorite air freshener in a natural progression, and so on.

Re: Choose the browser that best suits your privacy needs

#343
post #298

I really, really want to switch from Vivaldi to Firefox, but I am just too accustomed to the workflow. The interface is too slick and it "just works". I use vertical tabs with different workspaces, and although I am aware I can do it with extensions or userchrome in Firefox, I've found both variants pretty rough and unpolished -- and I don't have the time and energy to polish stuff that bothers me. The biggest questi…

I've used Tree Style Tab before and switched to Sidebery (https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/sidebery/). Never used Vivaldi, but you might want to give that a try. It works well in combination with container tabs.

Re: Choose the browser that best suits your privacy needs

#344

My main issue with Firefox is the unavailability of a decent profile switching. I know there's some hacky way to get the profile system done, but it is not comparable with Chrome's current profile-switching

Won't container tabs fit your use case?

Not the same thing. I want them to be completely separate, just like Chrome profile.

Re: Choose the browser that best suits your privacy needs

#347
post #259

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> It amazes me how quick people jump to something especially when it has a big company behind advertising it. Because it works . Advertising works. That's the bane of the conflict of interest between companies and users of Ad blockers. We (technical users) cannot complain that companies should not use and abuse Ads, because at the same time we (humanity as a collective) constantly show once and again that Ads do work…

> We (technical users) cannot complain that companies should not use and abuse Ads, because at the same time we (humanity as a collective) constantly show once and again that Ads do work excellently for their intended purpose. Just because something works, doesn't mean you should do it. Using a gun or knife to threaten someone with death if they don't hand over their wallet works. Do you think people should complain/…

It was just a short phrase, but was meant to refer to conversations here in HN (or anywhere ads are discussed) where it's easy to see claims about how ads are a cancer and companies "should not" use them and find a different business model.

Which I agree, but as long as society doesn't consider it harmful enough to ban it on Law (like the other activities you mentioned are), there's no reason (save the moral one) for a company to change practices. The incentives are just not there.

I definitely agree we should keep complaining. But at the same time, until things have changed radically, it would be foolish to expect that these complaints will achieve anything at all. Votes and such, that works much better!

Re: Choose the browser that best suits your privacy needs

#348

I keep seeing Edge mentioned as a worthy alternative, and I just don't get it. First, all Chromium-based browsers will eventually block uBlock Origin for the sole reason that they can't maintain Manifest v2 on their own, and they all rely on Chrome's Web Store anyway. This won't happen immediately because Manifest v2 will probably stick around for longer because of enterprise users, but the writing is on the wall. Th…

> they can't maintain Manifest v2 on their own The code for manifest v2 is really very simple (when you know that functionality for manifest v3 must remain available) - maintenance of it as an unmerged patch would be pretty straightforward. I suspect such a patch could be just 10's of lines of code - you're simply changing the condition list under which a web request can be blocking or not.

Isn't it about keeping the manifest v2 API running?

Re: Choose the browser that best suits your privacy needs

#349
I use Chrome profiles to separate my work and personal (and other) identities. This is helpful per se, but of course especially helpful because my different identities have different Google accounts.

Last time I looked, Firefox lacked this feature. This isn't the use case for Firefox "Containers" and indeed they could not be used for it. There was something very inconvenient involving starting Firefox with different command line flags to create instances with different profiles. For this reason I could not switch to Firefox.

Re: Choose the browser that best suits your privacy needs

#350

With uBlock Origin working as it works best on Firefox, I get a 3-5 sec lag on launch [0] as it prepares the browser to block ads. With Chrome, the launch happens in an instant. I should also mention that Firefox has always had a slow start up time on my machine. While am sure there is a setting to turn the uBlock feature off, it probably won't make enough of a difference to beat Chrome's start up time. [0] https://g…

I fail to understand this line of thinking. How often are you restarting the browser that this makes any significant difference in your productivity?
Post reply on HN