Live data from Hacker News

Robinhood apparently selling people's shares ”for their own good“

twitter.com

31–35 of 35 posts

Re: Robinhood apparently selling people's shares ”for their own good“

#31

These are probably margin calls for people trading on margin which is 100% legal and the risk you take when trading on margin.

that would explain a lot, this tweet looks a LOT past the line what I would expect them to do.

though there's also this screenshot: https://twitter.com/555Sunny/status/1354854993946406917?s=20

can anyone confirm if this is actually happening or if this is what margin trades at robinhood look like?

Re: Robinhood apparently selling people's shares ”for their own good“

#32

Robinhood is a private company and can manage their platform as they see fit.

Well that's just not true at all. Being a private company doesn't magically exempt one from things like laws and regulatory oversight and all the rest of that.

Works for Facebook and others.

Re: Robinhood apparently selling people's shares ”for their own good“

#33
They didn't sell people's shares technically speaking. If you bought shares on margins or options they closed out, and you didn't have excess finances, your positions because they felt you were a risk to yourself. Still really messed up and them doing it when the price was at it's lowest feels illegal, sadly they can bend you over a table all they want because of their t.o.s.

Re: Robinhood apparently selling people's shares ”for their own good“

#34
post #2

what on earth?!?! I can understand mandatory liquidation due to margin requirements. But AFAIK those don't show up as "orders" on your account that you can see in time to try to cancel.

I’d guess that this must be a margin account. In that case the broker is perfectly entitled to liquidate positions that they consider too volatile and risky. If it’s a cash account, then yes, they’d have no right to do this. I’m no lawyer, but I’d assume you’d very likely be able to sue them for any losses.

This was happening with people's "instant deposit" which is actually margins. The problem is that it only initiates and covers an actual cash deposit, making people think it's a cash buy.

The reason it looks like a normal order is because it Robinhood makes it look like one, as it becomes a cash purchase once the funds and purchase settle

Re: Robinhood apparently selling people's shares ”for their own good“

#35

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Thank you. This WSB GameStop phenomenon is one of the most poisonous news stories I've seen in the history of the web. It seems to induce irrationality and melodrama as though it were a psychedelic drug.

Maybe for you it's a news story, but for many of us it's a revolution.

You should be wary of any revolution based on giving up all your money.
Post reply on HN