Live data from Hacker News

People Drawn to Conspiracy Theories Share Psychological Features (2019)

scientificamerican.com

31–34 of 34 posts

Re: People Drawn to Conspiracy Theories Share Psychological Features (2019)

#31
post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Conspiracy: An agreement to perform together an illegal, wrongful, or subversive act. Insofar as 2 or more people have coordinated, colluded, or planned an illegal, wrongful, or subversive act, a conspiracy is afoot. In fact, almost all significant illegal, wrongful, or subversive acts include conspiracies to commit said acts. I think it is safe to say that the present sociopolitical and socioeconomic landscapes are…

Yes, there are a lot of conspiracies, but "Three may keep a secret, if two of them are dead;" so if a conspiracy involves enough actors, it is unlikely that it will be kept secret from the public except from some lunatic fringe.

This is a common trope paraded by conspiracy perpetrators. “Do you really think we could keep something like that secret?”

Also, it doesn’t have to be secret to be a conspiracy.

Fossil fuel companies more or less openly conspired to obfuscate, deny, discredit, and discourage evidence from their own scientists and the scientific community at large that fossil fuel use could cause significant heating and possible thermal runaway of the planetary climate for over 70 years in order to continue to exploit fossil fuels which they knew to pose a threat to human civilisation as a whole.

Cigarette companies acted similarly. Automotive companies have done similar things many times over.

Naively believing that collective human incompetence makes effective obfuscation impossible ignores a great many examples of successful collusion and implies a very naive optimism about the information dissemination mechanisms within society.

It is more plausible that collective human incompetence makes perfect secrecy unnecessary.

Re: People Drawn to Conspiracy Theories Share Psychological Features (2019)

#32
post #31

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yes, there are a lot of conspiracies, but "Three may keep a secret, if two of them are dead;" so if a conspiracy involves enough actors, it is unlikely that it will be kept secret from the public except from some lunatic fringe.

This is a common trope paraded by conspiracy perpetrators. “Do you really think we could keep something like that secret?” Also, it doesn’t have to be secret to be a conspiracy. Fossil fuel companies more or less openly conspired to obfuscate, deny, discredit, and discourage evidence from their own scientists and the scientific community at large that fossil fuel use could cause significant heating and possible therm…

> Fossil fuel companies...

And we know about it. The documents were leaked and uncovered by lawsuits.

> Cigarette companies acted similarly

And again, we know about it.

> Naively believing that collective human incompetence makes effective obfuscation impossible ignores a great many examples of successful collusion

Where? It's not incompetence. Every actor is facing a prisoner's dilemma, and at least one will act rationally and squeal on the rest.

Re: People Drawn to Conspiracy Theories Share Psychological Features (2019)

#33

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yes, there are a lot of conspiracies, but "Three may keep a secret, if two of them are dead;" so if a conspiracy involves enough actors, it is unlikely that it will be kept secret from the public except from some lunatic fringe.

This is a common misconception. The US system of state secrets for example is enormous, and while leaks do occur, they are negligible compared to what is kept hidden. There are multiple tricks employable, one is to keep any single collaborator in the dark aboout most of the conspiracy. That way, any single leak is manageable. Your conviction of believing conspiracies to be unrealistic is common and helps conspirators…

> The US system of state secrets for example is enormous, and while leaks do occur, they are negligible compared to what is kept hidden.

Not from those whose job it is to find them. The Manhattan Project leaked to the Soviets multiple times over. Any time the government does something illegal, a whistleblower has leaked it to reporters.

Re: People Drawn to Conspiracy Theories Share Psychological Features (2019)

#34
post #30

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Society is full of real, actual conspiracies and collusion that are harmful to people, whether they’re currently illegal or not. It’s just that the people promoting what popular media refers to as “conspiracy theory” throw enormous resources at distracting from those substantive issues by focusing on 5G, microchips in vaccines, chemtrails, and various silly theories of secret cabals running the world. If I was one of…

Also, 5g vaccine chemtrails is my next band name.

I can't wait to see how your fans search for you on the web.
Post reply on HN