Live data from Hacker News

Separate the cord from the device

bookofjoe2.blogspot.com

31–40 of 52 posts

Re: Separate the cord from the device

#31

One very practical reason that comes to mind is waterproofing. Kitchen counters get wet, and office desks do not. Anything with a plug is at greater risk of shorting.

https://www.sunbeam.ca/en_CA/kitchen-appliances/sunbeam-1.7l...

A plugged-in kettle is not as likely to fall into a bowl of water as a hand mixer.

Re: Separate the cord from the device

#32
post #19

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Also product liability. If you give a domestic hair dryer a 12 ft cord, someone will use it in the shower. If you give an insta-pot a 6 ft cord, someone will drape it off the counter and a child will pull it. UL standards actually limit cable length for many appliances. https://www.intertek.com/standards-updates/ul-1026-electrica...

I believe you can't put an outlet on the side of a kitchen island anymore because too many toddlers were able to grab an appliance by the cable and pull it down onto their heads. In the USA at least.

This is understandable, not easy to fix, and deeply frustrating for people who don't have or intend to get toddlers.

Re: Separate the cord from the device

#33
post #13

As much as I truly love replaceable cords, I'd be more than happy enough if I could just unscrew the shell of the device, unscrew the power wires from where they attach, and put in any cord. Where I care about waterproofing, some silicone caulk is an extremely cheap (and removable) fix. Unfortunately practically everything you can buy now is welded plastic halves, or easily-broken clips. So even when you might be abl…

Right: There's a spectrum of choice here, it's not as binary as "you must throw away the whole device if the cable breaks" versus "conveniently detachable with two fingertips or a light breeze."

You mentioned waterproofing, and I think another major factor is how often the device (and indirectly the cable) is going to be moved around, and which stresses and strains will be placed on the connection. What's best for my printer is not what's best for an immersion-blender.

Re: Separate the cord from the device

#36

One very practical reason that comes to mind is waterproofing. Kitchen counters get wet, and office desks do not. Anything with a plug is at greater risk of shorting.

https://www.sunbeam.ca/en_CA/kitchen-appliances/sunbeam-1.7l...

I tried to figure out how to buy that exact kettle recently because I typically store mine away in a cupboard (and so a "cordless" kettle with separate base is just an annoyance to me) and couldn't find it anywhere.

I had to settle for a Proctor-Silex branded unit that was only sold by Home Depot online. It does not have a detachable cord.

Re: Separate the cord from the device

#37
post #35

Detachable cables should honestly be standard on most kitchen appliances. Once you’ve experienced it on PCs and monitors, fixed cables just feel outdated.

I'm not sure if it's a full standard (eg UL), or an informal one, but one reason you might not want detachable cords on kitchen appliances is because the cords are intentionally short to avoid dangerous accidents. If cords are swappable, you lose this property.

There have been enough Crockpots and similar kitchen appliances pulled down by children onto themselves that it's driven two trends in the American kitchen:

- Short power cords, to avoid cords being accessible from below

- Placement of power outlets: to ensure there are enough to be used with the short cords and not tempt extension cord usage, and to keep outlets and cords plugged into them inaccessable.

There's a lot of tension in that last one, and the NEC has gone back and forth on how to regulate outlet placement, eg on kitchen islands, and where they should be allowed to go.

Re: Separate the cord from the device

#38
post #22

Headphones are a big one for me. By their nature, the cords are often going to get snagged and tugged on and are pretty much guaranteed to fail before the headset itself does. I'm pretty happy my current Sennheiser headphones have detachable headphone cables, though the shaky ground the company itself is on makes me wonder if I should stock up on a few...

My $300 Sennheisers have a detachable cable. My son's $99 Sennheisers have a detachable cable. My $25 almost-noname headphones have a detachable cable.

I think a detachable cable is a widespread option, as long as the headphones are large enough to make accomodating it easy.

Re: Separate the cord from the device

#39
post #18

I’m a big fan of this notion. My hot water dispenser has a magnetic power dongle kinda like macbooks MagSafe, but bulkier [0]. Ideally something like that would be more standardized across appliances the way some of the other three prong power cords are. [0]: https://youtu.be/E2WrHHRYrV4?t=108

I loved having one of these until the non-stick coating inside started flaking off badly after a couple years. Nowadays I'm only touching steel and/or glass on these things. An all-steel-interior Zwilling kettle has lasted me twice as long already, and looks brand new (on the inside) if I give it a brief acid cleanse to remove deposits. It's not quite as convenient or as stable temperature, but I'm more than happy to…

Two-layer, thermopot-style kettles are a thing; I own one. All-steel interior is a natural consequence.

Re: Separate the cord from the device

#40
post #39
post #18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I loved having one of these until the non-stick coating inside started flaking off badly after a couple years. Nowadays I'm only touching steel and/or glass on these things. An all-steel-interior Zwilling kettle has lasted me twice as long already, and looks brand new (on the inside) if I give it a brief acid cleanse to remove deposits. It's not quite as convenient or as stable temperature, but I'm more than happy to…

Two-layer, thermopot-style kettles are a thing; I own one. All-steel interior is a natural consequence.

What brand? I couldn't find any last time I looked, and I do generally prefer the dispenser style (slower to hit a temp, but rock solid once there, and basically always ready to go. surprisingly useful / habit-altering).
Post reply on HN