Live data from Hacker News

Microsoft's Growing Control of Linux

lunduke.substack.com

31–37 of 37 posts

Re: Microsoft's Growing Control of Linux

#31

Github was scary enough just as a monolith of FOSS code. In microsoft's hands, it's terrifying: they have shown lack of integrity in the past that makes their current professions (and examples!) of civilized behavior suspect. Is your project dead or is it just that Github et all the PR's others sent? Is your project discoverable there or is it buried in irrelevant search results? Could Microsoft open some of their ol…

Microsoft GW-Basic https://github.com/microsoft/GW-BASIC

Re: Microsoft's Growing Control of Linux

#32

Github was scary enough just as a monolith of FOSS code. In microsoft's hands, it's terrifying: they have shown lack of integrity in the past that makes their current professions (and examples!) of civilized behavior suspect. Is your project dead or is it just that Github et all the PR's others sent? Is your project discoverable there or is it buried in irrelevant search results? Could Microsoft open some of their ol…

Microsoft 3D Movie Maker:

https://lunduke.substack.com/p/microsoft-open-sources-1995s-...

https://github.com/microsoft/Microsoft-3D-Movie-Maker

Re: Microsoft's Growing Control of Linux

#33

Github was scary enough just as a monolith of FOSS code. In microsoft's hands, it's terrifying: they have shown lack of integrity in the past that makes their current professions (and examples!) of civilized behavior suspect. Is your project dead or is it just that Github et all the PR's others sent? Is your project discoverable there or is it buried in irrelevant search results? Could Microsoft open some of their ol…

Outside of Microsoft created QB64:

- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/QB64

- https://lunduke.substack.com/p/the-wild-events-that-nearly-t...

Outside of Microsoft created Visual Basic IDE:

- http://gambas.sourceforge.net/en/main.html

- https://github.com/wekan/hx/tree/main/prototypes/ui/gambas

Outside of Microsoft created FreeBasic:

- https://freebasic.net

Re: Microsoft's Growing Control of Linux

#34
post #24
post #16

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Wayland being a requirement sounds like a sound choice in terms of maintenance and the issues of X itself. Applications don't need to update to GTK5.

What are these issues of X? Because everyone talks about the issues of X, but Gnome, KDE, Xfce and others run flawless on X, but these same desktops have problems when running on Wayland.

X has some fundamental security issues:

https://security.stackexchange.com/questions/4641/why-are-pe...

The lack of problems on X and the problems on Wayland are mostly an issue of maturity.

Re: Microsoft's Growing Control of Linux

#35
post #5
post #3

There's an enduring belief in the Linux community that the reason the year of the Linux desktop hasn't come about has nothing to do with lack of stable ABI, API, murky processes of app distribution, inaccessible development processes, basic functionality like graphics acceleration or audio being dodgy for decades, but is exclusively due to dastardly machinations of Micro$oft (with a dollar sign of course, as other, t…

The article never mentions Linux on the desktop.

I think it is implied - I mean why else would one be fearmongering about big bad Microsoft?

The server? - The vast majority of the server market runs Linux - including much of Azure. Likewise there's no presence of Windows in the handheld market (I'm not sure if this counts as a win for Linux, since Android is barely Linux).

Re: Microsoft's Growing Control of Linux

#36

> “Linux is a cancer that attaches itself in an intellectual property sense to everything it touches.” — Microsoft CEO, Steve Ballmer > Just the same, over the last few years, Microsoft has invested heavily in obtaining control over key portions of the Linux (and, to some degree, open source) ecosystem. This seems incredibly disingenuous. The article is implying there's a smooth continuity between these two sentences…

> they haven't released a special version of Git that only works with Visual Studio or VsCode, etc

They _have_ released special versions of VS Code's C++, C#, and Python tools that only work with Microsoft-sanctioned binaries. [1][2]

They also ripped out a .NET feature at the last minute because they wanted to keep it exclusive to Visual Studio. [3]

[1] https://www.reddit.com/r/linux/comments/k0s8qw/vs_code_devel...

[2] https://github.com/VSCodium/vscodium/blob/master/DOCS.md#pro...

[3] https://www.theverge.com/2021/10/22/22740701/microsoft-dotne...

Re: Microsoft's Growing Control of Linux

#37
post #27

> “Linux is a cancer that attaches itself in an intellectual property sense to everything it touches.” — Microsoft CEO, Steve Ballmer > Just the same, over the last few years, Microsoft has invested heavily in obtaining control over key portions of the Linux (and, to some degree, open source) ecosystem. This seems incredibly disingenuous. The article is implying there's a smooth continuity between these two sentences…

Microsoft begins "Extinguish" phase of dealing with Open Source: https://lunduke.substack.com/p/microsoft-begins-extinguish-p...

From the linked article:

> On June 16th, Microsoft updated the policy for the Microsoft store to include the following restriction for all software sold: “to prohibit charging fees in the Store for open-source or other software that is generally available for free”

The obvious non-evil interpretation is that this policy is intended to stop scalpers who eg sell Mozilla Firefox on Windows Store.

See also this tweet: https://twitter.com/gisardo/status/1545473811226705922

> On June 16, we shared a policy aimed to protect customers from misleading listings,in effect from July 16. In listening to dev community,we got feedback it could be perceived differently than intended.We'll delay enforcement of that policy until we clarify the intent. Stay tuned.

Of course the GM posting this could be lying and the intent could be to specifically harm open-source, but... that doesn't seem likely given the evidence we have?

As evidence that Microsoft is doing "Extinguish", this is very thin.

Post reply on HN