Live data from Hacker News

Fake Tesla, Apple stocks have started trading on blockchains

bloomberg.com

331–340 of 361 posts

Re: Fake Tesla, Apple stocks have started trading on blockchains

#331
post #256

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's not like if hyperinflation could be avoided everything else should be fine. No, hyperinflation is a sign that the economy is grossly mismanaged, and that in turn is likely the result of desperate, incompetent government facing all sorts of economic, social and political problems. Switching to a different currency isn't going to fix a failed state, sorry.

It's an individual citizen's hedge against a poorly managed government in a country they have little choice but to be in (immigration isn't so easy if you're not born into an already prosperous, stable country to begin with). My friend from Venezuela certainly would've benefited from owning a currency that wasn't regulated by his government, which made exchanging Bolivars for external currency illegal except for thos…

Cryptocurrencies are not used as currency anywhere in the world, because they have properties that make them highly undesirable as money. People who live in countries facing monetary problems will use a foreign currency if they can, but the thing is, using a foreign currency and avoiding some of the problems of hyperinflation is just a marginal improvement, it doesn't solve 99% of the problems that these people are having.

Re: Fake Tesla, Apple stocks have started trading on blockchains

#332
post #174

Earlier quoted context omitted.

According to the Wikipedia link, bucket shops are illegal gambling. So if what this is doing isn't any different than a bucket shop... I think we'll see the same outcome.

Are they illegal everywhere though?

The spread betting companies in the UK work very much like bucket shops and are not only legal but tax free. Unlike these blockchain things they are regulated and unlikely to run off with your money.

Re: Fake Tesla, Apple stocks have started trading on blockchains

#333
post #295

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It has worked well enough for trading of physical items with dollar bills for quite some time

Until we've found better alternatives. Cash doesn't have a built-in paper trail and dispute resolution mechanism, all of which are highly desirable when doing business with unknown/not yet trustworthy entities. In many (definitely not all!) cases, transaction finality is a bug, not a feature.

You make good points on paper, but in practice (in my own life at least) I’ve almost never needed to reverse a transaction where the merchant couldn’t do it himself.

And the one time I had a dispute, Visa claimed that the transaction was out of policy somehow (timeframe, region, etc)

So no, that better alternative doesn’t favor the customer

Re: Fake Tesla, Apple stocks have started trading on blockchains

#334

Earlier quoted context omitted.

zkSNARKs are not only meant and used for cryptocurrencies. They are decades old technology but ofc they can be used for all sorts of solutions including cryptocurrencies. Maybe there are real people working on crypto problems or maybe there is some sort of Crypto winter akin to AI winter[1]. Let's take Satoshi for example a top notch computer scientist and a top notch C++ programmer. Who is even close to him? Vitalik…

> zkSNARKs are not only meant and used for cryptocurrencies. They are decades old technology but ofc they can be used for all sorts of solutions including cryptocurrencies. Yes, but their current popularity (and the reason why so much effort is put into this subfield of cryptological research these days) is most likely due to their use in the context of cryptocurrencies, as far as I can tell. If I'm wrong, please let…

OK....most big-shots are not working in the field.

I'm trying to argue that blockchain/crypto industry is amateur and infant and you think I work in such industry and scam people around. I mean c'mon!

Re: Fake Tesla, Apple stocks have started trading on blockchains

#335

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> zkSNARKs are not only meant and used for cryptocurrencies. They are decades old technology but ofc they can be used for all sorts of solutions including cryptocurrencies. Yes, but their current popularity (and the reason why so much effort is put into this subfield of cryptological research these days) is most likely due to their use in the context of cryptocurrencies, as far as I can tell. If I'm wrong, please let…

OK....most big-shots are not working in the field. I'm trying to argue that blockchain/crypto industry is amateur and infant and you think I work in such industry and scam people around. I mean c'mon!

I think you may have misinterpreted my last phrase (it was not an attempt at insulting you or calling you a scammer at all).

I'll rephrase it: "It's almost as if, if one is working in something blockchain-related, one must be a bad professional somehow (or, worse, a scammer)."

