Live data from Hacker News

Success depends on emotion management

muratbuffalo.blogspot.com

31–40 of 58 posts

Re: Success depends on emotion management

#32

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Reminds me of reading a story someone wrote about the epiphany they had when their therapist finally told them "the world does not wake up in the morning to fuck you "

Many of live in a country with a long history of laws written explicitly for that purpose.

Running a demoralization campaign on youngsters is unlikely to improve things, though.

Would there be an Israel today if Jewish people convinced themselves that the world is forever going to hate and subjugate them and that they are powerless to change it?

They could have done so, after all, the Holocaust was an unspeakable evil. But they chose the path of constructive defiance.

Re: Success depends on emotion management

#33
post #22

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Because "your attitude determines your success" explicitly states that if you fail it is because of your attitude. People fail for many reasons, usually a combination of reasons. Attitude is just one factor. It is very comforting for people who are high on the social ladder to believe in a meritocracy: it lets one their successes are due to their superior character, and those who are on the bottom of the ladder are t…

It doesn't say anything about the inverse. You can simultaneously believe success is determined by yourself and failures are just bad luck. It's positive thinking. Some enjoy it, some don't.

> It doesn't say anything about the inverse.

Interpreted as a literal propositional statement, it's saying "if you have a good attitude, then you will have success". Therefore if you do not have success, it must be because you did not have a good attitude, which is your fault. It's the contrapositive, right?

Re: Success depends on emotion management

#34
This article seems like a big maybe to me. Attitudes are contagious and are more observed than one may realize. I work on a platform team, many of our sibling teams wield the power and influence of being a platform team with the grace of an angry third grader with crayons and a blank wall. The angry third grader really used to get to me and people could see (whether I directly told them or not) that they had affected me in some type of way. These days, the self that I bring to work is more like a git clone --depth 1, and as a result the angry third grader exercises much less power over me.

I discovered that my colleagues notice me far more than I notice myself. I was reminded of this when I came back from a meeting with one platform team that has treated us with notable hostility; they frequently would backtrack statements and commitments that weren't recorded or logged, they would make up requirements on the spot after requirements had already been agreed on, etc... That's the flavor of team these folks were - everyone at the company knows it too. I was not able to get them to budge and it was more expedient and better for our users at this point if we just did what they wanted rather than the full vision. My peers asked what happened, I smiled, and said, "Well, I wasn't able to convince them to do everything, but we'll make do and continue to plan for the future as long as it benefits our users." In a one-on-one is when I was made aware of how my peers observe me, most of them remarked on my stoicism and the fact that it didn't deter me. The fact is that it does, I don't like disorganization that becomes nearly undecipherable from gas lighting, I don't like having goal posts moved, and I don't like organizations that are supposed to be constantly in pursuit of making users lives better thinking stagnation is a strategy. Having projects cancelled affects my promotion prospects, it wastes time/money/energy, etc... I feel some type of way about all of these things.

From my sample size of self, I think the article is right but more in a way that perception matters and you're either the type of person that has to:

- git clone self --depth 1

- tell yourself fanciful stories

Re: Success depends on emotion management

#35
post #2

Please can people stop using absolutist epithets like this. Managing your attitude, emotions, and the stories you tell yourself will help a lot . If you do it badly, it will increase your chances of failure. Doing it well will not determine your success. That’s just magical thinking. It will predispose you for success if the other conditions are right for it , but nothing more.

There are millions of people having such problems with motivation, attitude and experience lack of success, so these kind of blogs give them exactly what they want to hear. I wasted ton of time on such publications as I was under impression that if only I change my thinking then suddenly I'll get on right track. Unfortunately it doesn't work like that. What helped me the most is realising that making mistakes is just…

>millions of people having such problems with motivation

Presumably the clicks are why such pointless articles continue to be written.

Re: Success depends on emotion management

#36
This is blogspam written by someone who lacks the credentials to write it. Let's assume success pertains to careers, or achievements in the real world. Your judgment, decisions, timing and environment determine your success. There are an exceptional amount of folks with foul attitudes who are immensely successful. There are also an exceptional amount of folks with great attitudes who remain destitute and unsuccessful.

So to imply any kind of causal link stronger than a weak one between attitude and success is self-help nonsense. Having a workable attitude is a necessary but not sufficient condition. It does nothing to help you service the actual hard work and growth necessary to reach success.

EDIT: My, how this once mighty forum has fallen to the internet marketers, huh? Downvote away. I am happy to burn my internet points criticizing this dreck.

Re: Success depends on emotion management

#38
post #2

Please can people stop using absolutist epithets like this. Managing your attitude, emotions, and the stories you tell yourself will help a lot . If you do it badly, it will increase your chances of failure. Doing it well will not determine your success. That’s just magical thinking. It will predispose you for success if the other conditions are right for it , but nothing more.

What is "Success" actually?

financial, intellectual achievements over time?

I think living happy, healthily, in simplicity is success

In that case, I'd agree with the title

Post reply on HN