Live data from Hacker News

Roma's Wounding Confession

churchlife.nd.edu

31–35 of 35 posts

Re: Roma's Wounding Confession

#31

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I grew up in Latin America, so I guess I can give you some context about some of this stuff. I am not going to defend the entertainment value of the movie, because I personally found it pretty boring (I guess the voyeuristic value isn't there for me, having grown up in a similar environment). > It sets the tone for the movie’s aesthetic and hollows it out, reducing Cuarón’s worthwhile intentions and evident passions…

> If Cuarón's experience was always defined by a very simple interface (that of the "sirvienta" or "mucama"), then it's understandable that his version of her is a muted - one could say desaturated - version of the real person That's just rationalizing away the fact that the film's subject was poorly handled by the film's director. Someone else - and I'm not suggesting that has to be someone whose experiences more cl…

> but dramatically, a miss.

Well, I cried like a baby at the scene at the beach.

Re: Roma's Wounding Confession

#32

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> If Cuarón's experience was always defined by a very simple interface (that of the "sirvienta" or "mucama"), then it's understandable that his version of her is a muted - one could say desaturated - version of the real person That's just rationalizing away the fact that the film's subject was poorly handled by the film's director. Someone else - and I'm not suggesting that has to be someone whose experiences more cl…

> but dramatically, a miss. Well, I cried like a baby at the scene at the beach.

[deleted]

Re: Roma's Wounding Confession

#33
post #26

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Thanks for taking the time to share your thoughts. In retrospect I didn’t think much of Children of Men or Gravity either, and I can’t even remember what I thought of Y Tu Mamá También, so it apparently didn’t leave much impression on me. Maybe he’s just not my cup of tea. My upset with Roma was given how critically acclaimed it is, I was expecting a lot more. I appreciate your perspective but I still don’t think the…

Let me guess! You probably think the great gatsby is a classic.

The book is by definition a classic. The movie is not my favorite of Baz Luhrmann's. What's this got to do with Roma?

Speaking of Great Gatsby, I did enjoy Burning.

The Princess Bride... now that’s a classic.

Post reply on HN