I don't disagree that the field is filled with amateurs (and, yes, scammers). It still doesn't imply that there isn't any serious cryptological research being done within the (so-called) field of "blockchain", which was the argument I originally replied to.

Re: Fake Tesla, Apple stocks have started trading on blockchains

#336
post #156

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You could technically buy real shares and sell synthetic shares on the blockchain, harvesting the price difference. This would generally have the same effect as the blockchain user buying the stock directly, but through an intermediary collecting premium.

Why stop there, you could buy real shares, sell synthetic ones, and then sell the real shares, too. Or just sell synthetic shares without having any real shares in the first place. This seems like a case where a blockhain doesn't really do much good.

Selling the real shares as well as the synthetic is really just going naked short. Lots of risk/leverage. You have to put up collateral so that you have something to lose if it goes bad

Re: Fake Tesla, Apple stocks have started trading on blockchains

#337
post #331

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's an individual citizen's hedge against a poorly managed government in a country they have little choice but to be in (immigration isn't so easy if you're not born into an already prosperous, stable country to begin with). My friend from Venezuela certainly would've benefited from owning a currency that wasn't regulated by his government, which made exchanging Bolivars for external currency illegal except for thos…

Cryptocurrencies are not used as currency anywhere in the world, because they have properties that make them highly undesirable as money. People who live in countries facing monetary problems will use a foreign currency if they can, but the thing is, using a foreign currency and avoiding some of the problems of hyperinflation is just a marginal improvement, it doesn't solve 99% of the problems that these people are h…

My knowledge of the usage and value and improvement on quality of life for people using cryotocurrency in nations experiencing massive hyperinflation come from one of my closest friends from Venezuela, who I talk to every week for hours (I'm sitting next to him right now as I type this).

Where does yours come from? Because what you're saying directly contradicts his reported experiences for both him and relatives and friends of his. I'm sure you have an equally credible source on the ground of at least a comparable market that informs your view on what does and doesn't affect the lives of people in those countries?

To your point, many Venezuelans do store their wealth in Crypto, and only convert the amount they need to spend that day to Bolivars. That is the use case.

Re: Fake Tesla, Apple stocks have started trading on blockchains

#338
post #283

Earlier quoted context omitted.

How do stocks that never pay a dividend settle?

Companies hold assets, cash flow and perform real world activities that have a tangible value. There are multiple ways that value can be realised. Aside from speculative investors which were discussing, companies and individuals can buy shares in order to exert strategic influence over the company for their own reasons, so the shares have a value to them beyond just the share price. For example the way Microsoft owne…

I'm not talking about the existence of economic value, but of settlement. So there is no settlement except at an indefinite transaction event -- not even under your control if they're non-voting shares, i.e. "whenever".

Re: Fake Tesla, Apple stocks have started trading on blockchains

#339
post #283

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Companies hold assets, cash flow and perform real world activities that have a tangible value. There are multiple ways that value can be realised. Aside from speculative investors which were discussing, companies and individuals can buy shares in order to exert strategic influence over the company for their own reasons, so the shares have a value to them beyond just the share price. For example the way Microsoft owne…

I'm not talking about the existence of economic value, but of settlement. So there is no settlement except at an indefinite transaction event -- not even under your control if they're non-voting shares, i.e. "whenever".

True, it's not scheduled, but it's more common than a lot of people think, for a public company to be bought out. And the shareholders don't get to arbitrarily hold out, either.

Re: Fake Tesla, Apple stocks have started trading on blockchains

#340

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Isn't it also weird that crypto enthusiasts assume that you obviously can't trust a central clearing house (or similar mechanism) when they have been working well for hundreds of years? In numerous cases humans trust institutions for certain things, and those institutions are usually strongly incentivized to act honorably, and do so. And when they don't, the court system works pretty well. At least in the countries w…

This obviously doesn't hold up if we look at the original purpose of the blockchain, ie Bitcoin, to avoid issuers of money to debase said money. Which has in fact happened thousands of times through out history and keeps happening to this very minute.

Perhaps I should have said "de-fi" instead of "crypto" ?
Post reply on HN